Indian Idol 4: A Mess in the Making - Page 4

Originally posted by: *Woh Ajnabee*

Although there are several topics relating to what my topic is going to be about, I just have so much to say that wanted to create this topic. Others have drifted off to so many other issues and lost focus, that I can't relate to them.

First things first, I don't care how "un-Indian" you think Kapil and Sourabhee are, they were "Indian" enough to get into the show, and that should be good enough for you. Having said that, I don't deny the presence of regionalism, but such generalized and biased statements are not tolerable.

I'm so upset today, I cannot believe that Rajdeep was kicked off. He was that one hope of the show that was left. That one light at the end of the tunnel --- who knew that that light was just another train coming, right? That guy is so awesome, his performances were never weak, never lacking, from day one, he's justified his presence in the show through sheer talent and sincerity. He's been my favorite ever since he walked into the audition room with that smile of his and ever-so humble attitude. His rendition of Sonu's Rabba Mera Rabba is heart wrenching, I really hope he makes it big one day. Such talent should not be ignored. Despite all the fan following around him, I wonder why he was kicked off. What more is the audience looking for? Is good singing, good personality and humility not enough anymore?

I continued watching the show thinking that its okay that all these more talented singers are getting out and less deserving ones are staying, as long as Rajdeep's in the game, I was so sure that he'll bag the title this time.

Anyways, let us give a round of applause to Rajdeep's talent and his humble exit from the show.

Moving on to the singers that are the Top Three (despite all our grievances)...

Kapil: That guy cannot sing. I salute him for being a soldier, I respect his patriotism, and I appreciate his humble personality, but his singing just isn't up to the mark. He loses focus, his voice quality is extremely lacking, and his grip and knowledge of music is no where up to the mark. He should've exited today, not because he's not "indian" enough, but because it really should be talent that's being looked at.

Sourabhee: That girl has been quite consistent and carries herself well. Her spunk is an additional bonus to her overall image. But her singing isn't something I connect with. Her voice quality is very lacking and nothing original or unique. I'm not saying that she doesn't deserve the Top 3 spot, but I do feel that if some of these other singers that were eliminated early on were given a chance, they could do as well as Sourabhee, if not better. Having said that, kudos to her for making it thus far, and may she battle it out in the end with all her strength.

Torsha: I have so much to say about her. Torsha is the epitome of a female Indian Idol -- she has the personality, the mannerisms, and the looks to become the female Idol. What she's lacking is the singing. I love Torsha's voice quality -- its extremely unique, and a huge asset to her overall package. However, she has not learned to use that to her advantage. Her voice requires certain kinds of songs, and she's failed to pick those songs that will suit her voice. Her lack of confidence is a huge turn off. And so is her over-confidence at times. She's played both games so far --- the "bechari" act with her "i'm-trying" attitude, and also her "i-don't-care-what-you-say" glances. Neither's played out well on her end. The problem I have with her is that she hasn't shown us who the real her is. She seems to be trying too hard at times, but always on the wrong things. And although we want her to take the title, because she has the potential to be that female Idol, we can't deny that she hasn't delivered.

Regionalism is a huge problem in public voting reality shows. Its quite unfortunate actually, but apparently there's absolutely nothing that we can do about it. So, I won't get into that, it just makes me sad that we have to sacrifice talent simply because someone's from the same state as us.

By some miracle, I hope that Torsha gets her act together in the last few weeks and truly delivers. If so, I'd say she's fair game for the title. If not, give it to Sourabhee, so far, she's the best pick and most deserving of the three. Having said that, my guess is that Kapil will snatch the title from the gals and Sonali will be left chanting her "female idol" speeches.

Sorry for the extremely long topic, had to get this out of my system. Geez, I still can't believe Rajdeep is out. It breaks my heart to see him go.

Originally posted by: chutneyx4404

i agree completely with you about everything. it's like you took the words out of my mouth.

Originally posted by: mintyblue

I am very impressed with Woh Ajnabee's reasonable and rational posts. If someone can keep his cool and provide such a clear analysis despite one of his favourites being out, I salute that person. I myself am not capable of this and oten get carried away by strong emotions which I regret later. That's because one does get emotionally attached to the contestants. I for one loved Shini's voice and shared sonali's frusteration at her early exit.

I agree we should not balme other contestants. Its not their fault if they get votes. Also at times I feel channel plays its own games. I don't think the elimination oder isbased entirley on votes. There are certain things the channel may/may not want that comes into focus. For eg- I think priyanka and remo got out despite enver being in danger zone- i found it a bit stargen. def. channel has its own pre-fixed eliminations at times. Votes merely increase the profits of the telecom companies whic sponser the show...

But all said and sone, we cannot deny that certain regions vote for their candidates irrespective of talent. we have seen tat with Prashant Tmang and Prakriti giri earlier. I am not saying its wrong, but it can be upstting when better singers get out due to whatever reaons

Whta I think is Torsha is the best out of the 3. Her voice texture is very good. also she is nervous, at times under-confient I agree. But potential wise she is the best. I rmeber her piano round eprformances 'baiyan na dharo' and 'chura liya'. they were beyond expectations. even the first 2 galas and when she sang 'lambi judai' was exceptional. there she bloomed in full strnegth.

