3 Idiots-Sach ka saath....Duniya di tha tha tha!!!

Page

Next Last

--Revv--

@--Revv--

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

Idiots' Tantra Mala

Chamatkar ya Balatkar'idiots ki tantra mala....

Considering that we are all idiots and we need some semblance for we have a pool of writers, analysts and observers, who contribute to increase, improve and help our understanding Geet the serial, characters, plot and other aspects and symbolism in the story. We have people who find elements like water, color and let's not forget inanimate objects like dupatta in their analysis.
So here is the tantra mala for those who don't understand so much Hindi it is a system well it is not idiot proof for it is for idiots..

Tantra

1.The first post is the TANTRA Mala

2.The second post is the Index & Spoilerz

3.The Third post is for the ROTA

4. Topic opener's post

4. The first FOUR pages are for analysis ONLY as it gets lost in the pages later on. We have received requests for this.

5. Once the reserve of spot is done within say the first hour, the thread is then open for discussion and replies.

6. Anyone who misses the boat on first three pages to analyze the episode, should send a pm to the opener to index the link so that people find it easy to read your take.

7. We want maximum people to read the analysis and appreciate the effort and time put into watching the episode several time to bring in nuances.

8. The thread will be opened in a rota system and the list will be available on the thread as well.

9. The thread will open at 9:00 pm IST

10. We have opened a Chat Club, And the current CC is
https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/chat-clubs/1514005/maaneet-idiots-ki-adalat-14

Please feel free to join this and discuss everything under the sun, moon, stars' anything related to the episode, doubts, different pov, should be done on the main thread let everyone get to know what you are thinking'

The Idiot Family-VM

[YOUTUBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2TE5sz3CZd4[/YOUTUBE]

**********************************

Edited by --Revv-- - 14 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

--Revv--

@--Revv--

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

Index of links of analysis beyond page 4:

Pari76:

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/35326988

aditi123_78:

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/35327883

cxw1065:

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/geet-hui-sabse-parayee/1518976/3-idiots-sach-ka-saath-duniya-di-tha-tha-tha?pn=16

Vinu's Sexy Spoilers:

Edited by --Revv-- - 14 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

--Revv--

@--Revv--

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

Rota

Week Starting 18^th October

Monday ' Nihu

Tuesday ' shivu

Wednesday ' lavz

Thursday ' Vrushali

Friday ' Nags

Week starting 25^th October

Monday ' Rev

Tuesday ' Pooja

Wednesday ' Muniza

Thursday ' Dol

Friday ' Rickks

Week Starting 1^st Nov

Monday ' Kulz

Tuesday ' Fahsaad

Wednesday ' Jes75

Thursday ' Nandu

Friday ' Nags

Week 8^th Nov

Monday ' Imraana

Tuesday ' Sann

Wednesday ' Aditi

Thursday ' lily _k

Friday ' Rev

Week Starting 15^th Nov

Monday ' Lvraaz

Tuesday ' Sigma

Wednesday ' Rushtrip

Thursday ' sksg

Friday - Anisha

Anyone wanting to open the thread please send pms to the founding members, RushTrip, Revv and Nargis

IDIOT Assignments:

Aamir Khan ... Rancho - Nargis
Kareena Kapoor ... Pia - dolphinUSA (Dol)
Madhavan ... Farhan Qureshi - RushTrip (Vrush)
Sharman Joshi ... Raju Rastogi - MaaneetDD (Rev)
Boman Irani ... Viru Sahastrabudhhe - Rickks (Viji)
Omi Vaidya ... Chatur Ramalingam aka 'Silencer' - mysterygurl1427 (Shivani)
Javed Jaffrey ... Ranchoddas Shamaldas Chanchad - Yasu09
Mona Singh ... Mona - blueangle13
Rahul Kumar ... Millimetre - MM - SIGMA (Param)
Ali Fazal ... Joy - NanditaSingh
Dushyant Wagh ... Centimetre - Neha
Rajeev Ravindranathan ... Lead Ragging Senior - pooja83
Akhil Mishra ... Librarian Dubey - Maneetforever (Amerra)
3 IDIOT Audiance - aditi123_78 (Aditi)
Mona(Geet's) Unborn Baby - --sann-- (Nupur)
Shoaib Ahmed ... Chote - jamoshi2507 (Neha)
Meghna Bhatia ... Raju's Wife - pickle6586 (Soumya)
Amardeep Jha ... Raju's Mother - macho_muffin
Malvika Singh ... Mona's Baby - Star Struck- Anisha
Chaitali Bose ... Raju's Sister -LavZ

