India 4th August's episode - Page 2

Originally posted by: tisha_bhatia

I dont know about today's episode but Javed's retort to Shamit in the previous episode I thought was very apt. When Shamit was put in the danger zone, he took the mike and tried to justify his stance on voting for Gurpreet and when asked by the judges if he thought he voted for the right person keeping music in mind - he said NO and that he regrets making the wrong choice. To this Javed Akthar said - if you think you made a mistake by voting Kirti out, so be it. BUt if you think you are here in the danger zone because you voted Kirti out - then this would be your second mistake and our big folly. You are not here because of your vote, but just because you were not up the mark today. I didnt think his retort was not insulting at all. When Shamit challenged them - he was asking for it on national TV.

I personally think those who voted for Gurpreet that day made the wrong choice. The participants very well know why they have the power to vote - they are not the audience who get to vote just because they like a singers face - they as supposed to vote for the person who is musically sound without holding any personal bias. They failed to do that and did Kirti wrong and this guilt has even affected their performance. I think Shamit should just let it rest and not bring up this topic over and over again.

well said. i personally found Shamit very irritating today..........just caught the last 10 mins of the show.he had such a long face on!!!!!!!!

Originally posted by: tisha_bhatia

I dont know about today's episode but Javed's retort to Shamit in the previous episode I thought was very apt. When Shamit was put in the danger zone, he took the mike and tried to justify his stance on voting for Gurpreet and when asked by the judges if he thought he voted for the right person keeping music in mind - he said NO and that he regrets making the wrong choice. To this Javed Akthar said - if you think you made a mistake by voting Kirti out, so be it. BUt if you think you are here in the danger zone because you voted Kirti out - then this would be your second mistake and our big folly. You are not here because of your vote, but just because you were not up the mark today. I didnt think his retort was not insulting at all. When Shamit challenged them - he was asking for it on national TV.

I personally think those who voted for Gurpreet that day made the wrong choice. The participants very well know why they have the power to vote - they are not the audience who get to vote just because they like a singers face - they as supposed to vote for the person who is musically sound without holding any personal bias. They failed to do that and did Kirti wrong and this guilt has even affected their performance. I think Shamit should just let it rest and not bring up this topic over and over again.

Very well said. I too feel Shamit should stop bringing up topic over and again. He should let it go and concentrate on his performance.