Can Satya turn positive?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

priyanka

@ankusanu

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#21

y u ppl want him to turn positive aisa hua toh hw he vl be killed

Quote

BabyHimavari

@BabyHimavari

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: ankusanu
y u ppl want him to turn positive aisa hua toh hw he vl be killed

he won't turn positive... relax...😆

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

priyanka

@ankusanu

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: ifians

he won't turn positive... relax...😆

really hoping so ria

Quote

priyanka

@ankusanu

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#24

raavan ka ant toh tbhi hoga jb woh paap krega

Quote

Rachna

@richurachna

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#25

No dear he cant change yaar.
He is pysco person and his failure for rantara separation will make him more mad. as after marriage he will be fail to win the love of Antara.

so I think might he kill himself for being fail in all field especially in terms of mother love and lady love

Quote

Capucine

@Capucine

Navigator

Posted: 11 years ago

#26

Originally posted by: Catatonic_Cat
[I think, when his love towards Antara beats his hatred towards Raghu, it will happen.

This is not love lets not mistake that, he was a stalker plain and simple and the undercurrents of sending a message that a psychotic abusive person like Satya feels love is beyond sad. He doesnt respect Antara's personal boundaries, is this love when you want to make yourself happy at the cost of the person you claim to love.He is right now an emotionally abusive character and he shows signs of moving on to physical abuse. Such characters are black and have no redemption and its better we dont send messages to young women to stay with men like this.

I agree totally wid you no one should stay wid an emotionally and /or physical abusive person. serials shouldn't show that as normal

Quote

Dreamygal301

@Dreamygal301

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#27

Hi, good question!😊

First thing though, Satya is not very perceptive. If he was then he would have seen his mum saying one thing with her mouth but actually acting another way! DM is a cold person not given to affection or physicality. But there is no doubt in my mind, her love for her son is true, just that she has many layers and is not purely just maternal.

So everything she does is for her son. Her empire will be his. Think of it, she makes everyone call him Sahib - but not Raghu even though she is supposed to love him more. So everything she works for is for her sahib. Satya, so far, is seeing the world through a child's eye - the child he was when Raghu entered their home and he still feels threatened. The moment he starts observing as an adult, he will understand and little headway as been made on Friday.

Raghu is like the second in command, expandable when the time comes. In the meantime she has trained him like a dog - a wild one that she has trained to her touch only by feeding him maternal love on occasions. But he is so deprived that he could not tell real maternal love from a fake one and therefore thinks his mother loves him, to a point. He is not so blind, knows that he has to earn it and hence he is out there fighting for her empire! But he never thinks she will twist the knife in him and that is the saddest thing of all. He thinks she wants his best, and I really worry what he will do when he finds out that he is her trained pet and that she wants to kill the essence of his humanity so he becomes her true killing machine. This is where Antu comes in. With her in his love, he needs no one else. She is his love, his everything and yeah it will pain him to know DM has never been a mother to him but he will live.

Satya turning positive. Well, actually he is on the cusp I believe at the moment. I recently mentioned to another person that this is the time which will decide for once and well whether he goes totally dark or not. At the moment there is shades of grey in him. Yeah, I think what started out as a game for him (taking Antu away from Raghu so he wins over Raghu) has turned on him. His need to be loved is rising, yet there is also the desire to turn the knife in her and Raghu as well, for punishment. It remains to be seen if her presence does redeem him to some extent or as the other day's episode (Fri) he is falling along with his Mum. They both have been aiming for the same thing -destroying Rantara and making Raghu unhappy - from two ends and now realise their game is the same. It remains to be seen if they will join hands in partnership but I believe Satya's feelings for Antu might be the disruption between them. He might hesitate...or he might go the whole hog once he realise that Antu will never ever be his.

I believe he may go dark. The story already has a positive version of Satya in Ruksana. She will remain positive, IMO, because of what we had seen so far so I think the writers want to show the other side, when someone is determined to forcefully get love - which will be Satya trying his damn best with Antu. Beside at the moment the climax of the story depends on Satya either going dark or dying, so Rantara have a powerful enemy in him or DM. LIke all stories, our leads need to fight against the villain to win their happiness.

