Thank God Rajdeep is out! - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

40

Views

5.1k

Users

27

Frequent Posters

Meredith thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#21

WHY THE HELL DO PEOPLE LOOK AT REGIONALISM WHEN VOTING? I thought either Rajdeep or Torsha might get eliminated . He wasn't as bad a singer as other contestants, i.e. Bhanu. HOPEFULLY, TORSHA SHOULD EXIT THIS WEEK, ITS ABOUT TIME SHE DID!

Edited by Meredith - 16 years ago
mr.ass thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: mintyblue

Old black joe is not a bengali. he pretends to be one but is dfaming bings all the time

Rajdeep and Torsha were the only good singers in top 5. Remo and kapil was worst. sourabhee is above average



mintyblue, .. i am a bengali and i'm proud of it.. if i dont like some bengali singers thats my opinion.. i like them as composers more thats all..i already made it very clear that I love listening to the songs of the burmans and salil da and am a big fan of kishore da too.. if i dont think shreya's voice is unique or if many bong girls these days ape her voice doesn't mean i'm not a bengali. If i dont praise besura singers like torsha doesn't mean i'm a bengali hater.

i think i know my own region better than others.
Edited by oldblackjoe - 16 years ago
Sujal_Fan_No1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: Aamir's Fan

Completely agree with you on this Sujal. 👏👏



Y thank u Aamir 😊
324284 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: oldblackjoe

<br><br>mintyblue, .. i am a bengali and i'm proud of it.. if i dont like some bengali singers thats my opinion.. i like them as composers more thats all..i already made it very clear that I love listening to the songs of the burmans and salil da and am a big fan of kishore da too.. if i dont think shreya's voice is unique or if many bong girls these days ape her voice doesn't mean i'm not a bengali. If i dont praise besura singers like torsha doesn't mean i'm a bengali hater.<br><br>i think i know my own region better than others.<br>



Well said joe.
sandipb thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#25
I have looked at the forum properly. Just don't read the latest forums but go back 8-10 episodes earlier and see for yourseleves what comments were being posted against bengali contestants!
As I said earlier you have decided to ignore them now, but I can't
chal_phek_mat thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#26
The problem isnt who is from what state, the problem is the people who get their harmones raging looking at last names of people
Look Rajdeep Chatterjee is from Jamshedpur, if I am not mistaken Jharkhand😉, so unless someone is thinking regional he/she wont make a claim about Bengali's😆
But yeah I agree with your sentiment, good he got out
I want Kapil to win, I supported Prashant last year, supported Sandeep before and Abhijeet before😆, Its fun how people get to see all the people get high and mighty about classical singing when every year the classical bunch are getting chucked out like a bad penny
-Akanksha- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#27
I'd been rooting for Rajdeep way back since his audition. I guess I'm glad he's out, how many successful Idols have we seen so far? But I really don't care what region he was from, I would have been truly happy to see him win.
Edited by abhilasha2179 - 16 years ago
Sujal_Fan_No1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: chal_phek_mat

The problem isnt who is from what state, the problem is the people who get their harmones raging looking at last names of people

Look Rajdeep Chatterjee is from Jamshedpur, if I am not mistaken Jharkhand😉, so unless someone is thinking regional he/she wont make a claim about Bengali's😆
But yeah I agree with your sentiment, good he got out
I want Kapil to win, I supported Prashant last year, supported Sandeep before and Abhijeet before😆, Its fun how people get to see all the people get high and mighty about classical singing when every year the classical bunch are getting chucked out like a bad penny



I dont care bout wer he came from, the point is he was a really gd singer, now there is only 3 beh sura's there.

I cant vote as i do not live in indian, but believe me i would have done if i was living there. And as for u wanting Kapil to win and supported Prashant and Sandeep that is ur opinion and i respect that. But for me coz of contestants like that winning no wonder the show is going down and no longer worth watching.
Blossom5 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: bambooshoot

I agree to some extent.....

If Rajdeep and Amit Paul became Indian Idols, they would be added to the list of Bengali winners, and even if they were deserving, people would still criticize Bengalis for regional voting.
Let's disregard Kapil for now. But I really don't think Torsha should win this. If you compare her to the previous Bengali winners like Aneek, Sanchita, Anamika and even Debojit, she comes nowhere close. So I hope and pray that she doesn't win.

Well i guess Sandipb's point is making more sense to me as i read on, i was confused at first. It is true that people are enjoying his singing instead of lumping him with the other Bengalis who won shows and insulting them (which would be the case if Rajdeep would have won.) But i think such an outcome is apreciated in this instance only or in Torsha's case if she doesn't win (i don't think she should either.)
mintyblue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#30
rajdeep deserved to win...bengali or not bengali
Unofrtunately regional voting and blind votes have made Kapil come in top 3
He is not even worthy of top 10,frankly speaking
Kapil,kuldeep,remo and priyanka should ahve been first 4 to go out
Unfortunately it was singers like Ananaya nd shini who deserevd to be in top 5
So all those who are going on and on about bias for girls, let me tell you the show started with a bias against girls. A big time bias. If still we have 2 girls in top 3, what's the harm? true, the best singer could not win- couldn't taht have been a girl as well? were not bhavya n shini equally taletned as Rajdeep?
i do think we should get over our sexism now
as for best or no best, Torsha is the best singer aorund. I think I can see some people being very anti-Bengali in this thread and refusing to see Torsha's talent. which is very sad...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".