Vidhu vinod chopra aka VVC- Niha (honeydew)

The Open positions are:

Parikshat Sahni ... Farhan's Father
Jayant Kripalani ... Campus Interview Panel Head
Chandrashekhar ... Airlines Ground Staff 2
Dushyant Wagh ... Centimetre
Achyut Potdar ... Machine Class Professor
Atul Tiwari ... Minister in Auditorium
Arun Bali ... Shamaldas Chanchad
Supriya Shukla ... Matron in Hospital with Pia
Farida Dadi ... Farhan's Mother
Omi ... Chatur - pondicherry boy
Pooja Goswami ... Air Hostess
Harvinder Singh ... Mr. Dhillon
Nishi Singh ... Maid at Pia's House
Dinesh Kumar ... Mona's Husband
Aakash Dabhade ... ICE Student 2
Pitobash ... Junior 1
Rakesh Sharma ... Minister at Shyamaldas' Funeral
Michael Joseph ... Exam Hall Professor
Captain A.S. Duggal ... Pilot
Dr. Praful Kulkarni ...Doctor startled by scooter in hospital
Sarvanna ... College Security Guard
Trilok Sadhwani ... ICE Student 4
R.S. Kodange ... Doctor at Airport
Mukund Bhatt ... Raju's Father
Tanveer Ahmed ... Professor in Induction Motor Class
Hitesh Tak ... Ragging Senior 2
Sitaram Sharma ... Manager at Pia's Wedding
Raghunathan ... Professor in Corridor
Vaidyanathan ... Professor Vaidyanathan
Rajendra Patwardhan ... Govind
Sanjay Sood ... Peanut Vendor at Shimla
Annapurna Kaul ... Airlines Ground Staff 1
Pandit Prayag Raj ... Panditji at Pia's Wedding

Dr. Kishor Patil ... Doctor in Ambulance with Raju
Dayal Sharma ... Caretaker at Shyamaldas' House
Shankar Sachdev ... Ambulance Driver
Dharmendra Bhurji ... Airport Cab Driver
Apul Jaisinghani ... ICE Student 3
Shailaja Dhar ... Lady at Mona's Wedding
Saurabh Agnihotri ... Housekeeping Boy at Pia's Wedding
Kumar Veer Singh ... Waiter at Mona's Wedding
Sonu ... Library Clerk
Dileep Desai ... Priest at Joy's funeral

3IDIOT Index
(Last 5 Threads we made as one Big Idiot Family)

3 IDIOTS: Dil Ki Pukaar...Tum Aaona!!

3 IDIOTS: Dil Ne Suni....Dil Ki Pukaar

3 IDIOTS: Aa Rakh Le Humari Maan

3 IDIOTS: Do Dil Ek Jaan

3 IDIOTS: Mann k meet Maaneet-Mohabbat Zindabaad!

3 IDIOTS -Mere Haath Mein Tera Haath Ho..Maahi Ve

Quote

--Revv--

@--Revv--

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

Highlights of the epi for me:

The dream seq... Loved the way she dreams!! Wah.. naughty Geet!!! 😉😉

The hug... It was filled with such love and comfort!! 😍😍😍

And he is yet to read her eyes wrong!!! Beautiful - the way CVs portray that the eyes are windows of the soul !!
And the way she holds onto his shoulder... The unspoken gestures by Geet to convey when her lips refuse to corporate whats in her heart...
Her mind searching for words to convey the depth of deception played out by his bro..
Maan's own sense of guilt for not being there for Geet... Here is a Man with Gigantic sense of responsibility!! 😕😕😕

