Banner Contest II Winner[Note pg 13/19] - Page 3

Originally posted by: dhanya.r

Congrats sano. never knew u were a fan of HD.

Thank you but i don't even watch Hitler Didi. 😳

Originally posted by: Sano88

Hello all!

Well, the voting round had to be done into DT section because of cheating. The first voting round (which held in the section itself) forced us to do the final voting into the DT section. Considering the fact that first round had alot of new ids, and new members which are nowhere to be seen now forced us to take this decision.I would not like to mention names for the members who cheated as it will not look good. As far as you want screen shots for the final round, we'll talk about it with our team and will get back to you.

Sano,when the votes of mids are nowhere genuine,there is nothing wrong in publicly disclosing which ids were fake!!In this way atleast you can bring before us the mids!!Am not asking you to take the names of the members who cheated as it wont look gud definitely,but why not tell al of us wch of the ids in the voting process were mids!!We can delete those votes and count the rest of the votes,as that would be a fair one where the members of this forum decide the winner!!!

Originally posted by: aadk

Which awards are you talking about?Do you mean to say that a fan is not capable of judging an actor that we need someone else to take decision for him?
Moreover,here is a link of other forum where they had three rounds of voting and all of dem were open!! http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1281716
I dont mean to say that we must follow other forums or anything like that,but when we have an option for an open and a fair process,then why opt for a hidden one!!!

Originally posted by: preethimadhavg

I am talking in general sense

@bold - you question has your answer, yes fans are always biased to their favs that is not a hidden truth...

and i feel above mods reply gives all the info

I din get the general sense!!Sorry!!
@bold Now that doesnt make sense to me!!Do u mean to say that the first round of voting was done just for the sake of doing it,but in reality it had no meaning in itself!!!
Anyways,I hope the mods give us a proper reason!!!

Originally posted by: aadk

Sano,when the votes of mids are nowhere genuine,there is nothing wrong in publicly disclosing which ids were fake!!In this way atleast you can bring before us the mids!!Am not asking you to take the names of the members who cheated as it wont look gud definitely,but why not tell al of us wch of the ids in the voting process were mids!!We can delete those votes and count the rest of the votes,as that would be a fair one where the members of this forum decide the winner!!!

No, it's not allowed and things which are not allowed, we can't do that, isn't it?
The first voting round votes were counted and the the top 4 were selected. We've to keep the final voting round in DT section so members can avoid cheating. Cheating doesn't mean when only Mids can vote for some specific banners, it's also considered cheating when members vote for the exact same banners without making any change which makes you think how's this possible?

Originally posted by: aadk

Waiting for your reply tanni!! Pls do make things more clearer!!

Originally posted by: Sano88

No, it's not allowed and things which are not allowed, we can't do that, isn't it?
The first voting round votes were counted and the the top 4 were selected. We've to keep the final voting round in DT section so members can avoid cheating. Cheating doesn't mean when only Mids can vote for some specific banners, it's also considered cheating when members vote for the exact same banners without making any change which makes you think how's this possible?

@bold Now thts a way to get off easily Sano!!You cant cum up with such a response at this point of time when one demands clarity!!!
@red How can we be sure that those 4 banners selected by all of you were the top ones when u r not disclosing which ids were fake ones and which were genuine ones?
@blue Its same as how am thinking "Hows this possible?"!!!
I request all the mods of this forum to make things clearer to every member out here PLS!!!!

Originally posted by: aadk

[
@bold Now thts a way to get off easily Sano!!You cant cum up with such a response at this point of time when one demands clarity!!!
@red How can we be sure that those 4 banners selected by all of you were the top ones when u r not disclosing which ids were fake ones and which were genuine ones?
@blue Its same as how am thinking "Hows this possible?"!!!
I request all the mods of this forum to make things clearer to every member out here PLS!!!!

It happens in many sections but you're the only person who asked such question because many members are aware how the BC system/voting round works.

@ red : Because the banners which got the highest votes by the mids were disqualified as per the forum rules therefore, the few banners which were left were the top 4 banners. Moderators are giving you the most neutral reply but you're not trying to take it.

Originally posted by: tannipartner

HI aadk, As I said before, we did the first round of voting here in the forum, and the banners with most votes were voted again in coolbie videobie section.

And no its not a separate section. its a section where coolbies and videobies and viewbies and moderators and channel moderators can come and vote. We did it to make sure the best banner wins.

But I responded to it earlier, what else you do need to know more clearly? as for screenshots, we need to talk to channel moderator to see if something like that can be done.

To make the competitions impartial, I did not submit any entry on my side, so that I can remain impartial while counting.

@bold Tanni,anything that is not done right before all of us in this forum cant be brought under this section!!!
@red Thats really nice to hear tanni!!Even I,myself have not participated in this contest.All that am demanding is a fair judgement and if it has been a fair one,then what is it thats holding the mods frm disclosing it before the forum!!!!

Originally posted by: Sano88

It happens in many sections but you're the only person who asked such question because many members are aware how the BC system/voting round works.

@ red : Because the banners which got the highest votes by the mids were disqualified as per the forum rules therefore, the few banners which were left were the top 4 banners. Moderators are giving you the most neutral reply but you're not trying to take it.

Sano,being a member of this forum,I believe I have got all the rights to know what is happening here and how its happening!!!If things are the same in other forums,that doesnt mean it must be the same here!!
@bold I want a fair one!! Thats all am asking for!!!