the caring of Jeevika for Manvi..really!! Edited. - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

53

Views

7.7k

Users

22

Likes

222

Frequent Posters

uniquebluerose thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#11


Quite an interesting take. There are many perspectives you can take from Jeevika's stand and I think that's why the sisters relationship is more debated. With the brothers, it's a straight-forward, easy going relationship where both will be there for each other and there's hardly ever any disagreement. Where as the sisters, their whole emotional attachment towards each other is so unstable that you don't know what will trigger what kind of reaction. The reason why the brothers are in sync is because it's not their relationship which drives the show forward. You need the problems and conflicts for the drama which mainly comes from the sisters so there will be instances where J & M will upset each other and seem to not understand each other but frankly it's a part of their relationship. It's full of emotional upheaval .If they were like the brothers, all 'normal' (which I know some people appreciate more) then there would be no story to tell.

Reema perfect !!!!!!!!!i have almost said the points !!!!!!!!!!!!
priyachand thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#12
hi guys
i have just recently started watching this serial. but evn i felt that jeevika was more conscious abt in-laws. but she has a point. she does not want manavi to get bad name with her in laws. jeevika is caught bet her sis n her in-law fly. i do agree jeevika feels more protective than just being a sister. but she shd also be perceptive to know abt her sis. i mean she does not try to find as viren did. she point blank questions her. not evn ask but question her, i mean she goes into offensive.

basically she wants manavi to get good name with her in laws. i mean she was very happy whn swamini praised her with maya issue. along with her protectiveness, i thougt she was little self-centred i mean more worried abt her in-laws fly than sis. she is caring to her sis, she after all took care of manavi like her mother. no doubt abt that. but aftr marriage, priorities do change. it is not her husband but swamini n her dikat is more imp. did she ever disagree with them defending manavi? i don't know as i didnt see earlier episodes.


but i may be wrong. this is only my perception with recent watching. u can correct me if i am wrong.
virmaan84 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13
I would say that the show should be renamed as 'Ek hazaaron mein meri bhai hain' cos Viren understands and helps Virat so much...even before Virat knew his own feelings, Viren understood it...whereas Jeevika doesnt even try to understand what Manvi might be feeling...not only in the case of Manvi's love for Virat, even in the cancer matter...Jeevika has completely forgotten about all the doubts she had when Beeji and Madan chachu came to Chandigarh...In the process of lengthening the serial, CV's have made Jeevika quite dumb and the kind who never thinks at all and has no presence of mind...
hooriaa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#14
I to some extent agree...
To be honest instead of nw
It will be more interesting to see jeevika's reaction when...
1)maanvi's cancer is revealed
2)virat's luv for maanvi is revealed
3) when maanvi realises her love for virat and virman are in love

Good post though
preetivr thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#15
Jeevika is right in being protective for Manvi. Though Viren has told her about Virat's feelings, again as Viren said Jeevika thinks they are too immature and that Viren is being blinded by his conception of Manvi - Virat.
But am sure if the cancer track is revealed and she sees Virats genuine concern for Manvi , her insecurity and confusion will clear off.
Am loving the current track.😊😊😊
Bharathi_gurti thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Du_Nish

Jeevika is not wrong. She does not want her sister to be defamed. Even Maanvi has not realised her feelings for Viraat and thus her sister is trying to warn her. Like we say ''precaution is better than cure'' :)

What matters to Jeevika is her sister must not be defamed as what she felt in the words of Swamini Bua while Viren is unaware of the thoughts of Swamini Bua to Maanvi, all he can see is the happiness of his brother and is with Maanvi.
Both Jeevika and Viren are right in their concerns to their younger siblings when Viren pushed Virat to realise what really Maanvi means to him, Jeevika could not do the same, she asked Maanvi but Maanvi denied and she felt that it is better to take distance from this friendship rather than in the long run it grows into something deeper and Maanvi has to bear the wrath of swamini bua.
The only thing is as viewers, we know that it is a little late on the warning as Maanvi has already grown used to Viraat and will be a little difficult for her to keep her away from him , she has said the same to Jeevika and prefered to make Virat to take distance from her.
Maanvi does not want Jeevika to run into problems because of her and Jeevika does not want Maanvi to be bad mouthed in her in laws as she can not hear it, she wants Viren to clear it.
Viren does not want to clear it because he knows how Viraat feels for Maanvi and can not say to Jeevika and so indirectly the allegations from Maya and Swamini bhua can be right.

