Maan Justified...Slap Condemned. - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

73

Views

6.4k

Users

29

Likes

215

Frequent Posters

whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: mayurrocks

Varsa!! šŸ¤—This is amazing post!! You have pointed out the feelings from both sides and I just loved it!!! Especially your take on Behke Bheke dance and Maan giving his hand to Geet but later on going ahead with Ahaana suggesting he wont forgive her this easily!! Loved it!!! šŸ‘ šŸ‘

Thanks a lot. Mayur.šŸ¤—


I still feel he should have had a control over himself considering her to be pregnant, I mean last time he was violent with her before the dargah scene, he did not know anything abt her pregnancy.šŸ˜”

Maan knows he has a nasty temper and he was angry that's why he told Geet to go home...He tried to control his temper but could not and behave in such a manner....I guess he will also regret his actions later...because he has always bashed himself for hurting Geet.

However, Maan has always been like this-- at extremes!! He's romatic at extreme, angry at extreme, passionate at extreme!! That's how his character, the complexity, has been right from the beginning and that has what made us love him.
Wow ...Kya Baat kahi hai....BINGO...Every word should be highlighted..A BIG HUG FOR SUCH BEAUTIFUL WORDS>...šŸ¤—

goldenball thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#22
Loved your support for Maan... I also believe,, if Geet shows same kind of passion and love.. then things will be alright.. They hardly got time to build their relationship after confession... Dev disclosure came..
This is what I had posted recently on same.. (some ponits may now be out of context..)

Last few episodes are so good, I am have seen multiple times each one of them.. to understand what actually they are looking from each other..how CVs are going to conclude this whole tussle.. Is it when Maan accepting that Geet can survive on her own... then what.. will Geet come back to him... ?

But i feel there is another angle to it.. Geet wants to prove herself.. but what Maan is wanting from her... Will it satisfy him if he wins.. No i don't think so... Actually.. Maan wants Geet to love him and need him the way he feels for her.. The same craziness.. he is so vocal about his love.. in his deeds in his expressions.. But Geet is silent one,, not willing to express her love... This is what is driving him crazy.. and when she rejected marriage proposal, he is not able to take that she can just turn off..

So now what we see is he is coming very closer to her but not letting her touch and feel him... He is doing it on purpose.. he wants to run a test.. Does she needs me emotionally ?

and I feel that will be their meeting point... Geet will prove herself in the physical world that she can survive with out him satisfying her ego.. .. but emotionally she will express her craziness to him.. she will ask for his love as she cannot live without him,,, and that will satisfy his need..

whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: Rituparnaa

Thats the diff Varsa she can trust anyone else and she can take help from anyone else.
But poor soul Maan cant go that way.Now he cant be himself also.

That's what Daadi also feared...Kahi Maan aise andhere main na chale jaaye jahaan se woh wapas na aa sake....and Maan is a worrior...He was fighting for his love from his love but Geet's slap has pushed him back into darkness where he would not even he himself.
sksg thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#24
Varsha, You expressed feelings of Maan so well. It does appear that this is one time too many. He is like a volcano on the brink of eruption and until this volcano erupts, it can not go back to a calm state. His eyes are so full of pain. I really feel sorry for him.
sksg thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: whitepearl

That's what Daadi also feared...Kahi Maan aise andhere main na chale jaaye jahaan se woh wapas na aa sake....and Maan is a worrior...He was fighting for his love from his love but Geet's slap has pushed him back into darkness where he would not even he himself.



Don't lose hope girls. The love is still burning him. It has not yet abandoned him. In spite of all that has happened so far, it has not yet reached the point of no return.
whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: goldenball

Loved your support for Maan... I also believe,, if Geet shows same kind of passion and love.. then things will be alright.. They hardly got time to build their relationship after confession... Dev disclosure came..

Thanks GB..
This is what I had posted recently on same.. (some ponits may now be out of context..)
Last few episodes are so good, I am have seen multiple times each one of them.. to understand what actually they are looking from each other..how CVs are going to conclude this whole tussle.. Is it when Maan accepting that Geet can survive on her own... then what.. will Geet come back to him... ?
I am sure they will give some logic to this drama...I just hope they have a strong grip over it...otherwise they will be in great soup...But I always trust CVS...They have made us sad and they will make us smile also.

