18th May Performance... Rank the top 13 - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

3.4k

Users

16

Likes

12

Frequent Posters

prafulb thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#11
based purely on first gala
Excellent, Fabulous,👏
1) Sreeram
2) Arpita


Good 😊
3) Swaroop
4) Shivam & Vishwas
6) Yashraj (attitude is a put-off, but yes he is a good singer and thats what matters)

Could do better , I guess 😕
7) Naushad (Not sure why judges selected him in top 3 for this week)
8) Meghna (For her attempt to sing a Lata song)
9) Shashi ( I know he can do much much better)
10) Bhoomi ( Wondering if she on Mauli's track ?)
11) Manisha (what happened to her ? I am sure she is way better than this)
12) Rakesh (he deserves one more chance)
13) Tia (she has the x-factor though)

I think Tia should leave, but I guess Rakesh will be the one that might be sacrificed
Khushi. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#12
My Ranking for Gala 1 is-
1)Shashi Suman
2)Bhoomi Trivedi
3)Shivam Pathak
4)Yashraj Kapil
5)Naushad
6)Arpita Khan
7)Swaroop
8)Rakesh Maini
9)Meghna
10)Vishwas
11)Tia
12)Manisha
P.S- I missed out ShreeRam's performance , so Didnt rank him.😳
Edited by Uniquechoices - 15 years ago
somone999 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: slumdog

1.Sriram

2.Arpita
3.Shivam
4.Naushad
5.Swaroop
6.Vishwas
7.Bhoomi
8.Rakesh
9.Yasraj
10.Meghna
11.Shashi
12.Tia
13.Manisha



I agree with this list. So, Ditto!!
kuhu.kuhu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#14
O.kk ....here is my list...........
Arpita
Sreeram
Vishwas
Shivam
Yashraj( I know I will be getting bouquets from some and brick bats fom others ...but ohh well)😆
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Manisha ( though I think she is a fantastic singer but her song was so off sur that I am not hesitant to give her the last spot )
Rest can be filled in the middle in any order ...all of them fell short of at least in one department badly according to moi...whether it's soul or sur or expressions .😃
shivani9 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: kuhu.kuhu

O.kk ....here is my list...........

Arpita
Sreeram
Vishwas
Shivam
Yashraj( I know I will be getting bouquets from some and brick bats fom others ...but ohh well)😆
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Manisha ( though I think she is a fantastic singer but her song was so off sur that I am not hesitant to give her the last spot )
Rest can be filled in the middle in any order ...all of them fell short of at least in one department badly according to moi...whether it's soul or sur or expressions .😃



😆....well for me Sreeram and Arpita stand at number 1
Vishwas
Naushad
Rakesh
Shivam
Swaroop

...rest no comments about priority..


sunaina02 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#16
For me ... ( strictly based on Gala performance)
Arpita
SreeRam
Naushad
Swaroop
Shashi
Viswas
Shivam
Meghna
.......
Rest of the boys - I dont find interesting at all .
The other girls Tia, Bhumi and Manisha are not versatile ones and concentrate more in dressing and stage performance than in actual singing .
Twitz thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#17
1. Shivam
2.Yash Raj
3.Sree Ram
4. Nausad
5, Arpita
6.Swaroop
7.Rakesh
9.Viswas
10.Shashi
11.Meghna
12.Bhoomi
13.Tia
kuhu.kuhu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: Twitz

1. Shivam

2.Yash Raj
3.Sree Ram
4. Nausad
5, Arpita
6.Swaroop
7.Rakesh
9.Viswas
10.Shashi
11.Meghna
12.Bhoomi
13.Tia

U know i was so bewildered not to see Manisha's name in your list ..yet u listed 13 singers 🤔...I can't be hallucinating so early in the morning!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!😲 ...(though I need a coffee break ...and need to get to work)....But then I noticed u skipped 8.... I was like phew.😆..
Edited by kuhu.kuhu - 15 years ago
324284 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: kuhu.kuhu

U know i was so bewildered not to see Manisha's name in your list ..yet u listed 13 singers 🤔...I can't be hallucinating so early in the morning!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!😲 ...(though I need a coffee break ...and need to get to work)....But then I noticed u skipped 8.... I was like phew.😆..

Good one...,. I was also like where is Manisha!!!!!!!!!!!
sapoot thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Angad_Kripa_200

Today's performances were far far far better from yesterday's performance... And I have to say this is what you call a great episode... Packed with great singing and great performances...

Today's episode was started off with Bhoomi singing Aazma Luck Aazma... And man she was good... She sung the song with the attitude and punch it needed to be sung in... She was great and I hope to see more great performances from her... 👏👏👏... Three claps for Bhoomi....

After Bhoomi's rocking performance it was Sriram with yet another great performance on the song Tu Hi Meri Shabd Hai... He did complete justice to the song... I mean the passion and feel that he has sung the song with was praiseworthy... This is one performance that I would love to watch over again and again because it was equally as good as the original... I was really glad that the judges selected him the best performance of today... It was truly deserved... Five claps of Sriram...👏
👏
Following Sriram was Rakesh... Now this is one guy I never liked from the start... No offence to his fans but I don't know why I just can't stand him... And I thought he will be able to prove me wrong with his performance... But he failed to do so on his performance of Jab Se Tere Naina... I felt he sung the song at the same pace and there was no passion and feeling in the song... I could not connect with his singing and I guess he himself could not connect to the song... He did not do justice to the song according to me... I would say he was the second weakest performer after Manisha... So for Rakesh, it's going to be only one clap 👏...

Sashi... You expect a lot from this guy and I guess from his past experience you want him to deliver something awesome... But I just feel like Rakesh, he also failed to sing the song Mera Piya Ghar Aaya with the passion and feel that it was suppose to be sung with... He was good, but it was just plain simple... There wasn't anyway to connect with his singing... For him it would be two claps... 👏👏... He can do good...

Today, Meghna was a complete surprise... She chose a hard song of Lag Ja Gale and I guess she sung it pretty well... I mean she was good and today's performance was better than her past two performances and she has one of the most sweetest voices on II5 according to me... She was really good and I hope she can do better in the future... I don't understand why Anu didn't like her performance... Anyways three claps for Meghna... 👏👏👏
MEGHNA REMAINED REALLY NUMBER ONE ACCORDING TO ME

Coming after Meghna was Naushad... This is another contestant from whom you expect a lot... He sung the song Bol Na Halke Halke... Well, Naushad sung the song well but I felt he wasn't comfortable with the song because I didn't feel the passion in his singing... Usually when Naushad sings he amazes you but today I just couldn't connect with his singing... But nonetheless, he was good so here's three claps for him as well... 👏👏👏

And finally chotu motu gulu and my personal favorite Arpita... She song this song from Teen Patti sung by Sunidhi and composed by Salim... And damn she was good... The feel and passion she sung the song with was amazing... The attitude was bang on... And it was a great performance by her... But not the best of the night as the best of the gala goes to Sriram... So here is four claps for Arpita... 👏

Okay, a special mention of a special performance... It was Anu Malik on singing Yeh Kali Kali Aakhen... It was a great performance... Completely besura, completely off-beat but man was it entertaining... And the dancing was brilliant... So here's ten stars for Anu Malik... 👏

So after watching the entire gala, according to me here is how I would rank all teh thirteen performance...

1. Sriram...
2. Arpita...
3. Shivam...
4. Vishwash...
5. Naushad...
6. Bhoomi...
7. Meghna...
8. Yashraj...
9. Swaroop...
10. Shashi...
11. Tia...
12. Rakesh...
13. Manisha...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".