UNBELIEVABLE & UNACCEPTABLE

Earnshaw09 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Art is the representation of life,with a creative touch.But this notion has been absolutely misinterpreted by Illa Bedi,the director,and the creative team of "Hitler Didi".The story of "HD" has not only gone beyond reality,but it has become impossible for the audience to relate to it and the characters. And today's episode was a real disaster for certain reasons we'll are aware of:firstly,the character Indu,who is an eight year old,spoke without any understanding of what she is speaking about;she seems to be a forensic fingerprint expert,who is forcing her opinion on everyone that the'Lahorewali' is Indira,her mother. On the other hand,Kutum Sharma,the protagonist's biological mother,is suddenly made to realize her motherly instincts and judge the look-alike of Indira;whereas,she never judged,or has been curious about Zara,who also resembles her daughter in many ways.

In a nutshell,the story of "HD" has become a mess,and the script-writer,as well as the creative visualizers seem to be unaware of what they are heading into.First,they made the protagonist of the story die;then they showed the comeback of a look-alike of her,who does not only look like Indira,but also behaves like her,thinks like her;who shares a strange connection with Indu and Rishi,so much so,that Zara travels all the way from Mumbai to save the little girl Indu,and gets involved with the entire Sharma family;and she even binds a strong emotional connection with Rishi,who believes that she is his beloved wife Indira.And to add more to it,the CVs always tune in to the background music,which has been used when Indira and Rishi had romantic moments, whenever Rishi and Zara are together.But suddenly a suspense is created through the means of concepts of DNA and fingerprint;where they have absolutely failed to convince the viewers their immature story-line.Because,lets talk about fingerprint concept,which has been pinned in every alternate episode:the argument that is shown is that,Zara's fingerprints do not match Indira's;and the other look-alike of Indira,her fingerprint matches Indira's. But I think either the script-writer,or the CVs have been underestimated the audience,thinking that we'll take whatever is shown to us without a doubt.Here,they have mistaken,because it has raised a question in most of us:Who has given the Opinion about the fingerprints?-the lawyer,the policeman,or Indu!none of them being a forensic fingerprint expert.And the entire story is being based on this immature writing!where in fact,an expert fingerprint forensic will also state otherwise(as Warren Ashton,an expert in this field states that:"We conduct a series of experiments and sequential
testing
, according to prescribed procedures,a scientific methodology."]So,I think this is the most unbelievable and unacceptable story ever.So my advice to the CVs,and the script-writer of "HD" that,either do some research before you come up with a concept,or don't use such concepts in your story,which you're not clear about.Because you might be of the opinion that,the audience of your show is uneducated and ignorant people,who will blindly worship the show and its characters.Well,the fact is,the audience of the 21st century soap-opera is much more aware of the different iissues and concepts,whether social,or economical;whether issues related to family,or education,or that be Rights .


We are connected to a novel,or a drama,or that be a soap-opera,because we feel correlated to the story and its characters. And this is the very reason we have been so connected to "HD";but it s becoming hard now to either correlate with the story,or the characters.Because its neither convincing,nor acceptable to grasp the story hereon,where in one hand Rishi is being shown as a true and honest man,who has been unconditionally loving hie wife Indira;and believes that Zara is none other than her;and on the other hand the story seems to convince us all that the "Lahorewali" is Indira.

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1.8k

Users

12

Likes

44

Frequent Posters

sumitonly thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Let's wait and watch... I am puzzled to even judge anything...
ashish.sachi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
Go & watch that episode again , where Indu enquires about Fingerprints with Lawyer.

Lawyer tells that Forensic Report has come , that Indira Sharma & Zara's fingerprints do not match.


Again when Indu went with Lawyer & Policeman to Asalym,they submitted full legal forensic report to the Authorities (Nun) there. Then only she let go off LW.
jassi81 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: ashish.sachi

Go & watch that episode again , where Indu enquires about Fingerprints with Lawyer.


Lawyer tells that Forensic Report has come , that Indira Sharma & Zara's fingerprints do not match.


Again when Indu went with Lawyer & Policeman to Asalym,they submitted full legal forensic report to the Authorities (Nun) there. Then only she let go off LW.



you are correct :)
light_28 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Agree arpita! Just dnt knw what to say 4 HD.
-Paulomi- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: ashish.sachi

Go & watch that episode again , where Indu enquires about Fingerprints with Lawyer.


Lawyer tells that Forensic Report has come , that Indira Sharma & Zara's fingerprints do not match.


Again when Indu went with Lawyer & Policeman to Asalym,they submitted full legal forensic report to the Authorities (Nun) there. Then only she let go off LW.

but they didn't show the nun checking that fingerprint with that of indira,just indu told that there is a shankh
ashish.sachi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: -Paulomi-

but they didn't show the nun checking that fingerprint with that of indira,just indu told that there is a shankh


Why will nun check , when Police Inspector has given official report. It is common sense.
Heema22 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
Another great posts!! I love reading your posts. I get some stimulation to my tired brain.
I am in agreement with you!! This is absurd story!!! We know it but we keep hoping that it will get better and every day we get new shock !!! Writers must understand that viewers who watch HD are educated and prefer to watch HD to run way from Sas Bahu drama!!!
I am in medical field . During BT track , they wrote comedy !! I never met any one knows exactly on 30 th day their life will end !!! . Indira was going strong . She was doing dancing and working without any treatment . She even planned two weddings . I wanted to know what kind of Vitamins she was on !!
DNA testing was never questioned !! (specially after they found outs about MK ) someone must of have question this issue !! Fingerprints and 8 yr old is big joke !!

THE WHOLE MESS WILL BE SOLVED IF THEY TAKE DNA TESTE WITH ZARA AND KUTUMB OR INDER. Or LAHORWALY ,KUTUMB AND INDER. This mistry will be solved in one second , but I do not think so because CHOTI HILTER NEEDS TO BE GLORIFY !!!
aliveangel thumbnail
Groupbie Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
i loved reading this topic.
sakshi1 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
Beautifully written and apt title. Now this has become unbelievable and unacceptable. Finally I am thinking or came to the conclusion who ever is Indira will eventually end up with Rishi and who is Zara will go to serve the nation. Until then we audience will be in roller coaster ride.

One thing for sure, Rishi will help that LW to be back to normal. In this process I think Zara, Indu will also help.

I don't have any hope on this sharmas.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".