I love Indian Idol. Do you? - Page 2

Even the contestants except for 1-2 are below par this is the worst season in every way.

The show should be called as Pawan and his friends.

Originally posted by: cosmos2021

These are symptoms of Reality Show Sucker Syndrome.

It happens when you get over attached to these on screen personalities. distance yourself from them and try to see things as they are the public may be right in some way.

I don't think so. If public is right all the Indianidol winners should have been very successful in real industry as they are chosen by public but no one(except very few). Also if the negativity is real show TRP should have fallen but its continuously one of the top shows. This can't happen because of any single person. It's a group effort.

They were good just for that season or were marketed as being extraordinary, but the fact remains they could not carve a niche beyond II. I see the same fate for Pawandeep who is the predecided winner his name will remain in the halls of fame of history.

Even if Arunita or Sayli win so what there is a fierce competition outside the 4 walls of II it will be extremely difficult to topple Shreya G.

Don't take all these shoes seriously and this is not even a contest, any non singer can become a singer at the end of 10 months with slight skills.

Ekta Kappor's serials are zero in content but she rules the roost.

Someone get rid of Neha and Aditya, I'd be the happiest👍🏼.

I agree that the biggest problem is the creative team. They can easily do themes that appeal to masses but choose to do old themes and repeat songs. Even with COVID, the person they are tributing doesn't necessarily have to be in studio. Songs of Shreya Ghoshal, KK, and Sunidhi Chauhan can still be done even without them being in studio.

As for the judges I have respected Anu Malik and Himesh Reshamiya for a long time. However I feel like it is in the best interest of the show if they provide constructive criticism. Them jumping around and enjoying themselves is just going to encourage certain contestants to sing the same way they usually do. Don't worry I won't give any names haha.

Neha Kakkar shouldn't be there in the first place nor should Aditya Narayan. Old school Aditya Narayan in Sa re ga ma pa (2007, 2008, 2009) was amazing. He hasn't been the same since then. Manish Paul should anchor this show. I would personally prefer a judge like Payal Dev instead of Neha Kakkar.