Sonu Nigam vs Udit Narayan - Page 6

Originally posted by: best_guy

Proof?
Here you go. Listen from 7:50. Sonu Nigam compliments about Udit's voice.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lMQuuZrFaeE

Plus Udit has more awards.

Originally posted by: game_over

voice: udit has a rich voice and sounds better.. he doesnt quiver either...
sonu has a slightly nasal,quivery,thin voice..sounds like a clone of mphd aziz or shabbir kumar


songs: my personal opinion. i like pehla nasha,kuch kuch,koi mil gaya,chand chupa,papa kehte hai,mitwa sun mitwa, radha kaise,pardesi,aaye ho meri zindagi mein,tu cheez badi hai and prefer them over ,jaaye jaaye, what is mobile number,mera pant bhi sexy sexy... and sonu's good songs were slightly spoilt by his voice.. like main gar kahoon (which aneek dhar pwned him in 😃), piyu bole (over sweet and over dlicate),etc.. only kal ho na ho manages to reach udit's standard.. just abt..

my 3 cents.

Originally posted by: pksanam

your 3 cents are better than your blue cheese.. 😉 dont u like blue cheese?

i see you changed your nickname, obj.. it's good.. 😊 yeah... its game over for a while.. i dont know tamil but i have to learn 48 pages of it

now nkapoor had a wonderful reply which unfortunately seems to be deleted.. hmmmm.. anyways.. few of the points that i am going to add (who's gonna type up again)kk...

true, Udit has a good voice.. but Udit is very limited.. Sonu is way more versatile having sung all ranges of song..yeah... but i dont want to listen to half of those genres... thats why...

songs i love of Sonu..

Rabba Mere Rabba, Main Hoon Na, Satrangi Re, Saathiya, Kal Ho Naa Ho, Suraj Hua Madham, In Lamhon Ke Daman Mein, Kabhi Alvida Na Kehna, Main Agar Kahon, Sandese Aate Hain, Tu Kab Ye Maane Gi, Bijuriya, Tanhaayee (Dil Chahta Hai), Yeh Dil Deewana (Pardes), Sab Kuch Bhula Diya, Soniyo (Raaz 2), Meere Haath Mein Tera Haath Ho (Fana), Piyu Bole, Zindagi Maut Na Ban Jaaye, Mera Rang De Basanti Chola, Tumse Milke Dil Ka Hai Jo Haal, Humein Jab Se Mohabbat, Deewana Tera Tujhe Hi Pukaare, Do Pal Ka Hai Khwabon Ka Karwan (Veer Zaara).. many many more.. these are just a few..
yep sab achcha gaana hai


range that Sonu has nobody has.. and i did happen to have listen to Aneek's Main Agar Kahoon.. it's good but he has not outdone Sonu by any means.. Piyu Bole is supposed to be a sweet song hence overly sweet.. that's called range, my dear.. singer should be able to sing in all kinds of moods.. and that is where Sonu easily wins hands down.. even the new song Guzarish sung by Javed Ali, i believe, has vocals of Sonu which are amazing..
naaah sonu's was over sweet and too delicate.. and this had too many dhakka maar ke expressions...

also, mphd (??) aziz, you mean mohd aziz or shabbir kumar.. are you joking.. they were a very sad version of Rafi but Sonu is so much far better.. aziz and shabbir both sound like old guys but Sonu resembles more like a young Mohd Rafi.. otherwise, aziz and shabbir would still have their jobs.. needless to say, they never got the same appreciation Sonu is getting.. there must be more to it than what you are stating..!!

and there is that point again mentioned earlier by shehzaadi about the live concerts.. Udit has too many limitations there, which can't be ignored if we are comparing singers..
yeah but that voice 😍

Originally posted by: game_over

your 3 cents are better than your blue cheese.. 😉 dont u like blue cheese? are you kidding.. i love the blue cheese.. 😆😆

i see you changed your nickname, obj.. it's good.. 😊 yeah... its game over for a while.. i dont know tamil but i have to learn 48 pages of it awww.. best of luck.. 👍🏼 i'm so glad i'm done with my studies.. 😳

now nkapoor had a wonderful reply which unfortunately seems to be deleted.. hmmmm.. anyways.. few of the points that i am going to add (who's gonna type up again)kk... server loss, apparently.. there was a message by Vijay, the site admin..

true, Udit has a good voice.. but Udit is very limited.. Sonu is way more versatile having sung all ranges of song..yeah... but i dont want to listen to half of those genres... thats why... that's silly.. 😆😆 alright, valid at your end but void in general..

songs i love of Sonu..

Rabba Mere Rabba, Main Hoon Na, Satrangi Re, Saathiya, Kal Ho Naa Ho, Suraj Hua Madham, In Lamhon Ke Daman Mein, Kabhi Alvida Na Kehna, Main Agar Kahon, Sandese Aate Hain, Tu Kab Ye Maane Gi, Bijuriya, Tanhaayee (Dil Chahta Hai), Yeh Dil Deewana (Pardes), Sab Kuch Bhula Diya, Soniyo (Raaz 2), Meere Haath Mein Tera Haath Ho (Fana), Piyu Bole, Zindagi Maut Na Ban Jaaye, Mera Rang De Basanti Chola, Tumse Milke Dil Ka Hai Jo Haal, Humein Jab Se Mohabbat, Deewana Tera Tujhe Hi Pukaare, Do Pal Ka Hai Khwabon Ka Karwan (Veer Zaara).. many many more.. these are just a few..
yep sab achcha gaana hai wow, a compliment.. coming from you, that means a lot.. 😊


range that Sonu has nobody has.. and i did happen to have listen to Aneek's Main Agar Kahoon.. it's good but he has not outdone Sonu by any means.. Piyu Bole is supposed to be a sweet song hence overly sweet.. that's called range, my dear.. singer should be able to sing in all kinds of moods.. and that is where Sonu easily wins hands down.. even the new song Guzarish sung by Javed Ali, i believe, has vocals of Sonu which are amazing..
naaah sonu's was over sweet and too delicate.. and this had too many dhakka maar ke expressions...

that's just your prejudice against poor Sonu.. void.. 😉

also, mphd (??) aziz, you mean mohd aziz or shabbir kumar.. are you joking.. they were a very sad version of Rafi but Sonu is so much far better.. aziz and shabbir both sound like old guys but Sonu resembles more like a young Mohd Rafi.. otherwise, aziz and shabbir would still have their jobs.. needless to say, they never got the same appreciation Sonu is getting.. there must be more to it than what you are stating..!!

and there is that point again mentioned earlier by shehzaadi about the live concerts.. Udit has too many limitations there, which can't be ignored if we are comparing singers..
yeah but that voice 😍 all boils down to the voice then naa.. whose voice your prefer, but that doesn't take away from the other's singing.. 😛 Udit does have a great voice, but Sonu is a better singer.. 😉😊😊 ab credit de bhi do jahan due hai.. or you don't think Sonu is a great singer..? chalo, for your sake you can say they're both great and you love them both.. and you only have two choices.. yes and yes.. 😉😆😆

Originally posted by: pksanam

Originally posted by: best_guy

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y7mAGcIs-Xs <-- Udit has the best voice. Listen to this song.

Sonu Nigam may be better at vocalists, classical music. We are talking about playback singing where we don't need classical.

Udit sings songs beautifully and Sonu isn't as good as him in this. Plus Udit has better voice.

Originally posted by: ___fanaa4u___

you go and listen to the songs listed of sonu's in this topic, sonu has voice quality, versatality and freshness in his voice, and he is a much successful playback singer then udit narayan, has sung many commercial songs, and is compared to the likes of Mohammad raffi