But i feel there is another angle to it.. Geet wants to prove herself.. but what Maan is wanting from her... Will it satisfy him if he wins.. No i don't think so... Actually.. Maan wants Geet to love him and need him the way he feels for her.. The same craziness.. he is so vocal about his love.. in his deeds in his expressions.. But Geet is silent one,, not willing to express her love... This is what is driving him crazy.. and when she rejected marriage proposal, he is not able to take that she can just turn off..

Loved your POV....šŸ‘Geet's love need to be vocal...She should also have the same caziness to match Maan's love.
So now what we see is he is coming very closer to her but not letting her touch and feel him... He is doing it on purpose.. he wants to run a test.. Does she needs me emotionally ?

and I feel that will be their meeting point... Geet will prove herself in the physical world that she can survive with out him satisfying her ego.. .. but emotionally she will express her craziness to him.. she will ask for his love as she cannot live without him,,, and that will satisfy his need..

Well said GB......I also think Maan only wants to make her realise that she also love him unconditionally. The parts highlighted are SUPERB.

Fallen-Angel thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: whitepearl

This forum is again bustling with pro and anti views...Being a die hard Maan fan, I send my love to all those who supported Maan's reaction through this post....this is not a post meant to bash Geet 's slap because I personally do not see her slap as 'A SLAP'. Read on if you are Maan's supporter but if you are blindfolded by Geet 's reaction then venture at your own risk..

Geet fell in the pool and Maan saved her yet again....I wondered why Adi did not jump to save her?...well so it is proved that it is nobody else's but only Maan's prerogative to save her every time. See destiny has forced Maan to be her savior....So Miss high and mighty destiny what is Maan?...Geet's bodyguard???....Wonderful! What a job assignment for the person who deserve all the love and respectful of the world. Poor savior! He does not even protest because he thinks he is doing the most honorable job...What a hallucination?

Yes, hallucination is what Geet always cast on him.....he saved her from the pool...he looked into those deep eyes and lost himself. He forgot that same eyes had insulted him and mocked at him so many times in past two weeks...but today on the contrary, was he seeing admiration for himself...Geet realized that this is how she has always felt safe in his arms.....this is how they have met....Maan also remembered the same....There in HSP when he carried her out of water he was not looking at her...he was rude and indifferent..he just dropped her on reaching at the shore but here he very slowly and gently carried her, not breaking their gaze....lost in her eyes...he glanced around and was least bothered at people staring at them...he continued to look deep into her eyes...he put her down on her feel very gently and slowly...with absolute calmness....Geet was also satisfied and comfortable..she though that storm has calmed down....but her blurt stirred Maan's control once again..."hum aisi hi pehli bar mile the."...Maan was shocked and he jerked her away. Instantly, he became defensive thinking after all the sourness how can she act so normal?.....did she read his feeling yet again...is she mocking at the way he feels in her presence? if so, he will not let her do anymore drama...."Circus is finished"...yes Geet has made a circus out of his like. She has made his love look like a circus.....a tamaasha. He has danced on her tunes for long enough..but now he will not repeat a railway station or a manali mall scene where he proclaimed his love putting her self-respect his prestige all at stake...He will no longer let Geet treat him like circus ka sher...enough is enough. But Geet on the other hand was also shocked. She took this dialogue upon herself....She remembered all the hateful things that Maan told her and decided to talk to Him.....An intligent move Geet, I must say. But your reasons for which you were trying to clear the situations were wrong...she said to Pinky and Adi that Maan cannot just insult her or be her God whenever he wants...but darling Geet are you not doing the same. Haven't you treated him like a doormat... why the big cry? You have been always the beneficiary and Maan been the benefactor....Pity your relationship never turned into an equal partnership. Kyun kis ko bardasht kar raha hai..Geet?...why are you tolerating this if you are so disgusted...just leave and go... why do you want an answer...and as my friend Kashish rightly say why should he explain anything to you?...

