Why Did She Do It? - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

107

Views

5.5k

Users

18

Likes

286

Frequent Posters

Dreamygal301 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: _nandini

But thn again some questions bother me ... This is the same Arpi who said Avi on her SR tht "Ab hum poori tarah se aapke huye" If a teenager is mature enough to undertsand the meaning of poori tarah se aapke huye .... then she also understands tht going to a man who has kept such conditions bfr her (be mine for a day) .... means she is going to loose her virginity now. Agree tht she had taken a knife for protection n prevention .... but she went on agreeing to all his needs. He asked her to give him the shawl ...she did, He asked her to make tea ..she did, He asked her to close eyes n come with him ...she did, He asked her to wear the saree.... inspite of seeing the bed n the decorated room n his intentions....she did, He asked her to sit near him...she did, finally he asked her to hav the dring ...n she did 😕

HI Nandini,🤗
I understand what you are saying but I really think Arpita was so confident in her ability to handle RV she went ahead. Off course it was stupid but she felt she could do that. Given what happened in the last few months, I think deep down she may have also felt a slight sense of grievence towards RV herself and thought 'oh he thinks I am coming to sleep with him but I will actually stab him!'. We had seen her changing from the uncertain girl to the confident woman who made her husband give up weapon on his own to the woman who encouraged him to fight back for justice (in that durga avatar in the market). SO let's say she was being really confident and off course she also feels responsible as she is the only one who fought for this marriage.
SO she comes and then does as he says because she wants to LULL him into a false a sense of security, to take him unaware but she is such an innocent and drank that juice otherwise she may have succeeded. SO that is where she failed and she did not even think of that eventuality. So her INTENTION was good but failed by her own actions.
As for her words to Avdesh on their wedding night, I think she is still his only > to me those words do not just mean her body being his, but her heart and mind as well as her committment to his family and home. She took this step because she was his WIFE, his life partner in his and his families happiness and sorrow. She wants people to have the love and happiness she and Avi have. So she thought she could handle this. But she knew, she was taking away something that was ONLY HIS, and her actions when she went to the room to see Avi before leaving showed that awareness and her sadness and bitterness.
See women in life have to face so many difficult choices, off course never as dramatic as Arpita with RV's offer. But often some of the choices does impact on our married life and relationship with husbands....we all make choices, sometimes we are confident, oh we can make hubby see our POV and or will deal with the fall out when it happens and etc. She knew Avdesh will be devasted but I also think she felt confident that their love will heal them in time.
Though off course I am still not happy about the track but I lay that squarely at the Cvs feet.
swamini5 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: mauve

@cb, will arpi be able to forgive herself ? Even when she realises nothing really happened ,will her self respect /pride Be completely restored?she doesn't deserve to carry these scars for life .(her intentions were right &she did hv sum half baked plan against Rv ,keeping aside the fact tht they were reduced to zilch).So I m with u ,not angry but sad for her. Her only redeeming factor ?? Av?? Is he up for it ?so,cum Wht may ,but exciting times ahead.

Mauve
He will definetly accept her.He does have EGO but in the right sense
He is a true BAHUBALI.As Dreamy said Arpi will have to go through his hatred.......
But I think Avdesh will get in to a shell than becming a BHAIYAJI again.
He is for sure to keep his promise given to ARPITA.
I don't think this time he will get iinfluenced by BJ
chatterbox thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#53
👏 glad u cud put ur point here dreamy

its another way of saying here what i wantd to say..

arpi wud regret her mistake and she wud still be guilt ridden
and as i said before also lots of circumstances do matter here
Dreamygal301 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: swamini5

Mauve
He will definetly accept her.He does have EGO but in the right sense
He is a true BAHUBALI.As Dreamy said Arpi will have to go through his hatred.......
But I think Avdesh will get in to a shell than becming a BHAIYAJI again.
He is for sure to keep his promise given to ARPITA.
I don't think this time he will get iinfluenced by BJ

