Not like the book, but..... - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

28

Views

2.1k

Users

12

Likes

50

Frequent Posters

bookworm-ALS-- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: 2Obsessed

Nice analysis👍🏼

Just sad that Dylan didn't get to compare Dabbu's eyes wid that of Pears soap. I think he did that in the book.
Not his fault , he got away 2 soon.
Now obviously strangers don't ogle each other ,
only weirdoes do that.😆

Hope he wud find something gud to compare her wid , i.e. wen he gets d time 2 converse wid her.



haha. I am sure they will show that, later on when he gets the time to look at her eyes properly.
BeyondHorizon thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: bookworm-ALS--

@Mandy, Good points... Except I don't really agree about Dabbu being bechari... In fact she was more bechari in the book if you want to look at it that way...crying the whole day coz of a bad review.
As for her being shoved to the background, it's not about clothes but an ability to connect with people and I don't think Dabbu's good at that. There's a certain Luna Lovegood-ish manner about her which makes her a little weird in the eyes of society. So yeah, even if you are pretty and smart, there's no guarantee you'll be popular. I've seen that happen.

I agree about Mamtaji but seriously I never cared about her much in the book either. Love LN, though. Simply awesome he is. :)

Bhudevi ugh dont remind me. Hated her in the book will hate her in the show.


See Dabbu is bound to feel low if she gets criticised so badly for her very first job. Its one thing to fail a test or exam in school or college but when it comes to ur job, u tend to put everything at stake. It was only Dabbu fussing over it but no one else did. But here literally everyone pities her n they make her feel like a bechari. Luna was a weirdo, even from the way JKR described her but Dabbu is nothing like her. She seems confident n pretty in her own right n I defo dont see that awkwardness in her that will make ppl shun her like that. I just hope they sort of mellow down on that front.

I was interested to watch this show for Supriya Pilgaonkar coz I really like her as an actress and I was hoping Mamtaji's character will be depicted well considering she was a woman who had a progressive attitude back in 80's but here 🥱 I really feel Surpiya is being wasted.

Oh I love LN here and every girl should get a father like him 😳

Bhudevi used to crib n act stupid in the book which is defo not tolerable 😆 but here she is so vile 🤢 much worse compared to the book. Its like choosing lesser of the two evils for me 😆
peeyara thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#23
They are trying to keep the show intact with the book and i hope they do that
I dont understand why Mamata is made into crying n over worrying machine 😕 the Mamta of book was way better, she was not that worried, she was not that sweet to bhudevi, she used to tell her daughters to stay away from her matters especially to dabbu 😆
LN is impressive but i feel LN of the show is bit softer compared to LN of book
Bindu was not negative, her only agenda was to get her share of property so that vickyji can start his business 😆 here Binny is always complaining somewhat similar to book's binny n she is funny too 😆
bhudevi was irritating in book with endless drama but here she is being potrayed as negative 😕
now waiting for Dylan's parents n "mera shona" 😆 i loved dylans mother in the book, i wish her character is same as book, dreaming of playing with grand children soon😆
peeyara thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: 2Obsessed

Nice analysis 👍🏼

Just sad that Dylan didn't get to compare Dabbu's eyes wid that of Pears soap. I think he did that in the book.
Not his fault , he got away 2 soon.
Now obviously strangers don't ogle each other ,
only weirdoes do that.😆

Hope he wud find something gud to compare her wid , i.e. wen he gets d time 2 converse wid her.

abhi bht tym hai uske liye 😆
fursat mai dekhega wo dabbu ko toh compare karega na😆
Fly_high thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#25
hey Shreya haven't read the book so can't comment on that but as far as show is concerned loving it so far Bhudevi is vile and Mamtaji not too found of her for obvious reasons others loving them
bookworm-ALS-- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: peeyara

They are trying to keep the show intact with the book and i hope they do that

I dont understand why Mamata is made into crying n over worrying machine😕the Mamta of book was way better, she was not that worried, she was not that sweet to bhudevi, she used to tell her daughters to stay away from her matters especially to dabbu😆
LN is impressive but i feel LN of the show is bit softer compared to LN of book
Bindu was not negative, her only agenda was to get her share of property so that vickyji can start his business😆here Binny is always complaining somewhat similar to book's binny n she is funny too😆
bhudevi was irritating in book with endless drama but here she is being potrayed as negative😕
now waiting for Dylan's parents n "mera shona"😆i loved dylans mother in the book, i wish her character is same as book, dreaming of playing with grand children soon😆



Bingo! I loved Juliet bai too :P I hope they show her soon, loved her :D
As for Mamta ji, well I guess she is not as great as the book, but she's okay so far, except for the shaadi shaadi jaap. She's more Mrs Bennet that way.

I am liking Binni better than I did in the book tbh. I thought they would make her the vamp but by all means I dont mind if they give that allotment to Bhudevi instead! Lol.
bookworm-ALS-- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: vishti.dvd

hey Shreya haven't read the book so can't comment on that but as far as show is concerned loving it so far Bhudevi is vile and Mamtaji not too found of her for obvious reasons others loving them



It's okay if you haven't read the book... The show on its own seems nice enough for now :)
peeyara thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: bookworm-ALS--



Bingo! I loved Juliet bai too :P I hope they show her soon, loved her :D
As for Mamta ji, well I guess she is not as great as the book, but she's okay so far, except for the shaadi shaadi jaap. She's more Mrs Bennet that way.

I am liking Binni better than I did in the book tbh. I thought they would make her the vamp but by all means I dont mind if they give that allotment to Bhudevi instead! Lol.

Juliet bai scenes with Dylan and Dabbu were awesome, always making Dylan embarrassed😆
book's mamta was not that much worried for shaadi, she was modern day woman😛
even i am loving this binny :)

as far as Bhudevi is concerned, I am waiting for her husband n his affair with maid 😆


romaila thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#29
Sometimes its good to be 'Not filmy'. I hope we get to wtach something like this in future, minus melodrama.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".