Originally posted by: dhakarn
K ... here r my thoughts on shivani
i found her human in reacting to the shocking truth that he had faked his marriage thus conning her in the condition of marriage itself ... she has every right to be anger n show her anger n hurt on the person responsible...
yup reaction was human .. agree on that 👍🏼
n shivani was right in demanding raghu about what right he now has on her to decide on her life ...AGAIN... he is not her husband... he is not her naukar anymore as she had settled his 'baksheesh' earlier ... she knows he loves her n is desperate to get him admit it ... n raghu was tongue tied n blurted out the truth about the fake marriage ...
agree here too .. she just repeated what Raghu told her long back ...
shivani was right in asking raghu how could he 'fake' marriage n fool his family n herself ... she is shocked at his one way mind which is filled only with her n her well being so much so that he doesn't care a hoot about others including his family n a girl he has promised to marry...
yeah it did look like she was shocked with his revelation about how far he can go for her .. it was a pleasant shock though but she is not that selfish to feel happy about it as now she is attached to Raghu ka family too ...
i am in 2 minds regarding shivani asking raghu to apologise to sumi ... for one thing ... shivani has every right to make/force raghu apologise to sumi bec she sees its right (as an outsider or whatever), exactly as raghu sees it right to force her dance with / marry another man against her wish (as her husband/naukar/outsider) ... they both r taking liberties n ownership of eachother's life n decisions n i don't see why the process should be oneway traffic only...
I got to agree on this bit ...yes they both r outsider for each other yet both sort of feel they hv the right on each other which is debatable in a way but thats how the love story is shown .. they just need a name to this relation now ...
2nd thing ------- shivani don't know how evil sumi is ... only us viewers n maya knows... all shivani knows is that sumi had been very bad to her n her only!! ... she hasn't got a clue what sumi is doing in the house to others ... n sumi had only told her that she will take raghu all for herself , away from the family , not anything about she will destroy raghu or his family n all... so shivani assumed that sumi is a just a lot possessive in her so called love for raghu... n not a threat to the family ...n as we know shivani easily forgives whomever who has ever wronged her n doesn't carry any grudges against anyone so when she found out that raghu 'practically' used sumi for this fake marriage for 'her' sake , she thought that may be sumi deserves an apology from raghu ... which is not convincing to an extent
I dunno if I can agree on this because months back Shivani and Sumi challenged each other about 1 month thing when Shivani clearly said Sumi is not right for Raghu .. so all the way she knew Sumi is a wrong choice for Raghhu as her intentions r to separate Raghu from his family which Sumi told Shivani that night itself during 1 month challenge .. so if not full but at least Shivani is partially aware of Sumi's real face and always thought she is evil ... in fact last week itself Shivani dint think twice before telling Raghu that if u dont want me to marry Karan , then u too divorce Sumi and after that she told herself this is last option to get Raghu back in my life which means she was genuinely hoping Raghu to leave Sumi 🤔
This is where I felt it was a bit out of character for Shivani to ask Raghu in such strong tone to apologise to Sumi that moment itself ... in fact Bela was more in character and felt no sorry for Sumi even though both Bela and Shivani r on same wavelength almost when it comes to Sumi ...
I dont blame Shivani here but more the CVs to get her out of character just to do damage control on the whole hue and cry over Raghu slapping Sumi debate and so the sympathy was shown on Sumi here by compromising a bit on the character of female lead I felt ...
as for shivani's earlier condition that she will not marry karan if raghu divorces sumitra , it was her counter to raghu's declaration that he calls of the marriage between karan n her , just like that... bec shivani's next dialogue proved that she was questioning raghu on his right to decide on other's life ... she asks him how would he feel if she tries to tell him what to do... so it was a mere counter ... she didn't actually mean it ...
but she did tell to herself that this is my last option to get raghu back in my life after she keeps the condition .. so a part of her heart genuinely wished for Raghu to leave Sumi ...
n also i think shivani asking raghu to apologise was a blessing in disguise ... we found that raghu just doesn't care a hoot about neither sumi nor his family ... all he cares is for shivani ... only she is his 'apna' not an outsider ...
yes this is true .. also Raghu got to hear how much venom Sumi is carrying ,.. 😆
as for shivani accepting raghu to bear all her surgical expenses ,, i think many r jumping the gun here ...she didn't agree to it , as far as yesterday's epi is concerned ... she sorts of backs off when raghu blackmails her with his 'i-will-die' - 'i-will-commit-suicide' dialouges ... n she makes him promise her 'whether she lives or dies' he will take care of himself ...i only see a selfless girl here ... not a selfish one as some r trying to paint her...
yup she dint agree yet and i think it will put on hold .. Shivani might stsy with him in mumbai but she wont give her consent for operation and then sdome last min miracle might happen ...
n it was raghu who brought her to mumbai hiding details... not shivani who is making raghu dance to her tunes ... n if raghu gives her his 'i will die if something happens u' threat again , i won't blame shivani for agreeing for him to bear her expenses ... but i think she will feel pain n bad seeing raghu struggle for money ...
yeah we need to wait and watch for the part...
n its not just raghu who has taken humiiations silently ... shivani too took it silently when those women were accusing n blaming her for marrying karan for money leaving behind poor raghu when it was raghu who was forcing her to marry karan... if she wanted she could have told them the truth n blames raghu but she didn't... instead she took all the humiliations on herself
thats true but here I guess what many meant is only the RaShi equation where Shivani mostly has her authorative tone and Raghu has his submissive tone which is what is their basic nature reason why the whole distance of malkin and naukar is not going .. the day it becomes opposite , we might see them both as man and woman in love .. we did see glimpses of Raghu in authorative tone many times and Shivani at times in submissive tone too but its few occasions only ...the day I see it as regular pattern or mayb both in authorative or submissive tone together , they will themselves feel as equal ...
as i said , these 2 only sees each other ... look at the extremes they r going