Swamini,
yes Avdesh will turn into Bhaiyyaji again due to the betrayel he feels. He will question everything that comes out of Arpi's mouth now and he will say nothing good came from being nice and etc, so I will use my strength and force and no one can mock me!! He may even tell her why should i believe you anymore? you lie and etc!
SO in one sense I want to see him like this again but I don't want him to ignore her like he did before. Also he will listen to Bhootni again,....I still hate that puja thali scene, where Arpi came to give him the prasad and he ignored her and turned to bhootni instead!...but I guess this will be his way of punishing her.
talkie14 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#55
Hey Vistaa.. But why Arpita did what she did is an unanswered question in my mind.. I do feel bad for her but she brought it on herself & Forthe life of me I cannot understand why she kept giving in to all RV'S demands... The mistake was all hers & now she she has laid her 7 her husbands self respect & worth at his enemy's feet..Letz see how the story unfolds.. She should have confided in her husnand..This was a mistake & a costly one!!
Dreamygal301 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#56

Originally posted by: chatterbox

👏 glad u cud put ur point here dreamy

its another way of saying here what i wantd to say..

arpi wud regret her mistake and she wud still be guilt ridden
and as i said before also lots of circumstances do matter here

I'm glad V made this thread, saves me doing it!😆
And yes, she would regret, she was regretting before she even went to RV's. Poor thing was trapped but her own sense of confidence was her road to failure really. She now needs to lean and open up to Avdesh. For so long, she is focused on changing him that she never really talked about her ownself and the pain she is going through because I think she just didn't want him to feel guilty, she wanted him to change because he wanted to.
So once they get over their hurt, I think we may see Arpi talking more about her own feelings and insecurities. As you mentioned it all started at her maayka, she kept a lot to herself because no one there beside Mama would understand her and that kept on even though she married Avdesh because she realised she needed to be strong so he could change for the better. But who is seeing to Arpi being better internally and externally? she suppressed her own feelings time after time....
swamini5 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: Dreamygal301

Swamini,
yes Avdesh will turn into Bhaiyyaji again due to the betrayel he feels. He will question everything that comes out of Arpi's mouth now and he will say nothing good came from being nice and etc, so I will use my strength and force and no one can mock me!! He may even tell her why should i believe you anymore? you lie and etc!
SO in one sense I want to see him like this again but I don't want him to ignore her like he did before. Also he will listen to Bhootni again,....I still hate that puja thali scene, where Arpi came to give him the prasad and he ignored her and turned to bhootni instead!...but I guess this will be his way of punishing her.

Sorry Dreamy ....i think otherswise
I think AVi has moved ahead he has mellowed down a lot
Yes he will be Furious/angry .But some how Iam sure he will keep his promise
Thinking about all the Good things ARPI has done for him & his family & the sweet memories they had together.
BenNevis thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: chatterbox

hi swamini i had logged off

ok another point i wud say here

pardon arpi.. 😊
sorry vista i m adding my different view here in this post as i dont want to create another topic on this 😊

everyone is blaming arpita for all this fiasco or rather stupidity and foolishness.

let me all ask u one thing

in this age of equality when we say men and women r equal why shud a woman always be wrong or be punished.
if a man can go out and do a mistake or sleep around he is not guilty eh

bt if a woman makes a mistake whole world points a finger at her.

all say why did arpita not confide in her hubby or talk to someone else

when avdesh did his bhishma pratigya did he stop to think of his new bride who has all the desires for a loving married life. he didnt stop to think how it wud affect his wife.

then no one raises a point or rather ppl do forget and forgive his hasty action..

so why cant ppl forgive arpita for the mistake she made
she did wrong yes, she made a blunder yes,
bt its not that she cant be forgiven for it.

her intentions were not wrong even if her actions were wrong or stupid.

