Another Theory ::: Plz comment

Ok so I was thinking that

In harry potter and the chamber of the secrets
we find this conversation when Ron and Harry have taken the polyjuice potion and they go to the Slytherin Common Room

"Yeah. . ." said Malfoy. "Luckily, they didn't find much. Father's got some very valuable Dark Arts stuff. But luckily, we've got our own secret chamber under the drawing-room floor

So ... IF voldy could give Lucius one of his Horcrux(The Diary) then why not the other...and he might have hidden it in that secret chamber...

What say ???

i thnk Voldemot wud hav wanted thm scattered as far as possible, so Malfoy would have ended up with only of the Horcruxes... 😊

i don't thiink soo buh niice theory 😛

Yah! Its a good theory but, I think that Volddy would have placed em in random but protacted places. I don know but, it jus dosent seem right that Volddy would put 2 horecurses in one area.....

-Aastha

hmmm
well the ring (a destroyed horcrux)was found in gaunts house this held high importance to voldy as this was his ancestors house, not forgetting his magical side of the family,
we later discover the locket (which happens to be a fake) foudn in the cave where voldy went as a child a plce where he terrorised children, again the setting has connection to his past

therefore i dont belive that he would hide a prt fo his soul in malfoys house especially since has it has been highlighted over and over despite hw much the death eaters protest to them beong his so called frends voldy doesnt have any, and im sure just as dumbledore was that he would hate to rely on anybody even the malfoys as support

but the diary i hear u protest, well if u remeber correctly the diary tho was passed to malfoy to guard it was given wth strict order do not [ass on untill tod otherwose by voldermort malfoy being so arrogant felt he'd pass it on now and then he'd be valued higher amonst the rest....
therefore again all the horcruxes which regard importance to him n his lfe as do the places in which he keeps them

i agree with goody2shoes....voldy puts all his horcruxes in a place tht is from his past or has some importance to the wizarding world...oh and recently i thought abt wht if he put a horcruxes in grinotts (however u spell it!) bank....everyone always said tht grinotts wht the safest place other then hogwarts, well now it has become the safest place seein tht dumbledore isnt alive anymore....oh and does anyone else believe tht harry is horcrux....???

I agree wid the Gringotts theory since Gringotts is special however i doubt Lucious Malfoy has another one of his horcuxes... 😳 Bec voldemort wudnt risk having only Lucious keep his Horcuxes. 😊