STAR ONE - PLEASE DON'T EDIT GEET! UPD:GOOD NEWS - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

272

Views

24.9k

Users

152

Likes

2.3k

Frequent Posters

liv2laugh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#31
he team of Geet shot some really wonderful scenes
Scenes that worked with the storyline really well
Scenes that if they would have been broadcast
Everyone would have said "How swell"

unfortunately these scenes will never be seen
just because of this one editor it does seem
when I hear what he chopped I wanted to scream
Oh someone please tell me this is all a bad dream

Just because you have the scissors in your hand
you just cannot randomly cut and paste
Is it that you just don't care
Or maybe you just have really poor taste 😛

Can't you see the scenes do not flow
How on earth could you sink so low
From scene to scene there is no continuity
How on earth did you even have the audacity
To chop beautiful scenes like those
You kept the thorns and threw out the rose 😕 😕 😕
swan20 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#32
@ann....good post...much needed...👍🏼
taqdir thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#33

Dear Mr. Editor,

I sincerely hope you are doing fine because what i have learned about you gave me the impression that you are indeed a very unhappy man! Only the unhappy souls cause pain to others for no good reasons. I firstly pray for your sanity.

Secondly, film editing is an art and can be compared with surgery. You have to know fully what you are doing else its death, note it, its death and only death. It is nothing like tailoring that you'll cut a piece of cloth and then sew and join it. Sadly enough your activities reflects that you may have a history of tailoring. You think that cutting anything and anywhere and then joining gives new sense of fashion? Well with cloth it may but in film its horrendous.

Since last Friday i have been writing huge analysis addressing the geet team about how inconsistent the show has become, how meaningless the dialogues turned out to be, how dreadful the main leads looked that I even wrote an obituary for the character MSK since he no longer represented the character he used to. Hardly did i know that all this time it was you who were playing the villain. It was only for some wrong editings did the whole team looked like clowns. All the efforts of the director, performers and the team went in vain and thereby destroyed an art, made a huge number of viewers discontent and caused the beautiful show look meaningless.

However to err is human and to forgive is divine. We can forget the whole thing if you remember only one thing, never to commit the same mistake twice.

Thank you.

PS: Do not edit Geet, if possible edit yourself.

Edited by taqdir - 15 years ago
-RD- thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Gulaal-e-Jung Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 15 years ago
#34
As for the roop tera mastana seq

Dont fall for the Mahila Mukti brigade
Dont fall for their facade
Heart to heart they too want to see the hot stuff
All this protest is just a bluff
So give us something that we'll remember forever
Star One /PH its now or never



BgblZoolander69 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: piya2025

Awesome post by d TM & also by some members..But do u guyz think by saying or discussing things here on IF goona bring any sense to the channel or PH. ? I dont think so if der is any way or any1 have any kind of contact should just send dis reviews to dat person & should post abt it in a clear way on star one's feedback wall..dey simply cant do this to us viewers..
I simply dont understand what d hell those political parties r doing wid dis shows? is dis 4any good?I dont think so..As end of d day its just a show & we r not going to take any lesson 4m this..PPl watch d show 4entertainment not 4horrible edited scenes by d channel ppl..We want variety in a show if we have to see some random eyes-locks n all,der r 1000shows out der,which r running 4m past 2yrs,we r go n watch dis,what is d purpose of watching a new show wid those old stuf again n again..When d director of d show & d actors trying der best to show sumthing new?


That is why we gave all the contact info on the first page. Arwen has given many ways to contact the channel. If you can, use which ever method of contact is best for you. Lets get our voices heard. 😃
veil_of_roses thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#36

@starone
if u are worried abt TRPs than u need to work wid ur editing team...even if u have deadline u cant edit necessary scenes...there was no need to rush, if half truth was shown on fri n half on mon we would have not minded it...u can keep a mahaepisode if u want...bt this rush n crap editing will kill geet hsp.on a hand there are serial where story hardly moves,in geet u r rushing where scenes fly..
we are extremely unhappy with editing..if things would go like this..we'll loose interest from story as charm of story will go away..


about mahila mukti morcha..plz give us their address & ph no..we want talk with those ppl who think pregnant ladies cant romance..on which book it is written..as a doctor i say pregnant ladies need lot of love n affection n care n their is nothing wrong in romance..pregnancy is a physiological state..n plz tell them there are lot of women out here who dont mind in bold scenes of pregnant lady. they are just making fuss to get publicity...what were they doing when such incidence(fake marriage,dowry,rape,honour killing,female fetus abortion) happen. there are lot of other issues in INDIA i wish they 1st work on that...

as a woman i dont mind watching bold scenes as i know u r a responsible channel & u wont show beyond a limit..plus starone is a youth channel plz dont kill essence of show for such publicity hungry ppl.

signing off
Dr. gargi shah
Edited by gargi.shah - 15 years ago
maaniqra thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#37
yes i agree app aisa kyun kar rahe hai star one hamare show ko kharab mat kare aur hum fanz kiii guzarish sune plllllllllllllllzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz aur in nonsense baaton ko hanare serial main mat aane deeeeeeeeeee for god sake😡
Antares thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#38
Though I don't know much about these things.....but I would certainly like to say that the CVs of Geet have really been great with their work so far and managed to hook us all to the show like crazy in such a short span of time...it's coz it's their show and they know how the story should move and the characters be developed and the channel should not come in their way and ruin the entire show......it's the viewers who contribute to the TRPs.....so as long as we are pleased they should not interfere........editing out important parts will just kill the real essence of the show......I surely don't want that to happen to my favourite show.