And him backing up his promise that he would back her up cos she is TRUTH!!! Beautiful... 👏👏👏

Lowlights -

It took Geet 10 mins to say whats in her mind!! She was finding it difficult to even counter his fears!! 😕😕
I do understand Geet and I love the way DD played it out today...But just wished... it was not stretched... Or am I just being too demanding!!! 😳😳

And he is yet to know the fiasco in the office... And she is yet to know abt her new job 😆😆😆

CVS... please have a warning board asking viewers to tighten our seat belts... Like I doubted in the morn.... The CVS came up with a beautiful googly that has bowled us Idiotz over 😆😆😆

AND THE BEST LINE

2 fools trying to fool the other 🤣🤣🤣...Phoool mil gaye phooooooool se

Edited by --Revv-- - 14 years ago

Quote

@rickks

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

Yes Yes Yes....Maan Did not Walk away....

And he Reacted to what Geet said as it was required of him....

His expressions and actions were phenomenal...(GC was outstanding)

Will be back with More soon😊

Updating

There could not have been a better way to Kick-Start of the week...Hats of to the Creatives for the beautiful transitions of scenes from
dream to--reality to--brutal reality

Acting Credits:

Brilliant brilliant Job By GC, he as Maan just convinced us that Maan is the Best On-Screen Character to be ever Sketched.....His Emotional Out burst his transitions from mellowing at one point to being Impulsive to being haste was simply out of this world....
DD- Is always Mind Blowing at emotional Scenes and she executed her Part very well...
Well acting is nothing But reacting and these two proved that today but the show-stealer...Hands Down is GC....
"He portrayal of how the truth tore him apart in b/w with believing what his Love said and the truth instilled in his Brother...."

Well Looks Like Maula Mere as to how it started was quite Impressive...But later on was not that Great...(Sorry Just My POV)

The Diya/Candle Flame...Represented the Maaneet Love....

The Wind that was Blowing-The Truth about Dev and NT

Geet-Rushing to protect it from being blown off to be followed by Maan doing the same was symbolism of how Geet would never let their Love to extinguish, in fact she would be the first one to protect it....like today she was not ready to tell Maan the truth coz she feared that it would ruin his happiness and snatch all his relations forever......

Maan also Joining Hands with Geet to Protect the Flame showed that he would be equally there with her to guard her(His hand was over hers) and their love.....and the same happened today Maan protected her in him embrace of Love assured her that however Bitter is her truth he will not shudder and would be there for her/by her

The whole thing being a Dream-Seq showed that this was what Geet wanted, it was what her subconscious mind ached for that she Dreaded about the truth coming out and how her heart actually wished that Maan would Support her, be there for her....

Maan is a Man who keeps his promises and he proved it yet again...He promised he would be there by her in every walk of Loife and thats what he did today....He sensed something was wrong...he sensed Geet at that moment was not comfortable talking about it...but he was not ready to take NO for an answer......She was Disturbed, and he was not ready to walk away with being disturbed and Sad....even if that meant Forcing her to spill what it was that was bothering her.....

The only thing she will not compromise for anything in this world is him-Her MAAN
His Happiness matters to her so much that she chooses to not tell about Geet lest it could shatter him.Him telling her that he still has not been able to win her trust is like piercing a 100 Daggers through her Body.Him telling that their Love still has not bonded so Deep that she could entrust him with her secret tore her apart and she ultimately Gives in.....

We have always been shown that Maan is an Intelligent Guy and Bang On they used it well....He connected the dots very well when Geet said that she had come to see him on the Night of the Engagement to tell him what the entire matter was.....

From here on the Take Off of Maan's Emotion and Feelings of that of his entire world Breaking Apart...his Love on one side....His brother on the other side....was just too Good that how much ever i praise it....It will be like understatement.....

The 2nd Coming up showed that he would support the Truth as always which he is Geet....So it showed how righteous he was....even if it was Love(Truth) vs Family(Deceit).....