Come on Geet grow up girl....try to understand him.....If you are hurt how can he be fine?....I loved the way Pinky and Adi tried to put some brain into Geet but hamaari Ms..Handa...apne aahe to kisi ki sunti hi nahin. Bas apna dard ...apna gussa...apni takleef dikhai deti hai.

Party was in full swing but amidst all the shor sharaba, Maan was standing all alone raging over the their sour relationship that is slipping out of his grip....Mujhe tumhare aasoon se, ya muskurane se farq nahin padta Geet...and then his again lament over his lost love...why Geet .....why have you changed..you were not like others....

Ek tum hi toh thi jo mera dard samajhati thi..

tumhi to thi toh thi jisne mere hontho ko phir se muskurana sikhaya

tum hi toh thi jisne meri aakho ko sapney dekhne ke liye uksaya

tum hi toh thi- mera dil, meri ruh, mera saaya

phir kya hua, phir kyon nazari churai, kyon Geet kyon?

Geet found him near the bear bar....she coaxed him to speak up but Maan kept quite...He was confused as why she has come looking for him? Why can't she leave me alone?...He was sad..He did not know what to speak for he knew if he would open his mouth; his pain will come out... He tried to avoid her and commanded, " gar jao Geet"

kab ka jal ke khaak ho chukka hoon

Ab toh is dil se mat khel ai zaalim

kahi tere hi haath jal na jaaye

is raakh main sulagte angaare abhi baaki hain

As is he was saying, "Don't come near me..I am all charred Geet...you will get nothing but ashes of my love. I don't want to hurt you Geet Go away ....Go away before you burn your fingers....Can't you see the fumes of my unanswered prayers,...can't you smell the foul of unfulfilled wishes, can't you hear the shattering of my broken dreams....I am left with nothing but this everlasting fire that I have chosen for my self and nothing but this eternal hell that you have imposed on me..."

but Geet had come for an answer....she insisted upon but Maan avoided again...."Agar tum ab tak nahin sanjhei toh ab kya samjogi:...I was so moved by the pain in his voice complaining ' Have you ever understood me Geet?

Geet could only hear his anger..... 'What are U trying to prove by insulting me in front of every body?"

Wah! Wah1 Geet...mujhe ek sher yaad aa raha hai tumhaarey nazariye pe.

woh qatal bhi kare to charcha nahi hota

hum aah bhi bhare to badnaam ho jaate hai

Geet I know you are hurt the way Maan is behaving but girl kisne kaha hai tumhai sulagti aag ko hawa do....

Maan was speechless for once...How can he reveal his pretend?...No way he is not going to tell he is hurt...He will not reveal his wounds to her and if she can't understand him without him saying a word then she should better not understand him at all.... He was thinking for an excuse to avoid Geet's such direct question.Then Geet and Ahaana had a little convo-counter where Geet said ---as you sow so shall you reap...Well !Well! Well! Geet dear, so you understand what this proverb means...You are angry with Ahana....or with Maan or with both?.....Keep it up babes soon your anger is going to blind you. Maan senced Geet's anger and he looked at Ahana with disgust...He offered his help again but she refused...Okay girl you have a self respect...Good. But it always props out at a wrong time....

Ahana invited Maan on the dance floor..He refused....His whole being was dancing at a very different tune right then which was not enjoyable at all. He was still looking at Geet with complaint in his eyes and was thinking for a way out to avoid any sort of discord with Geet and Ahaana gave him one....He grabbed the opportunity and moved away least he say another hurtful thing to her....

But with he cannot resist himself showing how much he missed him during the dance. Never once he could keep his eyes away from her. He strode towards her with authority, extending his hand to her...first time his eyes pleaded with tears in his eyes...She also had tears showing her dilemma whether to accept it or not...Her hurt was quite evident so was his...Maan wanted to made her realized that he had extended his hand like that to her but she refused...but now even if she wants to she won't be able to get his hand so easily. ...She can't just reach out and have him...He brushed her while dancing telling her that this was close they were...Geet knew exactly what he was trying to show to her but her heart sank when he lifted Ahaana up...He reminded her this is how he always lifted her up in every situation of life.......She could not bear it....tears rolled down her cheeks so she went away..

