Now who is stone heart:Mods note PG17&31

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Gagori Chatterjee

@jyoti06

Alumni

+ 8

Posted: 14 years ago

#11

Veena I respect your POV,but sorry don't really agree with the stone-heart part😊...

I think u r just not trying to see it from Geet's POV mayb because u r not too fond of the actor..but from what I hv seen both MSK and Geet r equally responsible for the separation....Any girl with a self-respect will leave the house after hearing words like "begairat and safed-khoon" coming from her husband's mouth and that too after she just suffered from a MC and was expecting love from her husband but instead gets only accusations.,..I m not saying Geet was right in forgiving Dev or playing holi with Dev...yes she was also wrong but her intension there was not wrong..she did it all thinking this will help her to start a new life with her husband if she cuts off all the strings of her past related to Dev...she did it for MSK's happiness....Fine I agree she should hv told MSK about it but did MSK ever bothered to ask Geet directly why she did it ??...he as usual saw few things and jumped to conclusion and in his anger ended up speaking some really hurful words about his wife and that too post-MC....so for me both r equally at fault for not able to communicate in a proper manner...so its unfair to call one person stone-heart and make other look like god...

Coming to yesterday's radio scene...MSK did ask for forgiveness and after that Geet cried her heart out hugging MSK ka photo...with that how can we judge Geet is stone-hearted ??😕...is the scene complete ??😕..do we know what decision Geet will ultimately take...or do we expect in one episode itself to see all of Geet's self-talks ??...just like MSK ,we too r jumping to conclusion calling her stone-heart even without seeing what the future episodes will carry and what will b Geet's reaction....

When Geet was leaving the house bidding goodbye to all the family members..what was MSK doing ??why din't he stop his wife that moment itself ??...it was only after Dev giving MSK a piece of mind,he realises his mistake,...why ??...so isn't there MSK too becomes a stone-hearted man who needs advice from a culprit to realise where he went wrong ??...

Like I said in a relationship ...taali ek haath se nahin bajti...either both r right or both r wrong..only then a relationship survives or goes kaput...😊...and in this case both MSK and Geet hv done mistakes and right now both r in realisation phase where we cannot pin point on one person and ask why...we need to wait and watch how the future episode unfolds before blaming anyone in particular...

Quote

veena

@..VeenaGcian..

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: temorocks
Exuse me, try to be fair and keep being u GC's fan a side, what Maan said to Geet is not something to just keep aside, he should go to her and begs for apologize, What do u mean by not 1% mistake? What if anyone calls u what Maan called Geet? Would u just forgive so easily? If u think Geet is so not caring, she would not had forgave him last time when he got angry at her without knowing the truth......

I am not blaming any of Maan or Geet, coz they r writers' imagination, but here is surely Maan at fault, he needs to control his anger and stop saying things that hurt......

She spoke to daadi and told her to forgive her as she can't stay after what he said, every woman with selfrespect would not stay a mint back, be fair........

Simply people r supporting the male blindly coz most of the viewers r female, this has nothing to do with who is right and who is wrong.........

I am female, I like Maaneet a lots, but here surely Maan is the responsilbe....

No fight. What i wrote is just my POV of current track. I feel GEET is at major fault for not sharing the truth with MAAN before forgiving dev and being a women when she can forgive her rapist, this is least i expect from her.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Renu13

@Renu13

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#13

When you love someone madly and he misunderstood you it hurt more than anything. I think you have seen that she was trying to tell him but he was not ready to listen her. Who is wrong at this stage.She never hide anything from Maan then how can he think wrong about her.

Quote

LuvGuruRati11

@LuvGuruRati11

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#14

pata nahi sab yeh kyun kehte h ki yaha par sab female fans maan ki side leti h blindly ek baat me bata du ki jo hum dekh rahe h hum usi ke baare me baat karte h.and is sab me geet ki he galti h to h ise aap log jhutla nahi sakte h.

Quote

veena

@..VeenaGcian..

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: RENU1111
When you love someone madly and he misunderstood you it hurt more than anything. I think you have seen that she was trying to tell him but he was not ready to listen her. Who is wrong at this stage.She never hide anything from Maan then how can he think wrong about her.

wow u say she was trying to tell??. when she tried to tell after forgiving dev. was she not supposed to tell MSK before forgiving dev. MSK never said those words by MU her. he said those words because he too was in pain that she forgive him very easily

Quote

LuvGuruRati11

@LuvGuruRati11

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#16

well said veena.he said those words becz he is too in pain.you correct veena.maan ne woh sab kuch mu ki wajah se nahi bola.maan to yeh jaanna chahta tha ki geet ne us idiot ko itni aasani se maaf kaise kar diya.agree with you veena.

Quote

Renu13

@Renu13

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#17

Go & Watch again that episode you will get the answer. (Holi episode)

Edited by RENU1111 - 14 years ago

Quote

veena

@..VeenaGcian..

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: RENU1111
Go & Watch again that episode you will get the answer.

You do that and u will get a better answer. i already have my answer

Quote

LuvGuruRati11

@LuvGuruRati11

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#19

yeh jo keh rahi h go watch again that episode hume uski zarurat nahi h.shaayad aapko uski zaryrat hogi hume toh sab pat h agrar aap bhool gayi h.so you go and watch again that episode.