Dev-NT-well there was not Much from them But not telling anything about them at all would be Unfair....Dev showed he was still cunning by Getting NT to believe him and NT on the other hand simply Keeps proving that her biggest Fall is her over-confidence....

The Punch was just the start...Picture toh abhi Shuru Hui hai....

Array Array Jaiyega math.....😲

Acha chalo Jao...But be back tomorrow 😊

and Catch 9:30 (IST)

Geet-Hui Sab Se Parayi (A show with a Difference....)

Love Viji

Edited by rickks - 14 years ago

Quote

yasmeen

@Yasmeen786

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

Hey people😃, hope you all had a gracious weekend.....😉......

ok guys, I must say today's episode was damn good in terms of the revelation of geet's past, very content, the only wee complaint I had was that I wish we got to see more intimate scenes among maan and geet before the revelation😳........but maybe next time.......the aim of today's episode was the exposure of the dark secret, as usual maan was fantastic......loved how he conveys his actions through his facial expressions......he looked damn hot😊..........Naintara makes me regurgitate🤢, she was going to scarper again, (what is she human or inhuman), I loved dev today.....he has proved that he is not a coward anymore, he finally owned up to his despicable mistakes👏......he was very mortified and the expressions of remorsefulness were very conspicuous......hats off to Dev as he succeeded in pulling a wool over naintaras eyes, and got her to believe that he would be leaving with her as there was no use revealing the truth to maan..... he was compelled to turn the tables on NT, after all(Once bitten, twice shy)😆, poor NT was under the misconception that she had succeeded in indoctrinating dev again....and even called him a fool.....(but naintara, I pity you, because you were the one that was duped)......not that smart after all, are we????😆.......

In terms of maans anger during the commencement of the episode I would say his anger was justified but only to a certain extent......he was kept in the dark too...he did not have a single clue as to what was going on around him...if anyone was in his place they would have been as befuddled as him too....... He did not know what he should consider the truth and what should he consider false.........so he demanded the truth from geet.....maan was reluctant to get the truth out from geet by hook or by crook........he couldn't bear her silence treatment, therefore he was given no option but to suspect the word trust in their relationship.😲....this startled geet for a moment, she was given no choice but to succumb to his words......he reassured her that no matter how bitter the truth maybe, he will continue supporting her👏......geet is thinking emotionally (as she feels this revalation would distance him from his family, and she would be root cause of this occurring)whilst maan is thinking practically 😃(trust is important to him, and it holds a huge emphasis in his life).......his reassurance gave her a ray of confidence to spit out the truth⭐️......Loved maan again during the precap where he blatantly told dev, he will obtain justice for geet via punishing dev for his immoral acts😲......soo maan is full of vengeance........he will implicitly see to it that dev is punished for what he has put geet through..... Now this is what I call a magnanimous being😳.......maan you are the best👏......

However after the truth is revealed to dadi.....what will happen then??? 😕Will she support geet or dev???😲 After all they say blood is thicker than water.....will have to wait and see😕.....have a warm evening guys🤗......xxxxxxxxx

Edited by dilmilgaye-kash - 14 years ago

Quote

something

@Silentsoul

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

I just loved today episode every second of it...I loved dream sequence..geet Maan and first time dev too for ...accepting his crime finally..

I was sure Maan will not walk out this time .thats not his character ..if he is such strong preacher for truth and trust...He should have strong mettle to face .any truth...how bitter how harsh it is.....

Best scene was.when MSK smashed that burning candle. New Background score lifted from some movie... and camera..everything was perfect.
And GC acting was mindblowing.HE was terrific there from shocked to despair to finally angry MSK.

Dev fianlly confessed and played nice game with NT.

will add more....

Edited by kuls11 - 14 years ago

Quote

imraana

@imraana

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

25^th Oct 10

Allright guys!!!!!...after ages i feel a deep sense of peace n calmness wash over me!!!...i don't last rem wen i felt dis way....coz 2day....alls well in my world!!!!....surprised???????....welll me toooo!!!!!....i never tht dat i wud fell dis way.....ok enough of suspense!!!!...well i am in dis calm ,peaceful n relaxed state of mind....coz evything is well in maaneet land n soo allls well in my world too!!!!

