~ Discussion Thread ALL Version of GHKPM ~ #3 - Page 54

Again... this is the writers expertise ...

of interpreting and translating the source material according to target audience and bigger picture in mind.

Ghum fails spectacularly in that...

Translate bhi google se karte hai ye log

Virat’s character doesn’t have any boundaries since inception!! The way he called Pakhi his “pyaari cheez” even though she was already married to Samrat at the time! 🤣 Shruti kissing his hand...embracing and confessing her love for him...Pakhi holding his hand in cafe and crying and proposing himuff this guy..!!

Originally posted by: Moor278

Completely agree... I pointed this out because i felt it is significant that they are doing this early on...

With V as time passed... He changed and got more interested in Sai.

In Raghav they are making it clear that he has accepted this marriage right from day one. He is not moping around like V was...

That's quite different than ghum and they are doing this early on. Raghav in that sense is more clear and matured than V about his marriage and the whole deal scenario.

I think Inka confession ghum timeline se pehle ho jayega. 👍🏼

Is Surrogacy track main to V ka aur butchering hoga jitna Shruti main bhi nahi hua tha... I don't know what sadistic pleasure these makers get by writing him so badly. He is a lead and they treat him like a villain. Uska koi redemption koi growth nahi hai. Rather he is degrading day by day... Pata nahi kya problem hai inko....

ML can be a grey character but they are making him black 🤣

Originally posted by: nethraa_99

Why did you do this to me Moor? Bring in the writing.. This is my trigger point...you awoke the beast😆

Ofcourse these would make a lot of difference in the long run....it would have helped in sympathizing with Virat a lot more....whenever Sai failed to understand his love.

It is stupid to show Sai's insecurity by Virakhi blurring boundaries...they could have done it without such cheap stunts. The actual way to justify both Sai & VIrat's POV is to have an intelligent Pakhi...one who keeps her cards close to her heart...sly, but deceptively sweet ...which would make VIrat's failure in perceiving Pakhi's intention and manipulation understandable.

Here Pakhi's actions are so blatant...makes Virat look stupid. 🤔

And if they wanted to make Pakhi more sympathetic, they should have made her less vile...and also more vulnerable despite her cunning ways...maybe her parents die or she has only a sickly, widowed mother. Perhaps even make VIrat, Pakhi collegemates...will prevent audience from getting their ears burned from hearing friendship jaap for 2-day acquaintance..😵

PS: I fail to understand how professional writers can write such a shoddy script out of readymade material.🤔.

Nethraa remember when I used to translate KD for you guys, I told you that ROno getting influenced and manipulated by RK is so natural and obviou,. because of the way scenes are written & acted. RK herself looks convinced of what she is saying..It looked more of an impulse than a planned attempt. So during the whole Emon accident track, before she leaves home after anniversary, Rono and RK did not seem like they are teaming up, but they both were taking it all out on her, their issue, RK just convinced him that she understands him..Yaha writing, acting and physical distance is so apparent that makes you feel, ki ye Virat ka scene kya hai, does he still harbour feelings for her..With Rono it was clear, it was Emon for him, always , no Shruti, no RK. And he had his distance maintained physically and emotionally both.

Originally posted by: asmi_ekaa

Nethraa remember when I used to translate KD for you guys, I told you ROno getting influenced and manipulated by RK is so natural and obviou,. because of the way scenes are written & acted. RK herself looks convinced of what she is saying..It looked more of an impulse than a planned attempt. So during the whole Emon accident track, before she leaves home after anniversary, Rono and RK did not seem like they are teaming up, but they both were taking it all out on her, their issue, RK just convinced him that she understands him..Yaha writing, acting and physical distance is so apparent that makes you feel, ki ye Virat ka scene kya hai, does he still harbour feelings for her..With Rono it was clear, it was Emon for him, always , no Shruti, no RK. And he had his distance maintained physically and emotionally both.

To me, even in Ghum, it did not feel like Virat was still harbouring feelings for Pakhi in that scene..

But it definitely looked like they were both ganging up against Sai...Virat willingly accepted a crime partner...and took out all his frustration

I assumed it was the same way in KD too...but if it just happened in the flow of things..how differently it takes the narrative ..and also the merit of the characters

I am apalled

That's my whole point too...

Pakhi is not cunning... She is infact stupid... But she is sweet talker and manipulative in some ways...so she manages to gain sympathy for her.

Vo baki vamps jaise murderous bhi nahi hai. Zeher dena.. dhakka mar ke gira Dena types 🤪

I would prefer that type of Pakhi though .. a glimpse of what she showed in Ajinkya and Pulkit ka case...

Uske baad usko bhi mellow down kar diya hai. Probably to make her only seem heartbroken 😜

Isliye ye pura drama stupid and illogical lagta hai... She never moved on and V never doubts her intentions . Sirf Sai hi akeli samajhdar bachi thi... Ab usko bhi hormonal bana diya hai 🤣

Originally posted by: nethraa_99

To me, even in Ghum, it did not feel like Virat was still harbouring feelings for Pakhi in that scene..

But it definitely looked like they were both ganging up against Sai...Virat willingly accepted a crime partner...and took out all his frustration

I assumed it was the same way in KD too...but if it just happened in the flow of things..how differently it takes the narrative ..and also the merit of the characters

I am apalled

I am talking abt the scene where he berates Devi for Patralekha.. I mean Rono never did that. And Patralekha is venomous abt Sai...Very physical with her, RK never was.. She said the right things abt Emon.

It is very meaningless serial. please don't watch it.

Originally posted by: Moor278

That's my whole point too...

Pakhi is not cunning... She is infact stupid... But she is sweet talker and manipulative in some ways...so she manages to gain sympathy for her.

Vo baki vamps jaise murderous bhi nahi hai. Zeher dena.. dhakka mar ke gira Dena types 🤪

I would prefer that type of Pakhi though .. a glimpse of what she showed in Ajinkya and Pulkit ka case...

Uske baad usko bhi mellow down kar diya hai. Probably to make her only seem heartbroken 😜

Isliye ye pura drama stupid and illogical lagta hai... She never moved on and V never doubts her intentions . Sirf Sai hi akeli samajhdar bachi thi... Ab usko bhi hormonal bana diya hai 🤣

For me Pakhi could have been the most interesting character in the show. If performed well. I ended up loving RK after watching KD , the most. Because she was damn well, convinced me at times of her genuinety. She cried when Emon tried committing suicide, there were tears of regret, shame, of what I have done..And the moment she saw Rono getting close, she let go of that regret..The whole progression was so damn well done. Its not like she hated Emon, but she wanted to be the most important woman in Rono's life, exactly how I saw it. She was also not that cheap to harbour physical closeness, feelings for Rono, being his brother's wife . She would seek consent. Infact she was very graceful and had self respect. Rono also respected his brother too much to actually maintain that distance which was needed between the two. Also not to forget , she was not that disrespectful and you see discarding towards Badshah.

Pakhi has been reduced to a devar lusting Bhabhi. Devrani ki khoon ki pyaasi jethaani...I mean sad that they reduce women, to this, for men. They have reduced everyone, be it Pakhi or Shruti or Sai to not so self respecting women, for this guy. The women of the show are so badly written, so badly portrayed. Pakhi as a character inspired from RK, did not deserve it at all. She was educated, had good set of parents, had a good life partner. RK gave a good chance to her marriage and not forceful as you see here.. I feel bad for the character Patralekha. She was very dignified when she has a talk with Virat after he married Sai and when she also has a talk with Sai , while decking her up.

Exactly.. she was good in those scenes. She changed the moment she saw the lipstick 🤣