What they purpose of dev in this story

ronshaan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Now that I think of it, what would DEV do if he would be in india while the rape case of payal was happening ? what actually would he do
Nitiya was angry with him that he did not come / help and now that i thinkof it .. what would he do ???
Mrs goenka would make him believe that shauriya is innocent and he would have supported her.
seems like this character is wasted .. it had to be smarter .. ok this character not evil and does for good but hello... he is too innocent and dumbu what would he do

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

2.1k

Users

13

Likes

43

Frequent Posters

dey.bh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Innocence, Ignorance and stupidity are three different words. I choose the third word for Dev.
People who love 'dudh ka dhula' male lead are questioning why we blame this character when he knows nothing about the truth.

What truth is he looking for btw ? The rape case ? The rape case had two parties- The victim and her family and the accused and his family. Either of them are manipulating things and after the Payal's medical report and Nitya's death story or missing story he was suppose to calculate things before doing anything else. But no, he is good and that is enough for everyone here.


Again, his Visa problems restricted him to visit India. It was the exact time when the case was going on. Also, ever since he start re investigating the case, he was almost killed twice. Did he ever tried to understand who tried to kill him ? What exactly is his confusion here ?

People claim DUrga must tell him everything. I ask why ? He is a Goenka too . What if he tell the same truth to his mother ? What if his mother ask him to stay away from the revenge plan ?

People also claim that he knows nothing as of now. Great. He knows Shaurya was an accused and payal was the victim, isn't it ? In htat case, he is suppose to keep his investigation secret to both the parties. He has no reason to trust either of them. I say its fair enough he gives both the Mitras and the Goenkas a fair chance to prove who actually is lying but he isn't doing that. As if he is trying to prove Payal was raped but the man wasn't Shaurya but his lookalike. This way he can keep the cake and eat it too.

No he is not innocent or ignorant. He is only stupid. If he doesn't understand the importance of a high profiel case. If he doesnt understand how difficult it is for a driver's daughter to resist a powerful family like Goenkas, he doesn't deserve to be the part of the whole revnge plan either.
Edited by dey.bh - 11 years ago
zam123 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
When Durga unveils his families action one by one he will realise how awful his aunt, uncle and cousins were/are.
He will become strong as each steps taken by his family against Nitya and Payal are shown to him.

He has witness the tortureous effect of someone repeating the steps of raping payal. The next will be by promising marriage to Payal to change the statement and so on>
ronshaan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: dey.bh

Innocence, Ignorance and stupidity are three different words. I choose the third word for Dev.

People who love 'dudh ka dhula' male lead are questioning why we blame this character when he knows nothing about the truth.

What truth is he looking for btw ? The rape case ? The rape case had two parties- The victim and her family and the accused and his family. Either of them are manipulating things and after the Payal's medical report and Nitya's death story or missing story he was suppose to calculate things before doing anything else. But no, he is good and that is enough for everyone here.


Again, his Visa problems restricted him to visit India. It was the exact time when the case was going on. Also, ever since he start re investigating the case, he was almost killed twice. Did he ever tried to understand who tried to kill him ? What exactly is his confusion here ?

People claim DUrga must tell him everything. I ask why ? He is a Goenka too . What if he tell the same truth to his mother ? What if his mother ask him to stay away from the revenge plan ?

People also claim that he knows nothing as of now. Great. He knows Shaurya was an accused and payal was the victim, isn't it ? In htat case, he is suppose to keep his investigation secret to both the parties. He has no reason to trust either of them. I say its fair enough he gives both the Mitras and the Goenkas a fair chance to prove who actually is lying but he isn't doing that. As if he is trying to prove Payal was raped but the man wasn't Shaurya but his lookalike. This way he can keep the cake and eat it too.