Things which caught my attention 2day....

---logical n slick flow of da story!!!!...hats off to CVs 4 not wasting any time wid silly scenes n moments!!!...eveything went smoothly n fell into place at da proper time n in a proper sequence n manner!!!

---Geet...well wud do i say abt dis girl!!!!....whenevr she wants to take a happy step sumthing wrong does happen n dats y she is always apprehensive of doing anything dat makes her happy....2day was no less....wen she tht dat she n maan will hav sum special moments together....the whole sitn took he rby surprise!!!...

---Dialogues....well well...brilliant, stupendous n fabulous dialogues by maan...Baryy Dhillon u r A GENIOUS 4 giving us such amazingly b'ful n apt dialogues 4 each n every sitn in GHSP!!!!!...hats off n i bow down to u!!!!...

---Maan....well....undoubtedly da MOST UNDERSTANDING N SENSIBLE MAN dat i hav seen so far!!!!....da way he handles geet, makes her feel comfortable, gives her reassurance time n again is totally out of dis world!!!!!.......i just think dat da interaction bet maan-geet 2 day was sumthing extraordinary!!!!!...dat SPECIAL HUG bet maaneet was special beyond words!!!....da way maan held her seemed 2 say dat....

No matter wat it is

No matter how bitter it is

No matter how scary it is

No matter how painful it is

No matter how big it is

But you & I are meant to be together for eternity, n till we r alive n even beyond dat if its possible!!!!......NOTHING N NOTHING at all can come bet us n nothing can change da way i feel abt u...coz u are my life n i cannot possible live without my life!!!!

Isi pe ek naa cheez sher arz hai....

Tujhpe hoo main yun khurbaan

Hazir hai tere liye ab ye dil-o-jaan

Tu hi hai mera sara jahan

Tujhse hi hai meri yeh shaan

Tu nahi to meri duniya hai bejaan

Isi ko kehte hai Mohabbat

Mohabbat ka doosra naam hai Maan!!!

---- hey wait a min!!!!!....i forgot 2 mention THE MOST SATISFYING part of da epi!!!!....obvs Maan slapping Dev!!!!!....dat was da best scene of 2 day without a doubt!!!!!....how long hav we all waited 4 dis almost an eternity it seems!!!!....WOW waiting 4 more maan-bashing-dev scenes in da next few epi!!!!!

---ok now plzzz don't kill me 4 saying dis!!!!!!!......but wen geet tells maan d atruth...he almost doesn't believe het n turns away!!!!...so wat does dis ean dat if dev dint own up den maan was not going tro believe geet of maybe after a few days or wat??????....i mean i dont know but i kind of wanted him 2 believe her as soon as she told him!!!!!...i know i know dat i'm being a lil unrealistic herebut cant help sharing my views guys!!!!

Ok guys over to u all......plzzz don't mind my sher shayari!!!!!...just felt like putting these words here as dey came 2 my mind!!!!...cant really do justice to maaneet ...but tried 2 make an effort!!!!

Last but not da least... SUPERBLY BRILLIANT acting by guru n drashti...hats offf to dem n also bow down to da CVs n da actors 4 such OUTSTANDING performance👏👏👏⭐️⭐️⭐️👏!!!!!

Love u all my sweet family,

imu

Edited by imraana - 14 years ago

Quote

Lekha Ishwar

@-Destiny-

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

sorry i did not reserve directly thought and posted

I have a few questions in mind If any one minds answering them for me

First of all Now that all the truth is out will strained relations break all barriers ....ld not like to mention about the character Dev and the so called heinous crime he just confessed to .... In a way indirectly .... he has broken and strained relations that can never be mended

MY question here is are relationships so ruthless that they not only give u pain but also a life time of hurt and pain??

