STAR ONE - PLEASE DON'T EDIT GEET! UPD:GOOD NEWS - Page 15

Created

Last reply

Replies

272

Views

25k

Users

152

Likes

2.3k

Frequent Posters

327828 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: ann65

@Jake-lover I have proof that there is editing or else I would not be making so much effort to
do this. Is it so hard to believe that the channel would do something
like this? Haven't you noticed the choppy scenes in the episodes from
the past two weeks? Believe me, I am not making this an issue without
proof. I have my sources. I'm also not the only one aware of this
issue. My sole purpose here is to make sure our show doesn't get ruined
and loose its charm. I would love it if you supported us.



Of course.

Show me the proof. I'm curious. It's not that I don't believe you -

What there is to edit? Other than Maneet romantic scenes?

This is a show, not a movie. I did feel like some were chopped, but what do you except in 30 mins? 20, actually - Minus adds and all.

Let's see what we get tomorrow, then it makes sense to get hyper.

Don't we usually make an issue of CVs dragging the story? People stopped watching the show cause Maneet seperated. People complained. Thanks to editing or not, didn't we get them back in a week and we were all happy, weren't we?

I don't know what edited scenes look like, but if cause of those we have one awesome show, I don't mind. We can't have everything, now can we?

As far as bold scenes go - If you do have a proof and if they already edited tomorrow's sequence then I'm already pissed. 😡 Aren't I already pissed at GC? 😆
Edited by Jake-lover - 15 years ago
whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago

Are the really doing this?😲 I don't believe it...Is it the same idiot box that is allowing not one but endless kisses in one of the shows ( Sanjog se bani sangini) I don't know if I am allowed to mention this but sorry guys...I have seen hundreds of passionate and absurd scenes on indian television...now even news channels are dramatising crime stories in most bizarre ways....then why our serial Geet has to suffer?.....Come on Star Channel's decision makers come out of the rut....when they can show roop tera mastana back in 70s and 80s on DD channel...why this two faced theory here?.....Indian audiance has come a long long way....Geet anyways is just a fiction...so let the Geet team have their freedom of expression. Art and liteature can not be bound. All those women/politocal groups should so some real work..and save girls like suffering in our society....they should fight for the victims of rape cases, the dowry sufferers...why aren't they throwing their anger on people like Dev in our society?.......whay are they running after and wasting their time, energy and resourses on a mere serial....Star channel should not pay head to such hypocrat groups and people who wants to ride on Geet's success. As far as Geet's character is concerned, she is an adult and a head strong girl.....if she ever prefers pre-marital sex it's her choice..legally and also socially now...nobody can challenge her for doing something wrong. I am not advocating for premarital sex here but its just the mindset of people that has to be changed and Star channel can be instrumental in bringing about this change if it projects this pre-marital sex beautifully...

Edited by whitepearl - 15 years ago
MishtyShona thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
Starone pls pls pls stop editting episodes of geet...
We want BOLD maneet scenes from manali...
ash08 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
Ann, kudos for opening this thread dear.

Dear Star One Channel,

Have you heard the phrase "Vinashakale Viparitha Buddhi". Seems now you are on a self destruction mode.

Geet was the only show that got you in the first 50 in the TRP race. It was the only show that got recognition to Star One so much so viewers who did not get the channel went ahead, paid extra money to get that channel on their TV.

The show is a mature story. A story that deals with atrocities committed on women, atrocities committed due to certain beliefs. A story which caters to the mature audience. Have you once taken time to think as to why this show is aired on Star One and not any other GEC? That's because Star One caters to the educated, sophisticated youth. And the target audience of Star One are intelligent enough to understand what happens behind the scenes.

Do you know the difference between the Western shows and Indian shows? There the creatives have the creative independence where as in India, everything is decided by external factors. What is so creative about it? No wonder the shows go down the drain in a few months. Do you think the creatives who put their mind and soul into a show would give their 100% if at each and every mode they are influenced by others? Won't it affect their creativity?

We understand your need to carry on. After all it's a business. You cannot run on charity alone and your main intention is to make profits. That will work only when you cater to the larger audience and make shows with the larger audience in mind. But there is also something called being the first. Why cannot you try and be the first channel to oppose the outside factors influencing your work? Why cannot you take a stand and tell them that it is just entertainment and there is nothing to take seriously in fiction. Why cannot you consider the efforts put in by the entire team of a show in making it happen? We will assure you the day you take a stand we will stand united with you. I am sure by now you understand the reach of your audiences. We made you bring back Karan, Shilpa and Rati. If we can fight against you, we can equally fight for you and with you. We just need to be convinced that you are taking a stand.

Do not chop the important scenes as the show lacks continuity in such a situation. Remember that the viewer is full of choices. If he does not like a show, he will move on to another one. And all your TRPs will go down the drain. As they say, Prevention is better than cure. I hope you people pull up your socks and get down to work before things get out of hand.

A disgruntled viewer,
Ash
Edited by ash08 - 15 years ago
desigirl_18 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
Thank you for bringing this up!!! Seriously i don't want them to mess up a brilliant story just for the sake of TRPs!!! Why is Star One out to ruin it's shows?!!
i found today's episode to be one of the best.... dialogue and scene wise, simply loved it!!!...Just imagine how much better it could have been if all the editing hadn't taken place!! Seriously this is unfair to the actors and the whole Geet team, they work hard on their scenes and those scenes should be shown to us loyal audiences!!! The channel should stop interfering!! Geet is soo good that it doesn't even need to go crazy about TRPs, if they continue to please the audience with a good story and don't rush the scenes people will keep watching and loving!!
whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago

Gear up Star Channel....Fight back....U can't be bogged down by anyone....

