#Devil's Den:Ring-a-Ring-a-Maaneet - Page 86

Originally posted by: ash08

Exactly An. Having doubts in a relationship is logical. But hop, skip and jump from a bubbly girl to an intense woman in a matter of minutes for example is what I am finding it difficult to understand.

But thats how we all r in real life as well...In intense passionate moments with our partner,our reaction is different...when we r chilling out with our friends we hv different reaction...when we r gonig out with our partner for some picnic we r not intense but rather very chilled out...our reaction changes as per the situations in which we r put in...Geet too is going through same change of emotions but that doesn't mean she has memory loss.,..she just reacts accordingly in different circumstances..in office she tries to maintain her bubbly self ..but when she is in a private zone with Maan,her inner desires take over her basic bubbly nature...simple😳

Originally posted by: an12345678

It's all becoming about scenes and there lies the problem, according to me. Weave the scenes around the story and you'll have a good flow and something sensible and pleasing to watch.

Very true. Scenes should be an integral part of the story and should blend with the story. Not have a story written around a particular scene.

@Anjana: I understand that. Am I doubting the character or what she has gone through. Nada. I am not doing that even for a brief moment. But, the girl will have her private moments too when she thinks ... or she cannot have that because the story is still developing? The nature of character evolves agree but it should be visible too even if it's through symbolism.

Originally posted by: jyoti06

But thats how we all r in real life as well...In intense passionate moments with our partner,our reaction is different...when we r chilling out with our friends we hv different reaction...when we r gonig out with our partner for some picnic we r not intense but rather very chilled out...our reaction changes as per the situations in which we r put in...Geet too is going through same change of emotions but that doesn't mean she has memory loss.,..she just reacts accordingly in different circumstances..in office she tries to maintain her bubbly self ..but when she is in a private zone with Maan,her inner desires take over her basic bubbly nature...simple😳

Jyo I totally accept. I have no problem with the character of Geet, but the characterisation of Geet. After a night of intense moments with your partner, the next day you are your bubbly self with your friends with no indication to them what happened the night before, but internally you are affected right? Atleast we can watch Geet pondering over those intense moments is what I am trying to say.

Jyoti: I have all the patience in the world when it comes to stories and development of characters. Coz, I know how difficult it's to bring them to life and then see how they go through a cycle till the end. But, it should be defined with each phase. One cannot define her present state in the future phase. What she is going through now is the now moment, it won't belong to the tomorrow moment.

Originally posted by: jyoti06

...I feel Geet is different because here CVs leave a lot for the viewers to understand themselves and hv our different interpretations rather than spoonfeeding us in evey scene..the reason why we r hving so many discussions on Geet's self-talk or other issues is because of these symbolisms only..we will not hv such discussions for other shows like DMG or MJHT or Colors or star plus shows ,...simply because they explain almost everything in the show itself without any logic of course😆..whats the need to discuss then😆..Thats where Geet stands out from the rest because here lot is left to the viewer's imagination and thats where the interest comes in because we r discussing these issues endlessly😉😳;And this unspoken phase of love and confusion is needed to build a strong relationship between Maneet for the future...once they r in a committed relationship,these symbolisms will automatically go away and we will see real serious dialogues mayb😃 ...

@Vini and Ash:If everything is conveyed thorugh words or confirmation,then it becomes the same cliched candy-floss love story..How can we say Geet is different from the rest then ?..it will fall in the same category..its different because for the first time a show has dared to make the viewers think about every individual character and their basic nature..tell me which was the last show we witnessed where we had such intense arguments and difference of opinions about every character and each scene...because most of the shows r showing characters in just one dimention..so its easy for the viewers to grasp their character-sketches easily without much thinking😆...but in case of Maan and Geet ..thats not the case..their characters here r gonig through different phases of love and the reason why we r seeing the inconsistency here...the inconsistency is deliberate in this case but their basic nature is still the same..

I just stopped by for a sec, saw what was being discussed. I am with Blue, An and Ash. Since I am sick, I trust these sistas will argue for me too.

Love you all.

Polki

Originally posted by: an12345678

@Anjana: I understand that. Am I doubting the character or what she has gone through. Nada. I am not doing that even for a brief moment. But, the girl will have her private moments too when she thinks ... or she cannot have that because the story is still developing? The nature of character evolves agree but it should be visible too even if it's through symbolism.

😆 😆 Ahhh! But, it is visible n palpable 😉 Msg of HP trip became crystalized in the end. Msg to even the most dimwitted audience member: MSK: so long as i am alive, i will shield u from your past as u have become an instrinsic part of my life. Geet: Is God telling me to move on with him? Is he my future?

Now we have Trust Bldg - Truth Sequence Happening. It began with him putting her to bed and his emblematic dialogue: Someday Geet you will trust me enough to share all your woes and truth.

Now let us watch it enfold in its entirety. Am confident the message at the end will be equally CLEAR. All of it cannot happen in a scene...the platform must first be built...for the girl to accept... the mother to apprehend....and the lover to comprehend