As far as i know some strained relations can never be mended

for this episode I would like to post a song which according to me is apt

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B-A-4NQfFRs[/YOUTUBE]

And as far as maan's anger is concerned

think from both the sides

HE has become a wounded tiger😭 pain visible

I can so relate to what has happened

I Wanna rant more par aaj bilkool hi himmat nahi h

love and luck lekha

The anjaani of the 3 idiots thread

signing off

Edited by -Destiny- - 14 years ago

Quote

--Nargis--

@--Nargis--

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#10

OMG...Dev got off easy...just one punch...he should have been beaten to a PULP!!!😡

Updating.........

So finally I got a chance to see the whole episode again....YT was acting very funny today, with the parts uploading in strange order...not chronological!!😡 Imagine my frustration...watching such an intense scene...and then there is no part 4, but there is a part 5.....Ugh.....had to watch it bits and pieces!!😡

So Let me begin by THANKING the CVs......MUUUUAAAWWWAHHH!!! 🤗 Love you guys for airing this episode on Monday instead of a Friday......for there is no way I could have waited 3 whole days to see the continuation.... THank you for that KINDNESS!!🤗

Loved DD expressions.................but today for Me...MAAN the Man stole the show............i just love this character beyond belief. Now just look...here is man totally in love with this girl.....and if Maan was just any man...a mere MORTAL, then walking into the scene he walked into....seeing is LOVE dressed to the HILT all for him, in a SUPER ROMANTIC scene created by her, as a treat to him.....any Man, but NOT Maan, would have filed away the questions and just took advantage of what she was offering, the love, the comfort, the romance, the beauty...herself.......BUT NOT Maan. Her truth and pain are so VASTLY important to him, the he CLAMPED down on his own wants and desires, because even thru all this romance, he can SENSE her pain, her TURMOIL, and he knows that whatever it is ..its BIG......What a MAN!!! LOVE YOU MAAN SINGH KHURANA!!! There is non like you in this world!!! 🤗🤗🤗

I loved their ENTIRE exchange, but what I loved the most was the way MAAN deduced from flashbacks that it is DEV that she is referring to..........and the realization that dawns on his face via his expression....WOW....too good CG....you acting today was PAR EXCELLENCE!!! From SHOCK to DISMAY, to DISBELIEF, to DENIAL, to DISGUST......i was all there, and all present without having to open his mouth...all this so CLEARLY ETCHED in his features, the TAUGHT jaw, to the BULGING eyes, to the BITING lips, PHENOMENAL ACTING by GC.......you ROCKED!!!👏👏👏👏 Once again you brought out the ESSENCE of MAAN perfectly!!!

Now Dev......Thank GOD you did not woos out of this today......for I could never forgive you even now, but had you not stepped up to the plate as you did today..................I would loose TOTAL faith in possible REHABILITATION.....Though I will never accept you or like you as a HUMAN much less a Man, but today, you gained an ounce of respect (and I cringe as i say/type this....Nandu...plz don't kill me) ....but I had to point out that if DEV did not STEP UP and admit to it...this whole TRUTH could have turned really UGLY...really FAST, even if it would have been temporary!!

Now to the Punch....earlier today, i had not seen the SBS episode....but now that I have...I am truly looking for some more PUNCHES being reigned on Dev...........for he deserves no less!!!

Looking forward to tomorrow's episode.............and dying to know who Daadi ma will play into all of this..............I am totally CONFIDENT that the CVs will handle as GRACEFULLY as they handled today!!!👏

One again...............I LOVE you MAAN!!!

An ODE to Maan........

Main khud zameen mera zarf aasmaan ka hai
Ke toot kar bhi mera hosla chataan ka hai
Bura na Maan mere hurf-o-lafz zehr sahi
Main kya karun k yehi zaaiqa zabaan ka hai
Meri sanjeedgi mashhoor hai zamaane mein
Meri khaamoshi bhi Pehlu mere bayaan ka hai
Har ek ghar pe musallat hai dil ki veeraani
Tamaam sheher pe saaya mere makaan

Edited by --Nargis-- - 14 years ago

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 ... 24

3 Idiots-Sach ka saath....Duniya di tha tha tha!!!

3 IDIOTS -Mere Haath Mein Tera Haath Ho..Maahi Ve

Related Topics

Explore Topics