Instantly Maan left Ahaana ....Ahaana was just a prop for him....He stopped Geet and confront her this time....Geet ab sulagti raakh main haath dala hai to angaari lagainge hi...

After this what happened was the collision of two broken stars...both crossing each other's trajectory.

Maan was angry...Geet was Jelous...reason behind then was same....Unspoken Love.

Geet tried to walk away but maan pulled her back...But Geet hit the epicenter again....Kyon apna tamaasha bana rahe hai...why are you doing something that you know is wrong.....then again Everything that has happened is wrong...everything that is happening is wrong....Good girl So after all you have realized the pain that Maan is going through....and it hurts you too..So word it girl....say it. Don't run now!...

Geet stirred the flickering ash and he flared up ...all his pent up feeling just came out in open...You cannot see me with other girl....You don't like when I give importance to somebody else...you cant stand my nearness to other girls....Maan wanted Geet to openly accept that she was feeling jealous.....he touched the epicenter of her pain...She was shocked...she pushed Maan "leave Me"....Maan pulled her back into his arms..."Tumhe farq padata hai Geet...when I don't come near you....when I don't dance with you..."..Maan kept stirring her. He wanted Geet to react and accept that it does affect her. This angered Geet furthermore ...He tried to push him but he pressed her against himself and forced her into dance..... Maan misbehaved... and it ended up in a slap... Geet also misbehaved.

Wow! Miss Geet khud ke haath jale toh chaata aga diya.....Kaha tha na mat chedo...Adi ne bhi samjhaya tha.....

But to me that was not even a slap...it was not preconceived like you slapped Dev. This slap was out of defense...well when you can't attack you have to defense..and the moment Geet did it she knew she has done the biggest mistake of your life...You were a winner when you slapped Dev...but you became a loser when you slapped Maan...a person who has been your saviour, your defender....Pyaar nahin toh ahsaan hi mana hota uska...A Slap should be an answer to every roadside romeo but he is your love..how could you slap the person you love even if he wrong? Agreed he was just forcing you to dance. but why did you react so sharply.. He not attacking on your izzat......He had forced you to dance on kurbaan hua.....which you enjoyed and still remembers but today you've crossed your limits dear Geet. How can a truthful girl like you do be so unfair...Please Geet don't lose your goodness...be wise..think twice before you act...See what anger can make you do..you were angry on Ahana and bechara Maan bali ka bakra ban gaya...Maan to gusse main bhi tumhe nahi maarta tumko. He knows how toshow his anger in the right volume..but you have still not learned to rein your anger.

Just imagine if Maan would have behaved in the similar manner when Geet said aapko farq padata hai...Actually he would have given you a tight slap on that day in front of board members.....and made you realize your fault. par Maan to Maan hai...abhi bhi kuch nahin kahega..bus 'walk out' karega.

If wonder if even your tons of kisses and hugs would ever wash away this act of yours.

And Maan dear you really have made a tamasha of yourself ..why for a girl you are spoiling your image...why are you hurting yourself just to hurt her....Is she worth it? Oh! Yes...For you she worth a life...That's your love.


Sorry for the long post friend...I promise next time I won't write such long one..but today I just could not hold myself back. Please bear with it.



I agree with everything you have said , you have made some sound points. šŸ‘
I feel Geet has never understood Maan otherwise she would know he's really hurt and why he's behaving this way. I hope the slap doesn't make him go over the edge and completely lose it.


whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: sksg

Varsha, You expressed feelings of Maan so well. It does appear that this is one time too many. He is like a volcano on the brink of eruption and until this volcano erupts, it can not go back to a calm state. His eyes are so full of pain. I really feel sorry for him.