Quote

Smeera123

@Smeera123

Rocker

Posted: 11 years ago

#28

wo negative hi rahe 😡

Quote

807116

Hibernated

Posted: 11 years ago

#29

Though Satya's deeds are black, I want to consider his character as grey. He still has not realised the true face of his mom. What he will do once he realises is anyone's guess. Why did DM, who loved Raghu more than Satya, let him be gali ka goonda and let Satya study in London? Who will ask this question to Satya? DM or Antara ? (Obviously not Raghu as he is blind towards DM). That might shape up his future character. Though his feelings towards Antara are more of an obsession than love, he still maintains some respect. I felt, his reaction towards Antara was more of warning to her, to stay away from Raghu. (When DM asked him to just use and throw her, he did not nod. Antara is not a use and throw material for him).

I am not saying, he is positive. All I am saying is, he is less evil than DM, as he shows what's in his mind (unlike DM). Whether he turns totally black or redeemed, he will come out as a strong character. A head strong person who will stand up to DM to unite Rantara or a total evil whom we hate to the core.

Edited by usrfan - 11 years ago

Quote

her_story

@her_story

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 11 years ago

#30

Originally posted by: usrfan
Though Satya's deeds are black, I want to consider his character as grey. He still has not realised the true face of his mom. What he will do once he realises is anyone's guess. Why did DM, who loved Raghu more than Satya, let him be gali ka goonda and let Satya study in London? Who will ask this question to Satya? DM or Antara ? (Obviously not Raghu as he is blind towards DM). That might shape up his future character. Though his feelings towards Antara are more of an obsession than love, he still maintains some respect. I felt, his reaction towards Antara was more of warning to her, to stay away from Raghu. (When DM asked him to just use and throw her, he did not nod. Antara is not a use and throw material for him).

I am not saying, he is positive. All I am saying is, he is less evil than DM, as he shows what's in his mind (unlike DM). Whether he turns totally black or redeemed, he will come out as a strong character. A head strong person who will stand up to DM to unite Rantara or a total evil whom we hate to the core.

Of course, Antara is not 'use & throw' material for Satya, Antara marks his supposed victory over his nemesis Raghu, also, she is a means for him to get back at his mom for whatever he thinks his mom has done to him. Satya does not respect anyone. A person who respects a woman would never threaten assault on her, or use emotional manipulation, or fear as a tool to control her, or 'warn her' as you put it. I do not know what the writers intend to do with his character in future, whether he comes to know of his mother's true intentions or not. However, him turning suddenly positive just because he gets to know of his mother's true colours, would be highly unconvincing, if at all the CVs choose to go that way. If they intended to show him positive at some point in future, they wouldn't (or shouldn't) have shown him to be using manipulative and controlling methods on Antara, especially threatening her with physical assault. That kind of behavior is in no way forgivable, and is suggestive of a psychotic disorder. I don't see him redeeming unless he spends a significant amount of time in therapy.

DM certainly is evil, in fact one of the most evil characters I have come across, but that doesn't in any way justify or lessen the gravity of Satya's misdeeds.

As for the question of Satya's supposed 'respect' for Antara, I'd like to quote my friend's reply on another thread on the topic:

Originally posted by: Catatonic_Cat
I did not see any respect for Antara or her family when he sent her mom to the hospital so that he can prevent the wedding or when he pushed Geeta Kaul.

Satya is about one thing, himself that is all, what he wants, he wants to get and I am sorry any person who respects a woman would never frighten a woman threatening physical assault on them.
There is absolutely nothing manly or romantic about a man threatening a woman with violence be it with words or action.

Just in case anyone thinks a stalker is romantic , read and weep:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Priyadarshini_Mattoo

Link to the said topic: https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/do-dil-ek-jaan/3818905/satya-respects-antara

Edited by miss_bennet - 11 years ago