DOTW: Does Voldemort deserve death?

Eloquent thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

Hullo fellow Hogwarts crazy cats! (n dogs) It's time for another DOTW..😃




It's time to debate upon our dear Viewbie Siriusly's(coolniyu) sweetheart...😆😆😆 AKA... her Voldey poo😆😆😆

Well, Voldemort is the villain of the story...the one which we all love to hate (except niyu ofcourse)...

He's committed too many atrocities, both against magical n muggle folks. He has killed, tortured, enslaved, forced, poisoned, cursed, hexed, befuddled....too many people to count!

Moreover...he has surpassed normal evil acc. to Dumbledore(if evil can, in any way, be normal that is)

He has killed and has used it to his own twisted advantage..he has made not one or two but six Horcruxes in his quest for immortality!

So...do you think Voldemort deserves to die after all these things he has done? Bear in mind that, no one, absolutely no one, deserves to die...

But Voldemort has far surpassed being a 'one' ever since he split his soul. And yet I think that death would be too sweet for him...he deserves to be destroyed(if he isn't already) and defeated.
Yet as Dumbledore said in OotP, 'There are other ways of destroying a man...rather than death. [ 'We both know that there are other ways of destroying a man, Tom,' Dumbledore said calmly---OotP]

And to top it all, I don't want Harry or the others to kill anyone...

So what do you think?
Do participate!😃





Harshu, Niyu, Manshi, Khushi n Sam
HP DEV Team
Edited by Naughty_n_nice - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

2.1k

Users

20

Likes

2

Frequent Posters

friskysam thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
i dont think voldy deserves death...

my ideal punishment to him for being such a baddy is

let him be immortal but his magical powers shld be snatched from him i.e. he shld become a muggle

it wld be more dreadful than death 😈 ...beleive me 😊
tukz_REmix thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
of course he deserves death..but not too soon...1st he shud b tortured nden death.....crucio shud b used 2 him a 100000th times a day......den dey shud kill him....n den iwil b happy n so will b harry..... 😡
daisyUSA thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
well he is/was already living a life worse than death when he had no supporter until wormtail found him & nutured him back to his health....plus he is so power hungry & evil that he got Albus dumbuldore killed for his own greedy reasons that I think he should get a kiss from dementors....but wait that guy has no happiness that can be sucked out of him..or his sole happiness lie in killing harry....I think then kiss of dementor followed by any prison which is more hardcore prision than Abrazine.....where he is tourtured to be good to others & treat them nicely 😃 😳 😉 will be perfect than simple torturous death.
tukz_REmix thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: daisyUSA

well he is/was already living a life worse than death when he had no supporter until wormtail found him & nutured him back to his health....plus he is so power hungry & evil that he got Albus dumbuldore killed for his own greedy reasons that I think he should get a kiss from dementors....but wait that guy has no happiness that can be sucked out of him..or his sole happiness lie in killing harry....I think then kiss of dementor followed by any prison which is more hardcore prision than Abrazine.....where he is tourtured to be good to others & treat them nicely 😃 😳 😉 will be perfect than simple torturous death.

watz abrazine???????????😕😕😕its azkaban
coolniyu thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
awww ur too kind 😳🤗
neway i say he should be made an immortal muggle known only by his fathers ordinary name...n it wouldnt hurt to set someone like ethel of archie comics after him too..mebbe i could volunteer for tht 😳...n yeah we could send him myrtles favvie toilet seat frm hogwarts courtesy gryffindor's heir, whoever that is 😳

neway criusly.....

He doesnt deserve death...no,scratch that, death doesnt deserve him...
Somehow i cant think of a good enough punishment for him...he deserves much worse than death for what he did to all those people..and the idiot death eaters too ...
Unfortunately nothing is going to bring back the dead so whatever voldy gets in the end really wont matter
n yeah harry shouldnt turn killer just for voldypoos sake..james wouldnt have wanted his best friends to turn killer...so obviously he wouldnt have wanted his son to do it either..at the most harry can finish off the remaining horcruxes...that last living part inside voldys body deserves somethin else entirely..
Only remote punishment i can think of is that he is punished by his own victims...its mentioned in gof that voldy looked scared during the priori incantatem thing..hopefully something similar will happen in book 7...somethin to do with the locked room in Dept. of Mysteries perhaps?😕
Another thing i can think of is that ALL his followers turn against him for some reason?