Even today I did not understand how Maan was still standing there while Geet who was being led by Maan holding her arm was standing with Bunty and his dad.
luvmaneet thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#39
@ann wow Fab post👏👏

this was much needed...
GHSP has a great team Excellent actors,talented director,much efficient creative team,but in past few episodes the editing is killing all the excitement,depth of the most important scenes,No wonder its look like they are missing some parts,may be the CVs are confused with the story,characters,flow everything ,and this creates a question mark on GHSP team's capability from actors to CVs,so plz give some imp to editing,dont chop off imp scenes just to please a certain mass of immature audience ,remember they are temporary...

And about bold scenes,Its an intense/matured luv story,not just a family drama/college boy and girl luv story ,keeping that in mind the script demands the intense scenes to show the maturity of the relationship between Maan and geet,and if you really want to plz those immature audience you should go for it without any chopping,this will rise the TRPs to sky high


Lage raho Devils,we can make this happen😳we did it before,remember
😆😆
😆
ninand thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#40
Damn!! So that is what the channel has been upto!
I do hope they get the message that editing out such scenes which show the development or state of the character will never preferred over redundant eyelocks, or fall-save routines!

From the past couple of weeks this forum has been absolutely ringing with cries of proper editing, and we thought that the CV's were at fault! Goes to show we know what we want, the CV's know what we CRAVE but the channel has no idea!

WE LOVE MAAN AND GEET! the CHARACTERS. The way they have been built and developed! WE WANT TO HEAR THEM. Feel them. Be with them. You CANNOT show us enuf scenes where they are having a monologue or a heart-to-heart with each other , or maybe even no conversation at all.

Its because the director and the cv's have been taking their own sweet time with these characters and their development that they have become this popular! not to mention the casting was perfect. But let Nissar and his team work out what they have created , Please channel do not mess up a perfectly good show.

NOW, to the issue of moral policing----DAMN, F#@$%&* GOD!!! WHAT is wrong with people!!
Is that all we Indian can do?! Think in Black and white!

Marriage good------- no marriage(read 'real emotions') bad!
'Indian tradition' goooooood ---------------------- 'western culture' baaaaaaaaad
'saree-suit-bindi' gooooooooood -------------------- 'skirts-jeans' baaaaaaaaad
'beating girls in pubs and discos' gooooooooooood--------------------------- 'showing them independent' baaaaaaaaaaad

"forced marriages/child brides/abusive marriages/rape/honor killings"umm acceptable--------
but "valentines day!" definitely evil!

Bl**dy, I have seen some moral police here on this forum! WHy dont they get it. Marriage is just solemnising what you actually feel for someone. Its just a stamp on your dedication towards someone.
Marriage is not everything! Marriage does not make people good or bad. It does not automatically create love, or nurture it. People do that! their emotions do that!!

OhMyGod! Instead of seeing what 'Geet' is actually showing-- a strong girl who is Standing up for herself rather than giving in to circumstances(like our IDEAL INDIAN BAHUS), they see---
"ooo he looked at her as though he wanted to kiss her.....sheeeeeesh"
'oho, shes preggers with someone elses child and loving someone else.........chheeeee'
"o....they held hands!!"

GROW UP! Even if you do not agree with us. atleast respect our opinion! We have a right to demand, and to see and LIKE something as much as you do! INDIA IS A DEMOCRATIC COUNTRY!
But all I see is the conservative hogwash getting all the limelight and TERRORIZING people into accepting their norms!
There are a blasted million problems women/girls/kids still face in this Nation of "great culture and tradition"! Problems of the kind we wouldnt expect to find in a country even half as developed as ours.
What a closeted society we live in. And what a sad state of mind we have.
Damn these political groups who are limiting our thinking and narrowing our perception for their petty personal gains. Shudder to even think what might be our future if the only things that get done successfully in this nation is bringing down daily soaps for showing emotional and 'bold' content. Tragic indeed.


Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts · 5 months ago

Hello everyone! I have come back to the forum after a long time. I have been planning a SS on Maan and Geet Amritsar track. The infamous part...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m · 4 years ago

She met him in an unfavorable time when she was running behind the time to save him. Save the only one member of his family whom she call his...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan · 1 years ago

OLD PART LINK https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5011127 https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5009334 new part on blog who want please...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan · 4 years ago

Do dil.....

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m · 4 years ago

This is the story of Maan Geet . The couple who love each other and married secretly . This story will tell their everlasting love, and...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".