exactly...i agree...👏...
Bharathi_gurti thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#17
@tm...buddy its actually how we see/percieve the characters😛...usually characters are wriiten from one persons angle...but to get it conveyed as how its written , wholey depends on the way its directed as well as how we take it...so i feel jeevika is just protective and also still jeevika is also just 21/22 years., so we cant expect so much of maturity...all she knows is to love ., and out of love she fears for everything...i have co,me across many people in reali life too...so it is !!!🤗
Nikki_Titli thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#18
awesomee post..i truly agree wid u..i hv alwz loved the brother's relation thn the "main theme" of d show..n jeevika..goshh she hv bcome soo annoying these days..yday d way she purely restrictd manvi to nt go close to virat ws a thing i din like at all..bt still i thot as shes nt aware of truth shes behavin lik tht..bt aaj EVEN AFTR VIREN telling her truth,shes still doing things 2keep manvi away frm virat..y??is virat a gunda mawali or wht?virat is HER OWN devar..bt y d hell cant she trust virat 4 a bit?
Edited by nikki028 - 13 years ago
ILTHBEB thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Prach_VirMan

Actually I agree with you. I don't know why people can't see the difference in relationships here. Jeevika might be Manvi's mother, father and sister, but despite that, she doesn't know her sister like Viren knows Virat. I had this thought in mind ever since the episode when Virat boldly tells his brother about Jeevika and Manan! He knew his brother loves Jeevika, but he knew that finding out later will break him more, so he took a responsible and mature step for his brother!


Until now, I have seen nothing between the sisters besides weeping and oh-so famous dialogues! I abosulutely loved the track when Manvi was trying to break the marriage, but at that time, she had a reason. She did see something between Jeevika and Manan. But what makes Jeevika keep Virat away from Manvi other than her bahu-vrata? Maybe she can't see the love in Virat's eyes, but can't she see the happiness Manvi feels when Virat is around her? I hope we see a change in Jeevka soon. Neither did I see enough of Jeevika. It was always Manvi who sacrficed for her dead sister, and Jeevika can't speak up against her sasural? Maybe am judging her a bit too much, I should wait for the track that might change this. But honestly, I love the brother binding more. They have no cliched dialogues, no weeping, and they still make me aww! They will always be my favorite jodi!

If it were to me, I did make this show "Ek Karodo Mein Mera Bhai Hai!"

nice depiction...i all times impress in observing virat n viren's bro relation..the way viren understands virat n virat abides viren's utterance..its too cute..i don't want critical relation like manvi n Jevika..n u r8 from 1st to last only manvi always sacrificed for jevika..here jevika only consumes luxurious life...wow,u gave a great name of this show.



Note : No offence to JeeMan fans! Or anyone for that matter.


@ blue is my reply.
Edited by ogive_nab - 13 years ago
Bharathi_gurti thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: ogive_nab


well, i know Manvi's feeling for Virat still as bud...but her heart is not allowed to stay away from Virat..n i want this matter Jevika should have to aware without only hearing Manvi's talked...hence, i contrasted b/w Viren n Jevika's thought...now tell me, what will Jevika do when she knows Virmaan relationship in future?? Will she say Manvi to sacrifice her love for both families respect or not will she confront Sawamini Bua n make understanding her for Maniv's love??

well for sure jeevika will stand for her sisters love...she is not that much insensitive person who will ask her sister to sacrifice her love...😛...

many people were asking that if jeevikas priorities has changed!!!...to give a very practical answer...yes., it does...in India., especially to a women...because its the women who moves from one family to another family...its not just that her in laws to be happy for jeevika...it is also that she wanted an ever lasting relationship with her sister with out any hatredness ..😛.all she is seeking is a happily ever after relationship with her sister as well as viren...she is trying to make up things with both the families...its very simple...if she comes to know her sisters love., definitely she will stand for maanvi...😊...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".