Will Neha Maheshwari please reveal herself EDT P1 - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

68

Views

9.9k

Users

46

Likes

425

Frequent Posters

sun29 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#51

when you go about printing a news abt a show ending .. at least make it look credible by confirming from the PH or channel or your so called 'sources'...this news is not like creating fictitious affair between two stars whom you randomly spot in shopping malls holding hands,...this news is big and can create ruckus and issues...this is the lowest form of journalism...and coincidentally you seem to pen the same words of our very own CA...hhmmm


if you can click the mouse and copy paste internet news..it would not take much effort to punch the numbers on the phone and at least try talking to the people involved and then publishing...



hegdemedha thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#52
Saj, I can think of two possible scenarios.

Caveat: These are mere speculations and have not been verified with anyone involved in the publication, directly or indirectly, of the story under discussion.

--

The reporter was probably constrained by word count and could not add any information about the source of the story and verification thereof. Yet, the brave soul decided to court the ire of *fans* (yes, that dratted species again) and publish the story to warn them.

Or, perhaps, the piece was edited to make space for Maaneet's photograph. For, the *fans* would have probably laid seige to TOI for publishing a piece about the alleged end of GHSP, unaccompanied by a Maaneet photograph.
Silentsoul thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: anks_ams


😆😆 🤣😆😆 🤣😆😆




😆 Narad muni of IF too...
RajeevGurtiFan thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: minnie.reet

Neha aunty (in disguise CA ) why u never gave any news abt RBO or other SO shows who have more less TRP than geet ?????

my question exactly...
-pixie- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#55
Posting from FB

***********************************************************

GO TO THAT LINK. DIRECT FEEDBACK TO TOI EDITOR.
Subject: Opinion.
Option: Grievances
Link the article in the comment box : http://timesofindia.indiatimes?.com/entertainment/tv-/Geet-to?-wrap-up-soon/articleshow/9137?068.cms.
Ask them why they are badmouthing the show. Is Neha Maheshwari taking money? Tell them to publish WITH SOURCES. Else TOI will have ZERO RESPECT IN YOUR EYES. Use your own words please!

pippa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#56
Thanks, pixie for the link.

There are enough 'sources' that are either confirming or denying the news.

But, one thing I don't understand about the GF members is this:

When the same lady wrote the article about GC's tattoo and her opinion about it, many Gurti fans basically concurred with her and said she knew what she was talking about. No one then demanded to know the sources.

But when she wrote about the show ending in September, everyone is up in arms about her lack of sources.

Once Star One released the news about its revamp, the days were numbered for all the shows on the channel.

And since they can't remove all the shows at one fell swoop, they have to start somewhere. Geet being 'targeted' must be a coincidence. There could many logistic and behind the scenes reasons for the news of the show ending first...we've already heard a lot about problems between the two PHs that are producing the show.

Did any one wonder if that could be it? The crew are leaving the show at a regular basis.
Star One is denying the rumours till they are blue in the face..it could be that the news of the show ending leaked out to the press before the channel actually wanted it to be known...so until the time is right, they won't issue a statement and has kept a gag order on all concerned.

Plus, Star News is a sister concern of Star TV,..how difficult is it for them to confirm the news...they are highly unlikely to shoot their mouths off only to get into trouble with their bosses! Which is what Star News did and probably are in hot soup for it!!

And before you all get angry with me, I have to say that my heart is broken to smithareens by this news. The show has been a part and parcel of my life since it began, especially because it entered my life at its lowest phase which I'm still undergoing. It gave me something to look forward to everyday in the last one year and 3 months. It's like my life line being taken away.

So, I'm upset as anyone of you...but we have to be realistic and understand that every thing that begins has to end.