whatever it is....wish he gets it good n proper,be it courtesy harry or someone else!!😉 n ill be ther with him of course 😳 my shweetuuuu 😆
bewafa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
as everyone has said before me...Death is too easy. too 'sweet'.

he deserves something far worse...like living a life of immortality but as an empty shell....the dementor's kiss has been suggested...

how painful must it be for voldy to live forever, and to only have the memories of his failures...and also actually be unable to DO anything coz he'd just be an empty shell? aaahhh....if only.

but yeh, noone ever says to "kill" voldy, it's always "defeat"...which could mean so many things. maybe it will mean that the dark lord will be defeated but Tom Riddle will survive? *shrugs*

the other dark wizard that has been "defeated" before Voldy...Grindewald...(by dumbledore)...it's never been explained if Dumbledore actually "killed" him or just defeated the darkness within?
Like how that Warlock got rid of the Wagga Wagga Werewolf...(CoS...Lockhart taking credit for...)...which seemed to allude to the fact that he got rid of the werewolf and didnt actually KILL anyone...

and anyways, the only sureshot way to kill sum1 is with AK...and noone from the Right side will use that...*sigh*

Damn it, we're all gonna have to wait!!! What are other possible ways other than Death to punish someone? to live with one's failures forever? coz i do believe that immortality isnt a blessin but a pain to live with...(if u pardon the pun 😆 )

So yeh, getting back to the question...No, Voldy dusnt deserve death, he deserves something else...
btw Wormtail also deserves some sort of horrible thing...coz regardless of what he does to help Harry in book7...he was heartless...my poor Sirius!

Ena 😛
nitin_dave thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
Volddy sertainly deserves death 4 the sake of all the people he has murderd.. I know I do not sound very nice but think of all the people he killed many tortured.

N 4 the sake of all those people Volddy should be killed n wiped from the face of this earth...

(lol I sound like a poleticans 😆 )
-Aastha
username88 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
he shud b tortured 😈 by snatching his magical powers n send him in the muggle world...so he wont b able 2 come bak in da magical world😃
FollowYourHeart thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10
awesmee topic to discuss 👏 👏 👏 and newww i didnt knw u loved voldyyyyyyy 😲 🤣 i hope my twinny is not with you coz i hate no rather despise or rather am simply and totally disgusted by him....

well i know all of you feel that he doesnt deserves death but i have a different opinion here...through out the book its quite obvious that the one thing which voldemort fears the most is death....that was the main reason he wanted to conquer it, that was the main reason he wanted to split his souls and made horcruxes, infact that precisely was the main reason which motivated him to turn to a murdrer, i feel that had he not know murder was a passport towards imortality, he perhaps wouldnt have done it, atleast not at such a young age as of tom riddle, this obsession of imortality made him evil to an extent that it could no longer be termed evil it had very well crossed that simple understandable term....

he feels hes the most powerful coz he can so easily perform the killing curse without batting an eye. the only curse which doesnt has a counter curse, according to him there can never be more pain than death and he seaks sadestic pleasure by the looks of fear and plea in the eyes of his victims...

but honestly, do u realy feel that the AK curse is more torturous than The Cruciatus curse?....all the AK curse ever does is emit a green light and within seconds you are enveloped in it and thereby putting an end to all miseries,,,but Cruciatus is a living hell and thats wat is more horrendeous and evil....but voldemort has a different opinion....to him the AK curse is the ultimat weapon the epitome of power...and i personally do want him to see that curse coming stright at him though he wld be scared for just a split of a second but the force of that fear would be neough to seve him for all his deeds..just i wish that alongwith fear he has a pleading tone too a tone where he finally accepted defeat....i feel death is the only punishment he deserves coz even after returning to power he had flaunted that yes he was worse than alive for 13 years he suffered pain beyond expressing BUT STILL HE WAS ALIVE....and this thing instilled him to fight and nayhow come back again.....this is his strenght as well as his biggest weakness...and thats where harry is got to strike

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".