Any sympathy for Amrita ? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

69

Views

7.9k

Users

19

Likes

239

Frequent Posters

Nikki_Titli thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: roshani45


yes disgusting is the word 😆I find pretty disgusting his words about how innocent ( something like that ) that woman is ! Man you are trying to justify ur fault which your wife isn't able to digest , atleast stop praising that other woman !!

Ratan, well i don't know whats her take about the difference between right and wrong !!!i didnt expect this !!!



n the biggest thing he did all in his senses......still still i wud hv completly get over with Sampoorn & his dumb excuses...

bt Ratan...d woman who ws BEHAVING like a REAL WOMAN till monday epi...y ws she made mahan all of a sudden...nt mahan...y ws she made "dumb" all of a sudden??😲😲...

She faced the tragedy n stood as "man" of family..She din accepted Veera evnthough tht kid ws nt at fault..She lied to her child time n time again aftr droppin veera at orphange..so till then she ws INDEED shown as human who do good things...who do mistakes n who evn repent for mistakes(the way she said sorry to veera on RanVeera reunion epi)... But kal ka epi..it ws a COMPLETE U-TURN...n thts wht INDEED called "mahaanta" whether u agree or nt...it WAS yday Ratan TRANSFORMED into "super woman" frm REAL woman... Had this letter thing ws nt shown or no "reason" ws tried to portray for the "sin" Sampoorn did..Things wud hv been diff..I mean c she for "NAMESAKE" atleast "accepted" RanVeera's relation on thurs epi last week...with time she "wud" hv slowly givn somewht acceptance & change in her behaviour towards Veera...n THATS what "very human"...bt kal ka thing for ME its STILL vry "superficial"..

i feel she wanna LIVE IN DELUSION as she wanna beleive her pati is "still" mahaan & rite for her...Ok let her live a delusional life ahead now..as truly this is NOT THE RATAN atleast i loved,understood n respected...
MOTHERHOOD thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#22
Can anyone tell me why Sampooran did "IT" with Amrita.
Did he love her?

-Rojaa- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: Nikki_SAS-holic



n the biggest thing he did all in his senses......still still i wud hv completly get over with Sampoorn & his dumb excuses...

bt Ratan...d woman who ws BEHAVING like a REAL WOMAN till monday epi...y ws she made mahan all of a sudden...nt mahan...y ws she made "dumb" all of a sudden??😲😲...

She faced the tragedy n stood as "man" of family..She din accepted Veera evnthough tht kid ws nt at fault..She lied to her child time n time again aftr droppin veera at orphange..so till then she ws INDEED shown as human who do good things...who do mistakes n who evn repent for mistakes(the way she said sorry to veera on RanVeera reunion epi)... But kal ka epi..it ws a COMPLETE U-TURN...n thts wht INDEED called "mahaanta" whether u agree or nt...it WAS yday Ratan TRANSFORMED into "super woman" frm REAL woman... Had this letter thing ws nt shown or no "reason" ws tried to portray for the "sin" Sampoorn did..Things wud hv been diff..I mean c she for "NAMESAKE" atleast "accepted" RanVeera's relation on thurs epi last week...with time she "wud" hv slowly givn somewht acceptance & change in her behaviour towards Veera...n THATS what "very human"...bt kal ka thing for ME its STILL vry "superficial"..

i feel she wanna LIVE IN DELUSION as she wanna beleive her pati is "still" mahaan & rite for her...Ok let her live a delusional life ahead now..as truly this is NOT THE RATAN atleast i loved,understood n respected...


Yes thats true! Ratan's character suddenly took a U turn ! However , there are women who are emotionally weak , few words from their loved ones or their tears would break them ,they will end up forgiving them ! I think Ratan feel bad for Sampooran , she think just becoz of her , Sampporan went away , he isn't living with his family , whatsoever !! Maybe its sympathy for him.

But the truth is ,its hard to sympathize with Sampooran.
-Rojaa- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: ItIsMyLife

Can anyone tell me why Sampooran did "IT" with Amrita.
Did he love her?


hi i don't think he loved her !! He probably felt bad for her as she was ill , and the reason why he did that is confusing ! Honestly i don't understand why 😕
MOTHERHOOD thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: roshani45


hi i don't think he loved her !! He probably felt bad for her as she was ill , and the reason why he did that is confusing ! Honestly i don't understand why 😕


So he had sex with a lady just because he felt bad for her.
No love and no relation.
How can a wife forgive such a man?

SIP1997 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#26
Great analysis everyone.

After watching yesterday's episode, my beliefs about cheating are reinforced. I believe that cheating is cheating there is no excuse for it, but I had hoped that CVs would come up with something to change my mind, but what they came up with left me scratching my head in confusion.

Seriously, sleeping with Amrita because Sampooran was drunk would have been easy to accept then the reason they came up with.

I was flinching at each of Amrita's reason for running away from home instead of telling her family about her health.

My family's reputation would be more important to me then their grief when I am gone. A spot on the reputation of the family lives on for generation, but grief passes with time. She would have been more loved if she told the truth then doing what she did.

I really don't get this at all.

Okay the concept is that Ranvi has to become Veera's mother, this could have been done in other ways, but why do it this way? May be CVs will have explanations later, but I am really disappointed by this.



MOTHERHOOD thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27
So she wanted to get touched by a man.
Why can't ask an unmarried man to do the the honor?
And Ratan is not even angry with her husband.
So is it Sampooran's duty to fulfil the desire of every virgin woman.
Ridiculous.

hinz thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 12 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: sbp1971

Great analysis everyone.

After watching yesterday's episode, my beliefs about cheating are reinforced. I believe that cheating is cheating there is no excuse for it, but I had hoped that CVs would come up with something to change my mind, but what they came up with left me scratching my head in confusion.

Seriously, sleeping with Amrita because Sampooran was drunk would have been easy to accept then the reason they came up with.

I was flinching at each of Amrita's reason for running away from home instead of telling her family about her health.

My family's reputation would be more important to me then their grief when I am gone. A spot on the reputation of the family lives on for generation, but grief passes with time. She would have been more loved if she told the truth then doing what she did.

I really don't get this at all.

Okay the concept is that Ranvi has to become Veera's mother, this could have been done in other ways, but why do it this way? May be CVs will have explanations later, but I am really disappointed by this.





I so agree with you here, I even found Amrita's beliefs a bit contradicting...one moment she says she wouldnt want to give her parents pain and wants to be remembered as the chirpy Amrita that she is..but would they not always remember her for ditching the parents and putting their pretige at stake?

I just dont understand how the writers who did so well with the story so far, messed up when it came to such an important issue...like someone said here, it should have been left aside rather than showing us this unreasonable explanation...oblivion would have suited the story better...
Nikki_Titli thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: ItIsMyLife

So she wanted to get touched by a man.
Why can't ask an unmarried man to do the the honor?
And Ratan is not even angry with her husband.
So is it Sampooran's duty to fulfil the desire of every virgin woman.
Ridiculous.



@blue...
angry???woh toh ab door ki baat hai..coz she like all other "typical mahaan" heroines ended up forgivin her husband all of a sudden n tht too readin tht "most dumb reason"...😡

@brown...
oh god..srsly kal ke epi is truly portrayin stuffs like this..🥱
Nikki_Titli thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#30
hinz i had said tht...ki isse behtar tha NO REASON...coz hw can u evn give "reason"...totally disgustin..n the worst thing..aftr portrayin Ratan so soo fabulously n so strongly...she ws made DUMB jst like tht in a sec...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".