Edited by pippa - 14 years ago
-pixie- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#57
Pippa: I dont hold ToI in very high esteem..as IMO its barely better off than a rag..but just looking at an article from a journalistic integrity angle- this article mentions no sources. Atleast the previous article spoke about some "source" close to the couple...this has NO I mean nada, zilch sources. So what does one believe? If you read the papers regularly, I am sure you what articles which have no sources are called- they either come under the opinions section or the editorials...they are not classified as field reports. I dunno where you read about fans concurring with Neha that the tattoo was real..as I have seen it on IF and FB- 90% of the fans think that the tattoo is fake..which is not what that article spoke about

We all are free to believe what we want to. We have access to same amount of information, you may choose to draw your own conclusions and I can draw my own afterall we are all thinking, rational adults here!
eminent thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: 810Kankana

Guys, i have something very important to tell u... jitna mera experience kahta hai , key sayed show ko ek ultimatum mila hai , like upto 400 to 500 episodes, then the channel will analyse the TRP ratings, agar tab TRP achha nahi huya then the channel will wrap up the show, but Productions cant say about these things, u want them to come forward & say something, but it is against the rule. Koi show ko wrap up karna naa karna Channel ke haath hai, Production house kabhi nahi chaahega apni show ko woh band kar de...guys, agar aapne notice kiya hai , no one from the crew or no actor is saying that GEET is ending, coz they cant say this. The show might just have an ultimatum upto Sep , aur iishi baat ko kuch log badha chada kar bol rahe hain...ultimatum milna koi badi baat nahi hai, bahut sare long running shows ko ultimatum milte rahte hain...its not a big deal. Koi bhi channel ek saath 500 se jayda episode ke liye contract sign nahi karta ,minimum 500 epi hone ke baad ek evaluation hoti hai, uushke baad hi show ko extension milti hai yah phir show wrap up hota hai according to the TRP ratings. So abhi se GEET end hoga yah uushe extension milegii kisse pata hai, so, guyss, chill, rona bandh karo, aur as much as possible show ki TRP badhaneki koshish karo...iishimein hum sabki bhalayee hai.



Thanks for the info...hmm perhaps they (Ms. Neha & CA) are trying to kill 2 birds with one stone? Gain publicity and at the same time Caution the ardent viewers- so we can, in turn try to 'save' the show?...
Ok..far-fetched I know, but it's a thought..Right? 😊

War of the TRPs... when will it end...? 🤔

Anyway I thought about this whole ending thing, ...And you know what?? So what if it ends??...Maan & Geet still and always will Rock the Telly world...
We all know GEET will go down as a Classic in telly history..Heck we'll see new shows popin up being 'inspired' by our show...oh wait a second... I think that's already happening...😆 ...woah...and our show hasn't even ended yet!! 😆😉
Sorry Pixie, just ranting..(I don't think the above paragraph still pertains to this topic...😳 It's 2:30am ...argh..need sleep!!)



sun29 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#59
@medha..trust me...if the confirmation or quote was provided by the concerned party ..it was impossible to edit it coz that gives the article credibility...and as for gaining information...she was not exactly predicting the end of world that the article had to be printed asap...the show which supposedly is ending in sept...enough time and resources to make it look credible...

@pippa..it is not about what a person interprets from the news ..it is about how you give the news...the tattoo article was exactly what CA said ..even then she did not find it necessary to clarify with GC about it but printed it ...and the reason much ruckus was not raised coz every other day actors and their lives are in the news for good or bad...but here the issue is different ...when you make such a claim ..it cannot be put under gossip ...you have to have credibility backing it...that is the base of all journalism...the news may or may not be true...but the reporting had loops glaring ...









pippa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#60
@pixie:


"Why would you certify your love unless there is trouble brewing for real?"

That's the line I was referring to when I said many fans concurred with her belief...not that the tattoo was real or fake.

Pixie, I do read the newspaper every single day and do know the difference between editorials, opinions and reports...mainly because I used to work for The Indian Express and the The Asian Age as sub-editor, field reporter and Features Editor.

The Times of India is the most read newspaper In India as you may know. However, its accompanying pull-out, The Mirror is a rag. This article seems have appeared either in The Mumbai Mirror or The Mumbai Times which is a rag too...the Mumbai Mirror comes free with the main newspaper in Mumbai unlike other parts of India

My previous comment was about the irony of certain pieces of news which are readily accepted and certain others that aren't.

Ye, we all do have a right to an opinion, pixie, that's why we are here.

As far as I can see, I didn't say anything in my post to get you all uptight.

I was merely expressing my opinion just as you were.😊

Edited by pippa - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts · 1 months ago

Hi friends There is a very old fanfic I had read on Maan geet some 12 years back It was on a blog The story was thst Maan was in coma. Geet was...

Expand â–¼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: aina111 · 4 months ago

Geet is NRI she came back india to meet her relatives where sh accidentally married with maan but maan loves another girl that girl him so he...

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".