No he is not innocent or ignorant. He is only stupid. If he doesn't understand the importance of a high profiel case. If he doesnt understand how difficult it is for a driver's daughter to resist a powerful family like Goenkas, he doesn't deserve to be the part of the whole revnge plan either.


very well written and i agree with u,

ronshaan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: zam123

When Durga unveils his families action one by one he will realise how awful his aunt, uncle and cousins were/are.

He will become strong as each steps taken by his family against Nitya and Payal are shown to him.

He has witness the tortureous effect of someone repeating the steps of raping payal. The next will be by promising marriage to Payal to change the statement and so on>


its sad that she has to prove them wrong in front of dev
then what is his work in this if she has to open every thing in front of him
she can continue her plans alone without telling him what's going on
Preternatural thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
I agree. if he was in India 2 years ago then he wouldn't have digest the fact that his brother could stoop so low .
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
Debs has put forth all points I wanted to say.
In my opinion Dev is there for comic relief with his stupidity. Or maybe that one customary bechaara character that dampens plans of both parties (Goenkas and Thakurs). He is also a filler character to drag episodes with irrelevant dreams and past flashbacks.
Anurulz thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: dey.bh

Innocence, Ignorance and stupidity are three different words. I choose the third word for Dev.

People who love 'dudh ka dhula' male lead are questioning why we blame this character when he knows nothing about the truth.

What truth is he looking for btw ? The rape case ? The rape case had two parties- The victim and her family and the accused and his family. Either of them are manipulating things and after the Payal's medical report and Nitya's death story or missing story he was suppose to calculate things before doing anything else. But no, he is good and that is enough for everyone here.


Again, his Visa problems restricted him to visit India. It was the exact time when the case was going on. Also, ever since he start re investigating the case, he was almost killed twice. Did he ever tried to understand who tried to kill him ? What exactly is his confusion here ?

People claim DUrga must tell him everything. I ask why ? He is a Goenka too . What if he tell the same truth to his mother ? What if his mother ask him to stay away from the revenge plan ?

People also claim that he knows nothing as of now. Great. He knows Shaurya was an accused and payal was the victim, isn't it ? In htat case, he is suppose to keep his investigation secret to both the parties. He has no reason to trust either of them. I say its fair enough he gives both the Mitras and the Goenkas a fair chance to prove who actually is lying but he isn't doing that. As if he is trying to prove Payal was raped but the man wasn't Shaurya but his lookalike. This way he can keep the cake and eat it too.

No he is not innocent or ignorant. He is only stupid. If he doesn't understand the importance of a high profiel case. If he doesnt understand how difficult it is for a driver's daughter to resist a powerful family like Goenkas, he doesn't deserve to be the part of the whole revnge plan either.

perfectly written..dev is riding in both boats..on one hand he is sure payal is innocent and the case was manipulated, but doesnt utilise his grey cells to point to the obvious guilty party in this case..on the other hand, he gets his best friend to leave town coz of danger from his family, but wen it comes to payal or even the two death attempts on himself, there is no pondering on whether it cud be tht very own family..
he starts off in the right direction and then suddenly goes haywire..tht is NOT innocence, tht is deliberate stupidity..i dnt understand this guy's character..he is supposed to be a smart, successful architect but is as naive as a 13 yr old girl..at times even kangana who is the proverbial bimbo in the show reaches the crux of the matter faster than dumbo-dev..
dey.bh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
@ Anu.. exactly my point. He knows his best friend life is in danger because he and wife helped him to extract details of the rape case. On the other hand he is clueless that Payal's life could be at stake too because of the same reason..To claim he doesn't know the truth and he also doesn't know about Sakshi is a ridiculous argument.

I dont understand the Indian fan following. No offense but not always ignorance is a bliss. At times, it is a curse. It is a curse in Dev's case Not Sakshi be it anyone but I cannot believe he has no idea why Payal's life is at stake.


Edited by dey.bh - 11 years ago
SimSimmer thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
I call him innocent not🥱 He is stupid😳
He is wasted. He just came back to spice up Sakshi and Durga's never ending monkey see monkey do race😊 😔

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".