if u r an atheist den why 2 blame god fr ur sufferings...

designersaini thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
indira is an atheist.its ok...bcoz being a believer in god or a non-believer r 9 different.
Indira says dat wo bhagawaan mein vishwaas nahi rakhti n pooja-wooja nahi karti,if so den why 2 blame god fr ur suffering.u cant thank god when u r happy but when u didnt get wat u wont den u start blaming god ki unhone kabhi mere saath achcha nahi kiya n all to mai kyun unki pooja karu...whoa...if u r an atheist or 9t, u urself is d only reason fr all ur suffering den why 2 blame god.
Indira bhagwaan ko nahi manti bcoz she thinks ki unhone uske saath humesha bura kiya hai.but usme bhi bhagwaan ko kyun ghasit rahe ho usme bhi apne aap ko blame karo na,jab kuch achcha achieve karti hai to she says ki maine apni kismat khud banai hai.phir ab kya hua.
N aaj wo pooja mein nahi jaana chahti bcoz she doesnt believe in god.but cant she join d pooja fr her family's khushi.
ok...take an eg...Agar ghar mein diwali ki puja hai,but sirf tum us puja mein nahi jaate jst bcoz u dont believe in god,will dat b good.ur whole family is gathering n celebrating d festival n wants u 2 join it too but u dont want 2.aint it will b good if u join dem in puja for d sake f ur family happiness.isme tumhara kahan se usool toot rahe hain.
Edited by designersaini - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

2.2k

Users

13

Likes

77

Frequent Posters

Ranjinikishan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
double post😊



Edited by Ranjinikishan - 12 years ago
nutan7 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
very correct . If god doesnot exist ,then how he is responsible for calamitis in u r life?
Edited by nutan7 - 12 years ago
Badala thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
I would have to strongly disagree with the points of this post. She never said she was an atheist, all she said was she does not believe in pooja paath...

Dia! Of you read this, remember we were once discussing Indira's religious belief , so I guess we can say she believes in the mythological Hindu gods but believes in the theory of karma and that prayers do not help but deeds do.
TBDRESS thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: _saumya_

I would have to strongly disagree with the points of this post. She never said she was an atheist, all she said was she does not believe in pooja paath...

Dia! Of you read this, remember we were once discussing Indira's religious belief , so I guess we can say she believes in the mythological Hindu gods but believes in the theory of karma and that prayers do not help but deeds do.

Seema, I agree with you...if you are a non-believer, then it seems kind of illogical to blame something/someone you don't "believe in." And if you are a believer, then it is only fair that if you blame God for the misfortunes, then you must credit God for the good things...but to do this, one first has to have some gratitude and some appreciation for what they have.😆
Sammy, I don't think I'm qualified enough to decipher Indira's highly complex religous beliefs. 🤣 I really don't know what she believes in or does not believe in because it seems to change with every episode (like most things in this show 😆). Didn't she go to mataji's temple to pray right before she and Rishi were about to get married (don't ask me which marriage # this was😆) and then sat in the puja when Shweta was there. Well, I suppose her prayers weren't answered so she stopped praying...like every other character in the show, bhagwan ne bhi dhoka de diya Indira ko 🤣 Afterall zindagi jung hai 😳
Edit: Oh and Sammy, I must strongly disagree with you here 😆 why do pooja path and karma have to be mutually exclusive? Just because someone does pooja path does not mean that they don't believe in action.
Why did you say Hindu mythological gods 🤣🤣 I sense something other than sincerity here 🤣
Edited by Walden - 12 years ago
Heema22 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: _saumya_

I would have to strongly disagree with the points of this post. She never said she was an atheist, all she said was she does not believe in pooja paath...

Dia! Of you read this, remember we were once discussing Indira's religious belief , so I guess we can say she believes in the mythological Hindu gods but believes in the theory of karma and that prayers do not help but deeds do.


@ bold . Saumya . Today's episode Indira stated that she does not believe in god. Up to today she used to say specially to her very religious mom that she does not believe in Pooja path . So who knows what Indira view points are . She is clearly confused .
TBDRESS thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Heema22


@ bold . Saumya . Today's episode Indira stated that she does not believe in god. Up to today she used to say specially to her very religious mom that she does not believe in Pooja path . So who knows what Indira view points are . She is clearly confused .