if i was avdesh i wud be heartbroken yes, but i wud understand why or what made arpita did this. and i would forgive her and as it is i m forgiving her as me 😆



and at the end of it its just a show thats all

this point was told in view of the current track and why i forgive arpita and not find fault with her actions. 😛

Hey CB😃
I really understand what u mean. For me Men & women are always equal whatever the matter is .
We are the same human being with same heart. God always made them equal. But the civilizations and the cultures brought some inequalities between them according to their mind .
But God has given the same conscience to everybody which cannot be seen but feel inside.
When someone going to do something , the conscience tells us whether its going to be good or bad.
@1st red
In our story so far the couple faithful to each other For the character of Arpi we all know her intentions never ever be wrong. But when u got married and u r in relation with some one the sanctity always matters. (Regardless of gender)Here Wife and husband must be faithful to each other, whatever circumstances they are living in , it does not matter. She knows what she going to do to her husband means she already committed the sin in her heart. But She got somany opportunities came on her way to talk to her husband and family members to sort it in different way still she kept evry thing to herself(may be over confidence about her plan) and done a grave mistake to c RV.she thought she wont let him to succeed in this plan but unfortunately she could not understand the evil RV who is much more dangerous than she thought.
As its story , the CVs want to show RV is not that kinda guy and did not touch her but pretending as if she really consummated by him. But in real world its not possible to c a guy not touching after the deal.What would every one say if RV really done something wrong with her?Still u say Avi deserved her? Marriage and love not just for protecting each other but also caring for other things too.
The morals , ethics and sactity is same for men and women.If some one wrong then they must be punished regardeless of age and gender. ye jindhagi ki ek aur sachayi hi paschathap se badkar koi aur jyadha punishment nahi hai. When someone repent for their sin or mistake , that makes their heart and soul bearing the heavy burden (feeling as if they could not bear it anymore) that brought by their mistake will be taken away forever. But the point is whether they are confessing it or not?Realising its a mistake or not?
But here Arpita still trying to wrap the things under the pallu(which is making me really angry about her), which is not really good for her, even after her husband asking what is the matter . Everytime she keep telling one lie after the other to cover up what she done. It seems to me it will bring the fall of sky on her head.
@2nd red
When it comes to Avi's First Pratigya we should not compare it with what Arpi has done with the deal. I still hate Avi for what he done on their wedding night . But later he realised what he had done and he wanted and trying to restore the things back (he immediately went to search LS and want to finish so that he can fulfill the wish of both sides,though i hate killing ppl as part of revenge).
Two situations are totally different . Avi was totally emotional fool , was not in his senses and was under intensive pressure from BJ and he done a mistake as he even thought about his newly wedded wife even for a second and later blamed her not supporting him.
The night before the wedding he took her outside to tell some of the things she didn't knew about him. He did tell her that his father and Brother were murderd by LS, but did hide that he want to take revenge from LS by killing him. Why did not he tell her about this before marriage?
This is one of the things happens in somany marriages thinking that after marriage evrthing will be settled down(keeping some secrets in the families) and he dont want to tell her coz he thought she will support in this matter or as an arrogant man he thought she has nothing do with that issue. The moment he take the P , I felt he would never ever become a good husband but he got changed his mindset towards Arpi after saved his life .He came to his senses after he nearly saw the mouth of death.. But he never unfaithful to her .(as he already broke his 1st P)., and me think he would never ever do such kinda disgusting thing in his life, even if Arpi left him forever.
As of now sanctity always matters regardless of gender and forgiving and forgetting the things behind makes them moving ahead in their life happily ever after.(its the samething for everyone)
Edited by BenNevis - 14 years ago
chatterbox thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#59
oh man i m so tired answering all

anyways i see it as a story and i think all r entitled to interpert their own ways

so lets wait and watch how story unfolds


BenNevis thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#60
CB
U dont need to answer all , just reading is enough to know eachones opinion.😃

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".