Faculty shouldn’t interfere

Page

animaUSA1

@animaUSA1

Explorer

Posted: 18 years ago

Faculty shouldn't hamper all judges' decisions. Like FAMEGURUKUL all faculty members should remains silent and they shouldn't be present in gala studio while the gala performances are going on. I think their duty is over while all contestent come forward to show their talent.

When judges decides and express t heir concert and comments on performence, Dean Palash never agrees with that. What is that? I don't think he should talk or he should override judges decisions. If so than why reality shows brings respectable people to judge?

What you say guys?

Quote

Frequent Posters

Huzaifa Kaderbhai

@kothra

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

I sumhw agree with u..
But judges should nt b harsh at ol..
Faculty are not interfering but they just not happy with the judges comments
Judges cannot say o any1 ur besura or betala..judges are insulting the contestant

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

animaUSA1

@animaUSA1

Explorer

Posted: 18 years ago

@Kothra..Judges always say that all of contestens are capable of doing much better still they don't show their talents perfectly. In this stage of competition they should perform perfectly. They shouldn't sing besura, because they meant to sing well and they know their sur.

@Realist..I agree with you that Dean Sen is making the situation worse. He is not showing his respect to the judges. I know that its all acts..they are doing it to get higher TRP

Quote

Saikrupa

@Saikrupa

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Dean palash is doing a gr8 job only dalir makes foolish decisions...y they left adhi....he was gr8 at that day performance.....

Quote

kuhu.kuhu

@kuhu.kuhu

Sparkler

Posted: 18 years ago

I partly agree with you and partly don't ....if the contestants sing in perfect sur while performing in National television then they wouldn't have been auditioning for fame x , they would already been an

established singer .....that's why if they falter or make some mistakes then instead of saying besura or betala for the whole song it's the judges duty to point out where they went wrong so that they can rectify it .....so that way I agree with Palash sir ...

what I didn't like about Palash is yesterday he practically forced the contestants to vote for Banjo saying that he is not at all happy with the way the contestants voted last week ( hence pointed out

don't vote for Arunima) and then said acc to him it should be Banjo who should be saved ...like what the heck!!!!!!

As a result Arunima jaisi singer might be voted out this week ...when I was listening to Aru I felt she

shouldn't have been in fame x...as Dalerji and Ganeshji said ,u have a great voice but u have to come out

of the shy mode and said that Sammy should get Aru's singing quality and Aru ,Sammy's carefree perf .....that made me think that here also Sammy with his besurapan might win bec of his looks and carefree performance ...and Arunima although has an excellent voice but her shyness will let her down which Ganesh ji also pointed out ........

Guys , if you liked Arunima's singing and performance in the 1st few galas ( when I also became her fan which slowly faded ) should listen to her today sp her last english song " mariah Carey's Hero" ....simply mindblowing ..I for once want to hear more of this Arunima ..... 😃😃😃

Quote

Esh

@EshEffect

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

😊 I once made a post of same topic in the 2nd week of fame-x .. good to see ppl r finally noticing this .. all this dean-judge fight is only getting the contestants down ! If the judges throw their comments in a better manner and Palash Sen contradicts Daler and Ganesh a little less, may be the participants will do and feel much better ! Everytime Palash would fight with Daler and Daler would make a counter-statement on a participants level of performance, the only person geeting hurt is the participant and NO ONE ELSE !!!

Quote

rrb304

@rrb304

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

There are some tension undercurrents always prevalent on the sets and it's pretty evident Palash Sen and Daler M don't get along.

They need to address this or atleast be civil. It may be my bias but I kind of feel, Palash is right when he contradicts Daler. Daler is definately entitled to his opinion but at the same time he needs to be a lil more tactful in the way he says it and not be so obnoxious.

Quote

Huzaifa Kaderbhai

@kothra

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: animaUSA1
@Kothra..Judges always say that all of contestens are capable of doing much better still they don't show their talents perfectly. In this stage of competition they should perform perfectly. They shouldn't sing besura, because they meant to sing well and they know their sur.

I agree with u...But since day 1 daler has been very harsh i mean as he said to adi ke usko 3 months bhi diya fir bhi besura hoga was does he mean?..he cannot judge sum1 like this...To rakesh he always says awaz achcha hai lekin betala ho

Ashtosh..rehan 2-3 besura hojaate hai lekin maaf karsakta hai..it seems daler is nt stable with his comments

Edited by kothra - 18 years ago

Quote

SCS

@jimhawkins

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: animaUSA1
Faculty shouldn't hamper all judges' decisions. Like FAMEGURUKUL all faculty members should remains silent and they shouldn't be present in gala studio while the gala performances are going on. I think their duty is over while all contestent come forward to show their talent.

When judges decides and express t heir concert and comments on performence, Dean Palash never agrees with that. What is that? I don't think he should talk or he should override judges decisions. If so than why reality shows brings respectable people to judge?

What you say guys?

i agree with u... its ok if the faculty objects once in a while - when it is absolutely necessary, but not like - everytime the judges say something, the dean stands up to refute it... it negates the whole idea of having judges...

Quote

nsupu

@nsupu

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#10

Arunima has no improvement at all....she is the same from the first round......and sammy din;t perform well in Gala round but banjo performed well in the firt round......so i support palash decision...they two are worth to come in Cafe round.........

Quote

Faculty shouldn’t interfere

Related Topics

Explore Topics