Well said....What all this lava will burn...????😭 BTW I like your line...PURE LOVE IS ETERNAL
Edited by whitepearl - 14 years ago
shaz01 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: whitepearl

Agree shaz...as Ritu said...Maan has become what geet had made him....
I will only feel better if tonight Geet shows some sense and ask for forgiveness....or show some remorse on her action....
Its not that I do not feel Geet's pain but A slap was objectionable..so I made this post.
Well call me pearl or varsha...whatever you like.
Glad I found one more buddy today.šŸ¤—

Hey varshašŸ¤—
hav u seen the new SBS...from the office scene...it seems that Geet is def not going anywhere (as i had hoped) LOL...but she will try and manaofy Maan...eager to see this new angle nowšŸ˜†
Geet should definitely show remorse for her actions because as far as I know...I dnt think Maan is at fault here...Geet started this whole thing and he was a victim of her misconceptions
He couldn't understand what he had done so wrong that the only woman he loved with his heart and soul left him......aur phir woh bas isi confusion and anger mein ulajhte gaye and it became too much...
Who can blame him?? I surely can't...
Edited by shaz01 - 14 years ago
mehraan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#30
lovely post varsha!!! wen i read ur post it makes me feel relaxed n positive though i hve always had supported MAAN during the preg issue, n then the MUS....after watching yesterdays epsde several times one thng tat hit me really hard was the line MAAN says agar tum ab nahi samjhi to kuch nahi ......tat was really painful...MAAN many times tried 2 make geet realize her mistake, how much she has affected him, the pain he is undergoing.like the time he said in the office bolne ki chakkar mei sochna bul jaate hai...agagin there he hit her hard bt then geet wuldnt understand wat he is pointing here.... likewise geet said 2 him y did u call me here 2 insult me n the prty ....i was quite angry wen she questioned him..tis same thng applies 2 herw en she publicly made an issue in the office infrnt of his staff n also moreover the media!!! wasnt tat an insult, humilitation ????? the man who loved u unconditionally had 2 go thru all tis!!MAAN has always being arrogant, rude n shrewd..tis is from day 1 n tis is nothn new...he is trying 2 hide his feelings 4 her n he has always been like tat ..in his denail days wen he wanted 2 avoid geet...jus remember how many times he manhandled her...he is hard at exterior bt soft inside... yesterday 2 wen he was dancing..he kept a safe distance FROM AHAANA n his eyes were fixed on geet...he was trying 2 read her reaction as he always said her eyes always speak the truth n he cud read it...n the confrontation .. MAAN questioning her was rite , he jus wanted 2 hear wat he meant 4 her, his importance in her life, how much she loved him...he was trying hard so tat she cud blurt it out......bt then when he was manhandling her i felt pity on geet 2 wid the simple fact cos she is pregnant n MAAN shuldnt hve resorted 2 such a step, HE KNOS SHE IS PREGNANT BT THEN FORCEFULLY DANCING WID TWISTS N TURNS MADE ME SHIVER YAAR.. SERIOUSLY(I FOUND IT VERY S*XY, never seen anythng on tv screen like tis)...he was dancing wid her 4 sure bt like many who said rape n cheap...i dnt get the point of assoisating these thngs wid MAAN...in simple words he is wounded mentally, physically n most importantly emotionally....he jus needs 2 hear The assurance from geet atat no matter WATEVER HAPPENS BETWEEN US I WILL ALWAYS LUV U..... TIS WUD HVE DONE IT!! IM NOT JUSTIFYING THE SLAP NEITHER IM 4 IT......!
Edited by mehraan - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: heart882 Ā· 23 days ago

Hey Guys! I’m excited to be back after a long break and to dive back into my story. The Prologue is now posted, and Chapter 1 will be coming...

Expand ā–¼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts Ā· 6 months ago

Hello everyone! I have come back to the forum after a long time. I have been planning a SS on Maan and Geet Amritsar track. The infamous part...

Expand ā–¼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m Ā· 4 years ago

She met him in an unfavorable time when she was running behind the time to save him. Save the only one member of his family whom she call his...

Expand ā–¼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m Ā· 4 years ago

This is the story of Maan Geet . The couple who love each other and married secretly . This story will tell their everlasting love, and...

Expand ā–¼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mystic_Muse Ā· 4 months ago

Banner credit goes to @Quantom-Dot Summary Geet Handa, a successful wedding planner in Shimla, ispreparing for her own wedding with a charming...

Expand ā–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".