Manisha - Page 5

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Debayon Dutta

@debayon

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#41

Originally posted by: ZoobiDoobi

she is doing something relating to Music Degree....forgot what it was.

Yes, she is doing a degree in Music, but that does not automatically mean that she has learnt music and is experienced in that field.

Quote

Zubi

@ZoobiDoobi

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: debayon
Yes, she is doing a degree in Music, but that does not automatically mean that she has learnt music and is experienced in that field.

OH okkkkkkkk i might b wrong then. but she sang Sole Miya so well that u can't believe its her singing these days.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

somone999

@somone999

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#43

Don't know what happened to her after such an outstanding performance of Solemiya. She looks so confused when she is on stage now. She seems to have lost her confidence after that bad performance. She still has another chance of proving herself. I hope she does that.

Quote

babli1

@babli1

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

#44

dabulls di, i totally agree...Manisha needs to go...she thinks she looks great and great personality and so that thing gets reflected in her singing...one week someone can be bad but not repeatedly....

Quote

xobile

@xobile

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#45

Originally posted by: JaspalToronto
you are too funny paheli, but I feel sorry for this talented girl. I wish her to survive next week.

My thoughts exactly!

Quote

Debayon Dutta

@debayon

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#46

Originally posted by: xobile

My thoughts exactly!

I admit that it is entirely her fault, 110%, but for some odd reason, I believe that luck was not with her and what followed was a series of unfortunate events. I mean, she has done so well unitl her previous 2 perfomances.😕

Quote

Dabulls23

@Dabulls23

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#47

Originally posted by: debayon
I admit that it is entirely her fault, 110%, but for some odd reason, I believe that luck was not with her and what followed was a series of unfortunate events. I mean, she has done so well unitl her previous 2 perfomances.😕

Lets be honest how many performances totally has she had since auditions??? Last 2 out of how many?? How many has she done well in II 5??? you will get atleast 40-50% of the time she was horrible...how do we equate bad performance into luck was not with her that day...😳

I dont want anyone making excuses for bad singing...NOT you but in general....

If Vishwas has to go after giving excellent and good performances than Manisha should have been out...Hope judges save Meghna and eliminate Manisha as judges do have right to make that decision...😃

Edited by Dabulls23 - 15 years ago

Quote

kuhu.kuhu

@kuhu.kuhu

Sparkler

Posted: 15 years ago

#48

@ DB....I know Dii...what u mean ...but like many, I can't be harsh to her ...If she goes out then I would accept it ...But when she hit that 1st note in the audition one knows that she has music in her blood ....

I liked her in SRGMP too....Her Solemiyan made us more excited ..she proved she is very surili and can hit high notes with right passion and melody ...so viewers were excited as they thought she was indeed an Idol material ...

but then she was bad in 1st and 2nd galas ..her scale went haywire .....😕

Yet people think that if Tia( quivers in low notes ) and Bhumi ( falsetto in high notes) can improve and garner praises from judges then Manisha has a chance !!!!!!!!!!!!!...That's all....all this time ..in previous Idols audience kept voting besure singers who were singing bad ..thus taking them to top4 ...and ultimately win the competetion...

This time audience is voting a surili singer gone bad in early stages of gala ......I know what u mean ....U think this is not fair and u have right to think so ...But like many over here I am thinking she got another chance ...If she blows it ..she should be shown the door ...

I was thinking she would be out this time ....but now that i heard she is not ..I am heaving a sigh of relief ....

Still can't forget Vishwas's ouster though ... But i am sure he'll be back thru wc**fingers crossed***

I know u don't want to listen to this ...and I know what u r saying is ethically right ...but to me I am supporting her because I knew what she is capable of ...

sowwyy 😛

****..KDNBKD...*******

P.S ...I think Meghna couldn't connect with the audience at all..at least she couldn't connect with me ...she sang all songs as if she is in an exam...hitting all the right notes yet no passion...I am treating her like anybody else and critiquing her 'cause I know she wouldn't want her to be treated otherwise ....

omg !!!! I wrote so much😲...g'night

Edited by kuhu.kuhu - 15 years ago

Quote

Dabulls23

@Dabulls23

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#49

Originally posted by: kuhu.kuhu
@ DB....I know Dii...what u mean ...but like many, I can't be harsh to her ...If she goes out then I would accept it ...But when she hit that 1st note in the audition one knows that she has music in her blood ....

