A humble request to all the Writers of Geet Forum - Page 14

Created

Last reply

Replies

373

Views

24.1k

Users

70

Likes

946

Frequent Posters

-Crayon- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
Coming to the question ,"Why read if you are not comfortable? or Do Not read that parts or FF!"
True ,but It's a public forum , isn't it? And people post their stories for everyone to read.
If anyone is not comfortable with something ,they can voice their opinion .
What's wrong in that? I guess it should be fine until someone gets very offensive while putting their thoughts forward. Otherwise it should be fine. People are just honestly voicing their opinion. 😊
sdlife19 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: tich.1990mg



yaar its sounding like we are the only hope for society, we only spoil readers mind,, readers are innocent who can't understand their good,, they can't take a story as a story but will point a finger towards writer only, jaane de in everything we will do all to entertain readers but will get bashed by them only... and when we are clearing our plot,,, they will say we are supporting a CRIME... Now i got why MG writers are quitting day by day,, when readers can't support teh writer why should they took so hard time just to make them satisfy,, i wil say stick to ur respective writers who are saints,, i said all this knowing i m nowhere in this still it effects me cz indirectly its pointing all writer who had shown that particular phase in their ffs, i m not outsider of that LOL😆

this is making me feeI so low as if i have made a crime
indirectkly pointing out to us for writing m reaIIy sorry but would ask my readers to point out whether my FF are favouring such crime and now me seriousIy thinking off quitting my work as i cant write when i feel i made a crime. though i have severe fracture on my right hand m commenting here as it indirectly pointed towards me and good tat i got to know tat we are wrong. w8uId reaIIy think very seriousIy now about my work.
but still i have question to aII here when u dont favour such thing than why do u read and like it do any writer force u for tat than why make us feeI tat we are committing crime.
i totaIIy agree with u tich...
maanugeetu thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: World-of-Dreams

Coming to the question ,"Why read if you are not comfortable? or Do Not read that parts or FF!"

True ,but It's a public forum , isn't it? And people post their stories for everyone to read.
If anyone is not comfortable with something ,they can voice their opinion .
What's wrong in that? I guess it should be fine until someone gets very offensive while putting their thoughts forward. Otherwise it should be fine. People are just honestly voicing their opinion. 😊


I have something to say here, there is nothing wrong in voicing out ur opinion par uske liye pm system bhi to hai. people are posting their stories in this public forum for everyone to read. whatever they are writing it is their choice. so it depends upon the readers whether they will read it or not.
it is the choices that we make which creates all the difference. if ur an intense passionate rude aggressive person u will definitely like dark love stories, but if ur are light hearted fun loving carefree then u will like such cute stories. so it actually depends on the readers personality, according to which they choose to read a particular story. if u have a problem then send a pm to that particular writer, why to make such a controversial post. i know it was just a general post what when it involves such sensitive issues then the concerned person should solve it in a personal level and not make generalizations.

really sorry if i have hurted u.
Dipti_Sam thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
sdlife19 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: maanugeetu

hey sorry for the late reply.


i understand ur point but totally agree with tich di, anshra di and most importantly sdlife19 di.

i am a student and a part time teacher and i too know much about the younger generation then any other person. i deal with them everyday.

today's younger generation is much more advanced then us. they only understand the language of facebook, twitter and youtube and they even talk about mills and boon stories.and BDSM. they simply do not need any permission to know anything.
even if our forum writers stop writing about these things they will find it out from other sources.
we come in this forum for entertainment. hum mein se koi bhi yaha bachha nahi hai. we deliberately come here and read the stuffs, woh bhi aapni marzi se. so lets not discuss about society and morality issues. we are here to enjoy maaneet 's true love and all ff writers are trying in different ways to show only one thing that true love can change even a beast and a monster. so don't take it otherwise. yaha rape issue ko koi bhi justify karne ki koshish nahi kar raha. we can't do that.

u said 90% of the writers are writing about these things, that means its a trend aur koi bhi trend one sided nahi hota. readers feedback mill raha hai, 90% readers are reading it.they want it. no writer in any forum is a heartless sadist who enjoys writing these things. i have read so many stories with such issues in it and i can tell u that the writers have punished maan so much ki kuch updates ke baad readers ne request kya hai ff writer ko ki aab bohut punishment ho gaya aab to maan aur geet ko mila do.
so only 10% have problem with it. i personally do not read detective stories, thrillers i do not watch ghost movies because i can't handle them.
so my point here is simple, those who cannot handle it don't read it.
there are hundreds of other stories where there is no adult content. read those.

in any forums according to a rough calculation, there are 500 to 600 max members who read fanfictions. it is just a small part of the society. hamare ff writers ke wajah se samaj nahi badle ga.the real power lies with the readers and not the writers. jab readers yeh sab nahi read karenge tab yeh trend apne aap bandh ho jaye ga.

so just trust the writers and simply read ff's as stories . don't take it seriously.
if i sounded rude, plz sorry. i never intended to hurt anyone.

