Banner Contest II Winner[Note pg 13/19] - Page 2

Originally posted by: tannipartner

coolbie and videobie section comprises of coolbies videobies and DTs of all sections. This was done to make sure the voting was unbiased and no cheating is done.

I am not sure if screenshots of voting can be given out or if its even plausible. because if we oblige one group, we need to oblige everyone. but I will talk to our channel moderator about it.

Originally posted by: preethimadhavg

i accept with you because we cannot say which is genuine voting and which is done by MIDs (as MIDs is general issue in any forum)

How can a voting which is not done infront of our eyes be genuine then?If the attack of mids was expected then wasn't it better to not keep the first round of voting an open one!!The coolbies,videobies and the DTs could have been the judges among themselves and decided the banner for us!Now,since the voting was made open,the rest of the process must also be opened up before all!!

@Preethi: I agree about the MID issue...and frankly speaking, I support this idea of coolbies viewbies section because it will lead to fair judgement...The members of DT section aren't part of any forum politics and we can expect a genuine result from them...
@Tanni: I am quite excited for the new banner to be put up on forum...So when are we going to get it?

Love the new banner :) its pretty!! Congrats Sano!

Waiting for your reply tanni!! Pls do make things more clearer!!

congratz sano:)
banner looks amazing

Congrats sano. never knew u were a fan of HD.

Originally posted by: aadk

How can a voting which is not done infront of our eyes be genuine then?If the attack of mids was expected then wasn't it better to not keep the first round of voting an open one!!The coolbies,videobies and the DTs could have been the judges among themselves and decided the banner for us!Now,since the voting was made open,the rest of the process must also be opened up before all!!

Originally posted by: preethimadhavg

it is as simple as awards, fans vote for their fav irrespective of their actors performance but judges at the end sees every aspect of the actor good points or bad points along with the highest number of votes before selecting the winner

in first round they took our opinion and short listed it then judges done the rest of the part..

i didnot find anything wrong in this

i have no issues with

Which awards are you talking about?Do you mean to say that a fan is not capable of judging an actor that we need someone else to take decision for him?
Moreover,here is a link of other forum where they had three rounds of voting and all of dem were open!! http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1281716
I dont mean to say that we must follow other forums or anything like that,but when we have an option for an open and a fair process,then why opt for a hidden one!!!