Originally posted by: NYorker1
This a competition not a melodrama show. Javed Akhtar said what he felt and I personally feel that he is right. Kirti was the most talented singer among all of them but he was voted out by his mates....why? Can someone answer honestly? Same thing is happening again and again and INDIAN viewers who are eligible to vote are responsible for this disaster. I can assure you all viewers that any two singers who will be finalist will just be the finalist on SONY TV.....they will not go any further than this....MARK MY WORDS.
If you are giving a person the LIBERTY to VOTE, you have no business thereafter to question him on his vote. If you want him to vote according to your wishes, why have this sham of voting at all?
I thought we lived in a democracy, where every person has his right to choose. All that matters is that he is FREE to choose WHOEVER and WHATEVER he wants. If you are then going to critisize him on doing what he did, and make a public show out of it later on, please dont let the students vote....
Shamit thought he had the right to vote for whoever of the 2 he wanted to. He did that. Hell broke loose thereafter...WHY HE DID IT IS IRRELEVANT. What if I were to say JA was playing politics, targetting the best singer amongst the lot, so that maybe his favorite gets a shot at winning? Why is he targetting only ONE of FIVE people who voted against KIRTI????
If you want the students to vote for the best student, why not step in and do that yourself? WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU TRYING TO PROVE BY FORCING STUDENTS TO VOTE FOR THE BEST STUDENT???
DUH!!! the biggest DUH in the history of voting
WHY WERENT THE OTHER 4 made to pay for it also? WHY WERENT THEY SUMMONED INTO ILA's OFFICE AND TOLD THEY PLAYED POLITICS??
JUST BECAUSE SHAMIT IS THE ELDEST??? Just because he has leadership qualities?
Atleast Shamit had the guts to take JA on.. he believes he did whatever he did for the right reasons.. what about the other four who are hiding behind him like cowards??
SHAME ON THEM I SAY
Edited by PrinceOfDarknes - 20 years ago