Doubts & Discussions about HP book Series - Page 10

Originally posted by: Surya_krsnbhakt

Now now Draco, play nicely...

Originally posted by: Quixotic5

So u have a new name for me here too.. Draco ? 😳.. what happened to previous ones ?..hmm..i do vaguely recall them, egoistic, taamsic ( ok that was Sherlock) , non-believer,unitellectual..etc..etc..

Am i being a bad host again ?.. . i didnt c that happening.. 😕

BTW, would love to know ur take on "Felix Felicis" & "Dumbledore's puzzles".. so please, by all means, feel free to do so..

Originally posted by: Surya_krsnbhakt

You don't get subtlety do you?

I didn't call you anything like that..

And since I am too lazy to read the Hogwarts essays (😛) you guys have written in the previous page, you have to tell me the Sankshipta Ramayanam.😛 (Means Summary)

Originally posted by: Surya_krsnbhakt

Felix Felicis:

Ok are you serious? DO you really think that Voldemort could be defeated by Felix Felicis?? Dude, that's like saying I'll say my prayers before the Maths exam. Sure prayer helps, but you need to have studied.. and Voldemort = Trigonometry^70

And, if assuming Felix Felicis was the solution to the problems, and that old Dumby Dumbledore didn't leave behind a stock of the potion... you think he would be that daft to not use it himself?

Ok, now coming to the WHY part of it.

1. This is Voldy we are talking about. Not some toothless old Wizard who was imprisoned in Nurmengard.

2. Felix Felicis cannot destroy horcruxes. And if you are saying it will help them think better... well, they have Hermione.😆

3. IT takes six months to make.. just imagine, Harry will be like, "Come on we have a mission to complete!" Dumbledore/Hermione, "GIve me six months. I'll make this huge batch of Felix Felicis we can all use." That seems pretty dumb, don't you think?😉

Originally posted by: Surya_krsnbhakt

Dumbledore's puzzles... well to draw a relatable analogy, what if Vishwamitra took Rama and Lakshmana from Ayodhya and said, "Go kill Ravana." Would it have been right?

All the plans made by Brahmadev of making Manthara poison Kaikeyi's mind and fourteen years, and Bhrigu's curse to Vishnu, would go waste with that straightforward answer! Same thing here.

Plus, (I think you might be a little shocked), even DUmbledore didn't know all about the horcruxes. Sorry to break taht to you!

Originally posted by: Quixotic5

@ Surya

To be honest, i am not even sure if its the same Surya-Krsnbhakt that so effortlessly shot down most of my doubts in the Mythological Masti forum... its shocking really..i wouldnt surprised if somebody has hacked Surya's IF account & posing as Surya..i just cant c any other explanation o it.. ur presentation, interpretations are miles away from the Surya that i knew..i mean how could u miss the obvious things mentioned in my post..