thx dear
me aIso being a teaching faculty i know wat students know and believe me when they talk about some issues i have to ask thm wat the meaning of it.
none of the writers favour a crime like r*** here and blaming them for no use is injustice.
a person is brought up by values and morals he or she has and not by reading such things.
i personally read things on such stuff to stay informed as its necessary in life.
and i dont need to say again tat the teens here are much more faster than us.
tich.1990mg thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: maanugeetu

hey sorry for the late reply.


i understand ur point but totally agree with tich di, anshra di and most importantly sdlife19 di.

i am a student and a part time teacher and i too know much about the younger generation then any other person. i deal with them everyday.

today's younger generation is much more advanced then us. they only understand the language of facebook, twitter and youtube and they even talk about mills and boon stories.and BDSM. they simply do not need any permission to know anything.
even if our forum writers stop writing about these things they will find it out from other sources.
we come in this forum for entertainment. hum mein se koi bhi yaha bachha nahi hai. we deliberately come here and read the stuffs, woh bhi aapni marzi se. so lets not discuss about society and morality issues. we are here to enjoy maaneet 's true love and all ff writers are trying in different ways to show only one thing that true love can change even a beast and a monster. so don't take it otherwise. yaha rape issue ko koi bhi justify karne ki koshish nahi kar raha. we can't do that.

u said 90% of the writers are writing about these things, that means its a trend aur koi bhi trend one sided nahi hota. readers feedback mill raha hai, 90% readers are reading it.they want it. no writer in any forum is a heartless sadist who enjoys writing these things. i have read so many stories with such issues in it and i can tell u that the writers have punished maan so much ki kuch updates ke baad readers ne request kya hai ff writer ko ki aab bohut punishment ho gaya aab to maan aur geet ko mila do.
so only 10% have problem with it. i personally do not read detective stories, thrillers i do not watch ghost movies because i can't handle them.
so my point here is simple, those who cannot handle it don't read it.
there are hundreds of other stories where there is no adult content. read those.

in any forums according to a rough calculation, there are 500 to 600 max members who read fanfictions. it is just a small part of the society. hamare ff writers ke wajah se samaj nahi badle ga.the real power lies with the readers and not the writers. jab readers yeh sab nahi read karenge tab yeh trend apne aap bandh ho jaye ga.

so just trust the writers and simply read ff's as stories . don't take it seriously.
if i sounded rude, plz sorry. i never intended to hurt anyone.



dear a big hug to u for saying these things in so simple words, u said all without much effort still everything so clear, thanks for understanding a writer,, i m not saing only about me, but all writers will obliged to know the view.
tich.1990mg thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Dipti_Sam



huggyyy jaan i m glad ppl are still active when our show had ended so long,, hmm we always should try difference thing,,, start a super natural stuff i bet ppl will love it,, mera to book hain aur suru karungi to chappal se marenge sare, but i wanna read angel devil vampire or something like that, DEVIL is common now, every new writer is portraying a new devil but all their own way and i simply love each n every devil avatar of My Maanu



both already strt their BAKBAK without me here... huhhh

anyway, i dont read much ff, but mereko Tich ki update aisa nehi laga..
tich teri story koi s** relation ki tarha nehi hai,
teri story par pure love hai, friendship bond hai, betrayed hai, sab kuch hai...😃

n abt didu... mereko aapki devil sabse jyada HOT laga... bt my irresistible wala MAAN jyada pasand
as u know its my 1st ff i read n it just touched my heart... ❤️


hum samajh gaye 😆😆
but kya kare yaha hamari baat nahi horahi hain but still writers like me who had portray some scene that readers can't afford to read STILL they read and gets effected.
maanugeetu thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: sdlife19

this is making me feeI so low as if i have made a crime

indirectkly pointing out to us for writing m reaIIy sorry but would ask my readers to point out whether my FF are favouring such crime and now me seriousIy thinking off quitting my work as i cant write when i feel i made a crime. though i have severe fracture on my right hand m commenting here as it indirectly pointed towards me and good tat i got to know tat we are wrong. w8uId reaIIy think very seriousIy now about my work.

but still i have question to aII here when u dont favour such thing than why do u read and like it do any writer force u for tat than why make us feeI tat we are committing crime.

i totaIIy agree with u tich...

DI PLZ DON'T EVEN THINK OF QUITTING. U ARE NOT DOING ANY CRIME, KUCH LOG AISA CHEEZE PADHE TE BHI HAI AUR PHIR BURAI BHI KARTE HAI. SABKI PASAND KE MUTABIK LIKHNA ZAROORI NAHI HAI. SABKO KUSH KARNA ASAAN NAHI HAI. SOME PEOPLE TEND TO MAKE A FUSS ABOUT EVERYTHING. DO CONTINUE WRITING ATLEAST FOR UR LOYAL READERS. JINHE PADH NA HAI WOH ZAROOR PADHENGE. DON'T DO THIS TO US WHO READ UR UPDATES EVERYDAY. AND U ARE NOT COMMITTING A CRIME. DON'T THINK LIKE THAT. AISE TOH SAARE ACHHE WRITERS LIKHNA CHOD DENGE.