I am not saying sourabhee is not good she is. But if we are looking at compete packages probably Anaya was a better bet. she was an all-rounder, and a better singer than sourabhee any day. So we must not forgte those who are eliminated, and in that context Kpail and sourabhee are not deserving to be in top3....

Originally posted by: andysah

By castrating, I meant castrating the male voice which II4 has done after removing Rajdeep. The remaining one do not count.

Does anyone find Sonali's dumb comedic routine "Is bar Indian Idol ek ladki ee hogi" unfunny? She screeches that multiple times an episode to score her point and would even choose Torsha over Rajdeep because of that. Imagine the hellfire and brimstone if an ugly male judge (Kailash for example) kept on saying "Is bar Indian Idol ek ladka hogi."

Originally posted by: *Woh Ajnabee*

Although there are several topics relating to what my topic is going to be about, I just have so much to say that wanted to create this topic. Others have drifted off to so many other issues and lost focus, that I can't relate to them.

First things first, I don't care how "un-Indian" you think Kapil and Sourabhee are, they were "Indian" enough to get into the show, and that should be good enough for you. Having said that, I don't deny the presence of regionalism, but such generalized and biased statements are not tolerable.

I'm so upset today, I cannot believe that Rajdeep was kicked off. He was that one hope of the show that was left. That one light at the end of the tunnel --- who knew that that light was just another train coming, right? That guy is so awesome, his performances were never weak, never lacking, from day one, he's justified his presence in the show through sheer talent and sincerity. He's been my favorite ever since he walked into the audition room with that smile of his and ever-so humble attitude. His rendition of Sonu's Rabba Mera Rabba is heart wrenching, I really hope he makes it big one day. Such talent should not be ignored. Despite all the fan following around him, I wonder why he was kicked off. What more is the audience looking for? Is good singing, good personality and humility not enough anymore?

I continued watching the show thinking that its okay that all these more talented singers are getting out and less deserving ones are staying, as long as Rajdeep's in the game, I was so sure that he'll bag the title this time.

Anyways, let us give a round of applause to Rajdeep's talent and his humble exit from the show.

Moving on to the singers that are the Top Three (despite all our grievances)...

Kapil: That guy cannot sing. I salute him for being a soldier, I respect his patriotism, and I appreciate his humble personality, but his singing just isn't up to the mark. He loses focus, his voice quality is extremely lacking, and his grip and knowledge of music is no where up to the mark. He should've exited today, not because he's not "indian" enough, but because it really should be talent that's being looked at.

Sourabhee: That girl has been quite consistent and carries herself well. Her spunk is an additional bonus to her overall image. But her singing isn't something I connect with. Her voice quality is very lacking and nothing original or unique. I'm not saying that she doesn't deserve the Top 3 spot, but I do feel that if some of these other singers that were eliminated early on were given a chance, they could do as well as Sourabhee, if not better. Having said that, kudos to her for making it thus far, and may she battle it out in the end with all her strength.

Torsha: I have so much to say about her. Torsha is the epitome of a female Indian Idol -- she has the personality, the mannerisms, and the looks to become the female Idol. What she's lacking is the singing. I love Torsha's voice quality -- its extremely unique, and a huge asset to her overall package. However, she has not learned to use that to her advantage. Her voice requires certain kinds of songs, and she's failed to pick those songs that will suit her voice. Her lack of confidence is a huge turn off. And so is her over-confidence at times. She's played both games so far --- the "bechari" act with her "i'm-trying" attitude, and also her "i-don't-care-what-you-say" glances. Neither's played out well on her end. The problem I have with her is that she hasn't shown us who the real her is. She seems to be trying too hard at times, but always on the wrong things. And although we want her to take the title, because she has the potential to be that female Idol, we can't deny that she hasn't delivered.

Regionalism is a huge problem in public voting reality shows. Its quite unfortunate actually, but apparently there's absolutely nothing that we can do about it. So, I won't get into that, it just makes me sad that we have to sacrifice talent simply because someone's from the same state as us.

By some miracle, I hope that Torsha gets her act together in the last few weeks and truly delivers. If so, I'd say she's fair game for the title. If not, give it to Sourabhee, so far, she's the best pick and most deserving of the three. Having said that, my guess is that Kapil will snatch the title from the gals and Sonali will be left chanting her "female idol" speeches.

Sorry for the extremely long topic, had to get this out of my system. Geez, I still can't believe Rajdeep is out. It breaks my heart to see him go.

Originally posted by: Aisha_86

Everyone is raged about Rajdeep getting out. But frankly speaking his singing was never special in my eyes... He sings good, but it just never touched... But that is my choice and so does the public have their owns choice..

Agree with you in totality😉

Why are you guys worriying about it that much? If rajdeep had won this show (or in my case prasenjit), what difference would it have made? It would be good just for your own satisfaction, that the person YOU liked WON... But come to the real world... Things like this just happen get over it please..

Originally posted by: syrene

Somehow even though so many people dislike Torsha, I have a feeling that she may be more successful as a recording artiste. I can actually imagine buying an album of her songs...while i am not sure about the other two. It is just that i find her voice quite soothing. But seeing the voting pattern i am sure she is the next to go.