Originally posted by: kshah1987
AJ's problem is that he doesn't think logically. Yes Alisha is his daughter but he should know considering her acts and kands that she's capable of lying. it's easy to love and respect someone when everything is transparent. Trust should mean that even if there is clear evidences on the surface of something, things aren't always what they appear to be and if the person you claim to love and trust is saying something isn't right, the other person should be open to the idea that maybe they are right. AJ's claim of love and respect falls apart when guddan needs him the most. That's the crux of the issue. He easily goes against her every time this happens. I'm not saying he doesn't love her, i do think he thinks he does but love alone can't sustain a relationship like marriage when the other person has to continuously prove themselves to be right over and over again.
yes Alisha is capable of lying
100% right but what kind of father will thing that his daughter has faked a molestation & its not her blank words
he saw pics, he saw her waking up from nightmare --- how will he think his daugher will go to this extent
I repeat this again AJ has not "untrusted" Guddan
He has not said "I don't trust you" or "you are lying"
Yes, I agree Trust means to support one even when the evedences are against one -- 100% right
But are the evidences against Guddan ? has she been blamed for anything ? Is there any accusation on her ?
But here the eveidences are not against Guddan, the blame & accusation is not against Guddan
Its against Vikrant not Guddan
AJ have not done what you are saying, he has not untrusted her or broken any promise
Guddan is not proving herself right but Vikrant
AJ can support Guddan against all evidences just on her words cause he trusts & loves her.
But apart from Guddan's words what reason does he have to trust Vikrant ?
If this has to be then he should just go with anything Guddan says..
Its not about trusting Guddan but Vikrant
This has happened before like....
During Durga dahan, blame was on Guddan & he supported her blindly
Then they found proof against Angad
AJ believed it Guddan didn't
They had huge argument on this & at last AJ gave her ultimatum to prove Angad innocent within limited time frame or else he is sending him where he came from.
In that it no where means AJ didn't trust Guddan.
He trusted Guddan but not Angad on whom the blame was.
Now again he trusts Guddan but not Vikrant on whom the blame is.
Here the proofs & evidences are not against Guddan but vikrant.
He knew Angad had mental problem. Now he knows Vikrant is a player who plays mind game. --- I am not making this up, AJ said this.
If Alisha is faulty, Vikrant too has fault in his character which AJ knows of.
Edited by captainplus - 5 years ago