THAT IS WHY MERE PREVIOUS POST MEIN I POINTED OUT KI AISE CONTROVERSIAL TOPICS KABHI POST NAHI KARNE CHAHIYE. IT HURTS BOTH READERS AND WRITERS ALIKE. THERE IS A VAST DIFFERENCE BETWEEN PUBLIC AND PERSONAL DISPLAY OF OPINION, AND WE READERS HAVE TO UNDERSTAND THAT.

thanks a lot for liking my posts.

humna77 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
well after going through all this fiascoi just want to say one thingthat all the writers are feeling offended and they are trying to justify themselvesbut we are missing one point that what was the mainpurpose of the post? the main purpose was to voice out the reader point of view. parinain never meant to offend and blame writers but they are taking it as someone has personally blamed themand if u go through this thread u will realize that almost all the readers have sided with parinain. the reason is that many people including me was feeling this but was afraid to voice it out fearing the reaction of others.and i was right. by the reaction i can c what may have happend to me if i have written it. c problem is not about ruining innocent mindsproblem is that there is repititiveness int he ffsalmost every ff shows maan abusing or raping geet as a twist i love work of writers hereand i enjoy reading it but lately some writers just to continue the story are adding itand by some i mean only somedont we have a right as a writer to point out to our writerswhom we love so muchdoes it means we are loving u less?no it means we want it to be heard and we love and trust u so much to tell u what is in our heartinstead of sending pm sepreatly and undermining the spirit of writer it is better to make collective post about how one is feeling.expressing one feeling is it such a big crime?that everyone is pouncingesp when no bashing or harsh word was used in the post.please try to understand her percespectiveu people are talentedtake it as a challange and bring new cocnepts as anshra di pointed outinstead of showing rape as a twistno matter how much a person is repentinga girl can never forgive her rapistthat is unrealand by writing it u r not showing real facebut u r showing it something that can be forgiven.WHY ALL OF U WERE UNABLE TO FORGIVE DEV?why u all said its wrong how geet can forgive her rapistjust the fact that maan has done the rapedoesnt change the fact and no way he can be forgiven.ANSHRA DI u said some writers justified it.sorry but i disagree. how can this act be justified? plzz explian?by justifying u go away from rality not closer to it@anshra di. sorry for disagreeingi love ur work and u have shown no rapebut i dont agree with ur statementi hope u r understanding enough to understand my point of view and dotn bash me
and I KNOW U WONT ACT CHILDESS ENOUGH TO THREATEN THAT U R QUITING BCS OF THIS COMMENT
Edited by humna77 - 13 years ago
alwayzzgurti thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 2 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
Well Dear... I read the post, and was in a complete illusion..

and I do agree that...Rape scenes are being written in few ffs in recent times ...but I Do Have to Say Tis... U cant Say Rape is Not a Part of Real World...

I Read Daily in Newspapers and TV tat Rapes are HAPPENING...U CANT DENY THE FACT...

U can Even See the Segments about Physical Abuse in Segments of Savdhan India and Many Reality based Programs and Some Writer's are genuinely trying to portray this Grey Part of the Soceity... I dont think its an Offensive thing...

And Fallling In Love with a Same guy is portrayed only after he is shown he has repented his mistake... A REPENTED SOUL IS NEEDED A CHANCE...TATS REALITY...!!!!

and about Readers here...I do see Every Writers Giving a Warning Statement ...pointing about intimate matters...!!!!

And About the Adult contents portrayed, pls agree with me the word "SEX" is no more a component to be written in astrix...cos it has become a common fact, even today A CEO of a Big Chain of Hospitals, today addressed infront of 7000 students in my own college, among school students about SEX...sooo...when the soceity is pushing u to know somethings which may given u awareness, including such scenes is not a big issue...its my POV...

I Do agree fr some very intense scenes...but its not needed to be read when its indicated clearly, its not according to ur age!!!! Even a Google and Youtube gives more facts than these, its in the minds of ppl whether to see it or not...likewise..here also..if u want u can read...tats it!!!!

And last but not least... A MAN IS A SOCIAL ANIMAL...every man has a Good and a Grey Character within...and exploring only good things looks soo filmy...and some writer's are trying to bring some Grey shades, it should be appreciated...cos its the reality of the Soceity...!!!! i agree to read Maan as a Rapist is a sad thing...but is the Characterisation of His Character...and Touch of Reality is also needed, as the Real Maan in GHSP is also portrayed as a Women hatred, an arrogant person...

So i just wanted to say my POV... GF is a place to explore all ventures of human reality in form of ffs i believe... if its not aggreable to ur ethics, lets just ignore it..tats it!!!!

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: heart882 · 8 days ago

Hey Guys! I’m excited to be back after a long break and to dive back into my story. The Prologue is now posted, and Chapter 1 will be coming...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan · 1 years ago

OLD PART LINK https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5011127 https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5009334 new part on blog who want please...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan · 4 years ago

Do dil.....

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m · 4 years ago

This is the story of Maan Geet . The couple who love each other and married secretly . This story will tell their everlasting love, and...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts · 5 months ago

Hello everyone! I have come back to the forum after a long time. I have been planning a SS on Maan and Geet Amritsar track. The infamous part...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".