I think the writers use this "religion" issue with Indira just to tell us that Indira is not like "aam ladkis" 😆They use the issue as a novelty and a gimmick- doesen't seem like they are genuinely interested in exploring a character who has a different set of beliefs...I guess that's the case with everything in this show.
Heema22 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
Seema I totally agree with you, I have a same conflict like you do . If people do not believe in God then why they hold him responsible for your bad luck ? Why people use GOD for their convenience ? Why Indira thinks that " God did nothing good for her ? Indira always has negative outlook on things, Half emty glass mentality . She survived last stage BT , she walk away from burning Pyre and Walked to Pakistan . Saved by Kabir . found by Indu her own daughter , survived assacinstion attempt by
Zara ,mentally challenged cured by Husna song ( this is Gods miracle ) third degree burns disappeared , reunited with husband and family . And survived stab wound . She is really loved by her husband Is this bad luck or good luck ?? For me it's Damn good luck .
I think Indira is confused and doesnot know what she is . If you ask me. I would label her as agnostic .
Like Dia mention. Indira has been in temple Prayed took Prasad and Shidoor from Pandit .. She did Pooja for Indu when Sweta demanded so she is not atheist !!
I really donot understand why anyone needs to refused to participate in Pooja .? If you do not believe in it what's wrong if you participate to respect your elders. Or as social function as you said in your post. Why any one needs to be so rigid and lecture everyone on Usools ? Very complex character indeed . .. Its hard to comprehend .
Edited by Heema22 - 12 years ago
Badala thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Walden


I think the writers use this "religion" issue with Indira just totell usthat Indira is not like "aam ladkis" 😆They use the issue as a novelty and a gimmick- doesen't seem like they are genuinely interested in exploring a character who has a different set of beliefs...I guess that's the case with everything in this show.



God! 🤣 why did Indira say that and ruin my argument 😆
(Dia! I keep dumping this show every few days so I don't remember the instances you are talking of)
Honey! you could have included her in your group discussions and that group leader would have changed his views about agnostics, instead he would think that the prajati who thinks they are the know it alls to be the ones who are actually fickle minded.

Dia! No hidden motives there. I really meant it about hindu mythological gods because she was complaining to devi ji about her brain tumour. karma and puja paath do not have to be mutually exclusive but its ok if someone does not find it intersecting.

Sad to know that even bhagwan has nothing else to do than make her zindagi jung 🤣
-Paulomi- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Walden

Seema, I agree with you...if you are a non-believer, then it seems kind of illogical to blame something/someone you don't "believe in." And if you are a believer, then it is only fair that if you blame God for the misfortunes, then you must credit God for the good things...but to do this, one first has to have some gratitude and some appreciation for what they have.😆
Sammy, I don't think I'm qualified enough to decipher Indira's highly complex religous beliefs. 🤣 I really don't know what she believes in or does not believe in because it seems to change with every episode (like most things in this show 😆). Didn't she go to mataji's temple to pray right before she and Rishi were about to get married (don't ask me which marriage # this was😆) and then sat in the puja when Shweta was there. Well, I suppose her prayers weren't answered so she stopped praying...like every other character in the show, bhagwan ne bhi dhoka de diya Indira ko 🤣 Afterall zindagi jung hai 😳
Edit: Oh and Sammy, I must strongly disagree with you here 😆 why do pooja path and karma have to be mutually exclusive? Just because someone does pooja path does not mean that they don't believe in action.
Why did you say Hindu mythological gods 🤣🤣 I sense something other than sincerity here 🤣


@bold yes she did go but later on she only said that once I went to her and then she only gave me an 8 years of exile.

I just want to say that yes Indira doesn't believe God, but sometimes we do certain things I mean we have to do which we don't want but still we do for other's sake.I just want that if Indira doesn't want to hurt JD then at least for her happiness she can act only if she wants.

All the religious complexities of Indira as shown should be blamed on the PH because I think she doesn't write her scripts in the same way of the other characters don't and just like the unemployment issues for the males.
Edited by -Paulomi- - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".