Edited by whitepearl - 15 years ago
veil_of_roses thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
ann post 4 lions link here u have posted geet's link twice...
Awesome.Sauce thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
WHOAAAAAAAAA...aint i js a little too late to get to this thread??🤔 Meh...WHO CARES.
First of all Ann,Thankyou so much for taking the initiative of bringing this topic up.😳WAS VERY MUCH NEEDED. Now coming to the issue.Its not the first time that some channel has done the "CHOPPING" of "simple and subtle" scenes that they THINK will do NO good for their "TRPs". 🥱. The secret recipe of running a SUCCESSFUL show or even gettin' HIGH TRPs is : CONNECTION between the storyteller and the audience. You can show all the glam/item songs/random nonsense scenes but you js CANNOT manage to glue a group of mature audience until and unless they FEEL the CONNECTION with the story. This is the reason, when you EDIT a specific scene abruptly...the audience gets "What the hell js happened?" moment.In other words, the INTENSITY/VISION with which the director/storyteller is trying to project the storyline or the characterization to the audience gets DISTURBED. Hence, people dont FEEL connected to neither the story or the character....which ultimately leads to Loss of audience. and If people wont WATCH your show...HOW in the world would you be able to gain or even retain your daym TRPs??🥱😕
If a scene is SIMPLE...it doesnt mean its TRASH . Simplicity speaks volume. Simple is substantial.You should know better . More than ANYTHING the audience cherish scenes that make SENSE and are close to REALITY. For instance, Me as an audience, prefer to watch any "art" film rather than watching some random /senseless GLAM movie ANYDAY. Mainly becausethey are CLOSE to reality. I watch a show for its ORIGINALITY, CONTENT and MOST importantly, THE VISION behind the whole plot. Up until last week , I was NEVER disappointed with how Geet was building up. Its since last week or so that i felt that the CONNECTION which i used to feel while watchin' the show or even the characters is MISSING BIG TIME. Usually, the DETAILING factor of this show has been EXCELLENT...buh these days THAT is the one major concern for me. There is NO DETAIL WHATSOEVER . The scenes are rushing up at the speed of light...WHY?? may be bacause the "editing" department wants to squeeze EVERYONE in one episode. WHY would you have to do THAT??
Dev-Myra are FINE. I find their scenes OKEY if not GREAT. BUT, here a BIG BUT, I would certainly NOT appreciate them cutting off in between Maan-Geet. I gets extremely ANNOYING when a perfectly SENSIBLE maneet scene is ruined by them popping on the screen without any significant contribution in moving the storyline forward. 🥱
and now the certain "SOCIAL"group. 😕THEY js fascinate me with their REASONING ABILITIES.and the channel is BUTCHERING scenes to PLEASE them ??? SERIOUS???🤢😕🥱WOW....I would say TRY that ...You shall be getting the answer from the AUDIENCE real soon in the only languageyou seem to understand: THE TRPs.😳
I dont think that i need to elaborate on what happened to the other shows ,for instance MJHT and the LEGEND DMG as a matter of fact. If the audience will NOT get the idea behind the scene..they will NOT relate to it, and if they will NOT relate to it , they will NOT FEEL the essence of the scene and if they wont FEEL it , then they will feel SHALLOW about it, and quit watching the show...and if they wont be watchin' Geet ...then WHY do you think they will watch your CHANNEL??🥱(O i almost forgot ...the channel has other " shows" to offer eh??? O Wellll..... *Roll eyes* 🤢)
LONG STORY SHORT:
Trust your own shows. Trust the people who work day and night to put on a great show, trust the idea, Trust the visions behind the story and most importantly, TRUST YOUR AUDIENCE.😳
If YOU will NOT let THEM down , THEY will NOT let YOU down.😃
TRUST ME, m the audience.😆😆😆😆 I know better.
nd about the ROOP TERA MASTANA seq... I would say HANDLE WITH CARE. It would be better if you stay away from your respective AXES.😆😆😡Let the GEET TEAM take care of that. You WONT regret. You will be thanking them INSTEAD.😆😆😆
and DUDE...i wrote a LOT.
😕😆
Thankyou.
*I hv got my EYES on you *
neha<3
Edited by *mesweet neha* - 15 years ago
kiran000 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
ya i completly agree with dat post.
Please starone stop dis non sense n lets us watch our innocent maaneet as it is.plzzzzz dont spoil dis fab serial Jst like DMG.
Ahhhhh its a pity wat u hv done wid DMG,BUT PLZ LEAVE OUR MAANEET. U plz dont interfere in d story line of Geet.=o((
BgblZoolander69 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: gargi.shah

ann post 4 lions link here u have posted geet's link twice...



Gagri which link and where?

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts · 6 months ago

Hello everyone! I have come back to the forum after a long time. I have been planning a SS on Maan and Geet Amritsar track. The infamous part...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m · 4 years ago

She met him in an unfavorable time when she was running behind the time to save him. Save the only one member of his family whom she call his...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan · 1 years ago

OLD PART LINK https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5011127 https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5009334 new part on blog who want please...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan · 4 years ago

Do dil.....

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m · 4 years ago

This is the story of Maan Geet . The couple who love each other and married secretly . This story will tell their everlasting love, and...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".