CHARISMA vs TALENT - Page 3

Originally posted by: shagun_luvs_?

i disagree. Shahrukh is the best. Hey ding dong, do you personally hate eveyone.

Originally posted by: Vera

There is no doubt that Arijit is the best singer out of Kazi and Rex. The basic 101 of Music is "sur". Rex and Kazi may be good performers but they sing "besura". How would we like it if Sonu Nigam or Shaan or some other singer sang besura?? They will not survive in the industry no matter how great a performers they may be!!!

Even Pandit Jas raj was willing to take Arijit as his student so you know Arijit sings well.

Also, Mona sang the Parineeta song so perfectly ! I thought that she is a better singer than Ruprekha, Shamik, Rex and Kazi.

It's stupid for Fame Gurukul to ask their peers to vote because the peers will want to get rid of their competition so they will choose someone who is not good..

By the way how did Arijit get picked yesterday? Did the Faculty save him?

very well said but do you beleive the people who are giving vote to Qazi know anything about Pandit Jasraj or music.

Originally posted by: infiniteattract

All i have to say is its the mass who made Shah Rukh Khan "King Khan" and Amitabh Bacchan "Big B". So if they prefer charisma over talent why not develop charisma instead of arguing that the mass is wrong, because charisma cant be developed a person is born with that. If u are talented with regular practice and riyaz it can be increased but if u are not charismatic neither anyone can teach u nor u can develop that.

And as someone has pointed out he has given the answer himself that if Qazi becomes a part of the Jodi he will perform but need Kirti or Anubhav to do playback for him. So he has himself given the answer that they are capable of doing playback only so why try to come on stage and woo 3 million people. Qazi doesnt need anyones mask on him to woo the audeince.

Lastly if I say that I am doing a very tough thing and my teachers say yes I am a genius i dont become a genius until its something exceptional in the eyes of 1000 people viewing it. Same has happened with Arijit and Shamit and Qazi. They say we can sing tough songs, faculty says yes they can but the mass voting says they dont want them to do that. Then whats the use of doing that and they are the ones who says Qazi is not learned enuff but if his besura singing is liked by 3 million people and their strong alaaps dont even go thru the tymapanic membranes I think they should try some peppy numbers instead of those tough ones and develop some body language instead of copy pasting Bosco's steps; audience is neither deaf nor blind they will surely accept them. If they cant see or hear what u are trying to show and make them hear its not their fault the fault lies within u.