Indian Idol will never have a proper winner again. - Page 2

I agree that Indian Idol is like a joke after the first season. If rajdeep is out, i don't see any promising singer in that show now. I don't know what people see when they vote? :(

Originally posted by: girija babu

All 14 finalist of the indian idol 4 is least talented contestants. Except for Prasenjeet and Rajdeep no one is wah wah singers. Even Rajdeep is not that great but he is definitely far better than those mediocre contestants. Thats the only reason I feel he should be Indian Idol.

Its just a joke now. They just need to complete the formality of disclosing a winner.

If Sourabhee wins then after Abhijeet she will be the next best indian idol....

Originally posted by: teazerboy

If Sourabhee wins then after Abhijeet she will be the next best indian idol....

i don't think tat indion idol will not get true winner..i think sourabhee is way good n she deserves to win..as for kapil n torsha.. even i think they don deserve at all.. but let's c who wins!!

torsha is a very good singer but she really needs to be consistent..she has a lovely voice but messes up most of the time

Originally posted by: Prosenjit1

Indian Idol is not for trained singers like Rajdeep, Bhavya and Prosenjit. They ought to be in "saregama pa and VOI"

Originally posted by: preethi_p_r

I dont think they would stand a chance in SRGMP , the later is way above standard !

I agree

Even Sourbhee will not stand a chance in SRGMP, she will not even make to top 10. I think Mitika and Naina were way better than Sourbhee and Torsha and they were eliminated early one. None would stand a chance against Vaishali, Soumen, Yashita and Pratibha.

I used to lool forward to Mitika, Vaishali and Pritibha's singing and listen to their music again and again especially Vaishali's....I have not done this with Indian idols singers..many times I fast forward when they are singing.

Originally posted by: mintyblue

Just remmeber 1 thing....Torsha is still there and she is a good singer

Check out her perfromances on youtube and you wlill realize that in top 4, even if someone could give an iota of competition to rajdeep,it was Torsha.

and stop saying wonderful things about saregama and VOI. they are sometimes also bad. The winner of VOI ravi shukla is in league of Kpail/remo only. nothing better....

I agree

Torsha is better singer than Sourbhee...but she is nowhere near Vaishali or Pratibha..Indian idol's standard is very low compare to SRGMPA.