Waah!!! PLEASE READ THE NOTES before commenting - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

102

Views

12k

Users

49

Likes

431

Frequent Posters

-Sara. thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#61

Originally posted by: -Pj-

I'm think I'm a bit late to this party. But I'm gonna comment anyway. This show was the first Hindi show I had watched in a long time and the main reason for that was an unique story. Thinking about it is a surprise on my behalf to why I've been here for so long. I normally give up after a while. The main reason is the acting of the cast and it's difference to other shows. Unfortunately the best actors in the world can't compensate for a poor script.

I digress. I heard about this new writer and to be fair to them I had no clue who they were, or what they have written. But many have you have stated that they have written for shows such as DMG/MJHT and the problem is that those shows are vastly different to this one. In a nut shell they we're teen shows that explored lust and love in that region. If I take Virat and Maanvi's story. They seemed that they would go down a different path to the one they are currently on. Yesterday's sequence was fine there was nothing technically wrong with it except for the fact it was picturised on Maanvi and Virat. It doesn't go with what they characters are like or how they have been previously portrayed. Butchering (sorry can't think of a better word) characters is often done within serials over time, and I won't comment in the dramatic change in characters personality on this show as that has been discussed at length previously.

Now coming to the main point. (You're probably thinking she chatted on for ages and now she getting to the point) Maanvi cancer. Well does she have cancer is my question? Like Reemz has said, cancer symptoms only appear when they are suited to the writers. Which is a damn pity as it the most awaited moment and story of the entire show. From the beginning it has developed the notion, that these sisters will go through thick and thin and how will that be possible in this society? It was an integral part of the original plot. But somewhere down the line the cries of online viewers has ruined something that was magical. Someone posted somewhere that the writers will show us things that we want to see. If we want to see full on old style romance then they may change the plans and show us that. My argument to that is- they should show us their story. Their vision. Online fans will always want something but it's up to the writers to give them the unexpected, the vision they see for the their characters. The journey they can take then on. Not what fans envision for the show.

PS- everything is my opinion. Sorry about the post being long and please excuse all grammatical errors, as I'm currently replying from my phone once on my laptop I will edit.


Could'nt of said better.
divya86 thumbnail
Groupbie Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#62
The show is not what I thought it would be, not at all! The behnas were supposed to be the focus, Jeevika was supposed to be silent, traditional (in the 'follow the rules' sense) yet STRONG, Manvi's rock. She was supposed to be Manvi's protector, for god's sakes!! When did she get so weepy and 'not emotionally strong'? Is this the same girl who refused to get married if her sister wasn't present? Manvi was supposed to be bindaas, full of life and without a care in the world except her sister. What happened to her? Why did she become such a Swamini-pleaser? I mean, they didn't even say that Manvi was listening to her for Jeevika, which still would've made sense... Viren was the perfect guy, matching Jeevika in all ways, with just a bit of human imperfection that would've made him SO interesting as the show progressed. And Virat was the mysterious one, the guy who lost his first love and his passion in one go, the one who would be taught to live and love by the (dying) Manvi. His backstory was lame!!! The Maya track was so unnecessary... And I don't know who forgot that Maya was supposed to have STOLEN Virat's music, but that person needs a good slap! I had such high expectations for this show, honestly... Being a huge Nishal fan, I must confess I'm happy each time they come on screen, but as VirMan they deserve so much more! And so do Virika. And most importantly, so do Jeeman! 😊

Edit - Just thought of something @ the song sequence yesterday. May be this is what Virat is actually like when he's happy and in love? I mean, we know he's the PDA kind from the flashbacks with Maya, plus he's the one who told Viren that he'd imagine his love everywhere, so he obviously does believe that... Just a thought!
Edited by divya86 - 13 years ago
Eyes-Wide-Shut thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#63
Dammit Pj teacher you beat me to it but you did help my carpel tunnel lol
Topic maker: Great topic and I agree with almost everything you have mentioned. If I had more time and if Pj hadn't beat me to it you would have been able to read my essay lol

About Cancer: The less I say the better, my dad is a cancer survivor and I work with cancer patients so this show manages to raise my BP regularly.
360155 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#64

Originally posted by: ifyaa

I actually hated that virman song sequence yesterday:(.. And this coming from virman biggest fan.. Everything abt it was totally no virman, they r better than that and do deserve better!! 😕



yes they do !

But heyyy ifyaaa ladki where were u all this time? did u even read this? 😆=http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2924220


Sorry everyone for going off topic 😆

applenpeaches thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#65

Originally posted by: divya86

And Virat was the mysterious one, the guy who lost his first love and his passion in one go, the one who would be taught to live and love by the (dying) Manvi. His backstory was lame!!! The Maya track was so unnecessary... And I don't know who forgot that Maya was supposed to have STOLEN Virat's music, but that person needs a good slap!
Edit - Just thought of something @ the song sequence yesterday. May be this is what Virat is actually like when he's happy and in love? I mean, we know he's the PDA kind from the flashbacks with Maya, plus he's the one who told Viren that he'd imagine his love everywhere, so he obviously does believe that... Just a thought!

I also had the impression that Maya had stolen his music and that was the reason for Virat-Maya break up. But when Maya entered, they showed that she wanted her career. I thought I had understood wrongly. But guess I was right all along...

The CVs arent too good, I guess... They lose the track at times.. That is the reason we see so many people angry at the way things are handled... I would be impossible to please everyone, but atleast they can do justice to the various characters...


Fortune13 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#66
Heyya i love vireka too!! but what to do!!but the Majority don't want to see such a boring couple:P what to do? 😆
pritivirika thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#67
if virika are boring than virman immaturrd virat have no clue of their own love and manvi alzeihmer and don't get me started with the acting def some needs a acting lesson
Fortune13 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#68

Originally posted by: pritivirika

if virika are boring than virman immaturrd virat have no clue of their own love and manvi alzeihmer and don't get me started with the acting def some needs a acting lesson



Wowww what a replyyy:) i like youu:) psshh don't say in public that KD needs acting lesson;)
-Sara. thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#69
Who bashed my Veeru? I'll break there nose.
ifyaa thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#70

Originally posted by: Nonchalant

<div></div>

yes they do !

But heyyy ifyaaa ladki where were u all this time? did u even read this? 😆=http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2924220


Sorry everyone for going off topic 😆

I saw it.. Didn't want to get my hopes high!! Though i would be the happiest person if this piece of news turned out to be true I want kajol to make a comeback without srk and johar!!! Btw im around, enjoying the hungama.. Even the kayamath forum wasn't this bad:( how u been stranger?!Did u see the PLL final!!! I was disappointed!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".