I liked her in SRGMP too....Her Solemiyan made us more excited ..she proved she is very surili and can hit high notes with right passion and melody ...so viewers were excited as they thought she was indeed an Idol material ...

but then she was bad in 1st and 2nd galas ..her scale went haywire .....😕

Yet people think that if Tia( quivers in low notes ) and Bhumi ( falsetto in high notes) can improve and garner praises from judges then Manisha has a chance !!!!!!!!!!!!!...That's all....all this time ..in previous Idols audience kept voting besure singers who were singing bad ..thus taking them to top4 ...and ultimately win the competetion...

This time audience is voting a surili singer gone bad in early stages of gala ......I know what u mean ....U think this is not fair and u have right to think so ...But like many over here I am thinking she got another chance ...If she blows it ..she should be shown the door ...

I was thinking she would be out this time ....but now that i heard she is not ..I am heaving a sigh of relief ....

Still can't forget Vishwas's ouster though ... But i am sure he'll be back thru wc**fingers crossed***

I know u don't want to listen to this ...and I know what u r saying is ethically right ...but to me I am supporting her because I knew what she is capable of ...

sowwyy 😛

****..KDNBKD...*******

Koeli u dont need to say sowee for giving your views...We all are entitled to one...

I have no problem what you are saying and I appreciate other's comments too....I am not supporter of TIA nor of Bhoomi..If they have given horrible performances send them out too..But they were not any worst than Manisha....I am not singling Manisha out...But as she was the worst of all twice in a row I really dont care she should be out...

If u go back & read I was so impressed with her first performance during auditions I think...I was hoping for some awesome renditions by her but she let us all down...I thought she might surprise me this time and make a supporter out of MOI...It has been bit disappointing to see Naushad, Manisha, and even Arpita has dropped a bit....They gave their best performances first time around and set standard high for us viewers and they are not able to keep it up...😳

may be I sound harsh to some but I am being honest here not being biased towards anyone....

Manisha should have been out and My plea to judges to keep meghna and eliminate Manisha....Only fair thing to do....No more post on Manisha from MOI unless another horrible performance I have to witness

KDNBKD 😃

Edited by Dabulls23 - 15 years ago

Quote

kuhu.kuhu

@kuhu.kuhu

Sparkler

Posted: 15 years ago

#50

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

I have no problem what you are saying and I appreciate other's comments too....I am not supporter of TIA nor of Bhoomi..If they have horrible performances send them out too..I am not singling Manisha out...But as she was the worst of all twice in a row I really dont care she should be out...

If u go back I was so impressed with her first performance during auditions I think...I was hoping for some awesome renditions by her but she let us all down...

may be I sound harsh to some but I am being honest here not being biased towards anyone....

Nope ..u don't sound harsh ...and I know ur taste ...we have been in this far too many times to understand what we expect from a musical show like this ...But I differed from ur point and if I have to comment in this thread I have to say what I feel😛 ....I just can't lie ...can I ??😉.....

We agree most of the times ...but here we disagree on one point ....u think Manisha doesn't deserve a chance and u r not happy that she got one and I say agree she doesn't but i am glad she got one 😃

truce !!!!!!!!!!!!!...and I added something about Meghna too😉...

Goodness gracious ..it's 1 am ...chalo chalte hai ...aarrey...shreeram, Shivam, Shashi, Naushad, Arpita ke ke baare mein toh hum agree kartey hai naa ???😛...specially the 1st 3 ....bas...

see ya .....

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 6

Manisha - Page 5

Related Topics

Explore Topics