Whats right with Shilpa??? NOTHING

Logical-Indian thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
Now if your wondering from the topic whether I'm talking about the character Dr. Shilpa or the actress Shilpa Anand basically I'm talking about both. :):):)

This forum apparently has a rule about NOT discussing the actor. But excuse me is'nt she an ACTOR ?? If we don't discuss her ACTING SKILLS then what exactly should we discuss....her pet dog??? 😉😛. So keeping this in mind I'm sure we are free to discuss Shilpa Anand the actor and Shilpa the character. So here goes......

Amidst all the confusion of her being the original Riddhima and NOW a new character "Shilpa" the audience has to deal with an irritating, atrocious and nonsensical storyline.

Ever since the character has entered the serial has gone from BAD to WORSE and from ANNOYING to MOST ANNOYING.

Wats it with ALL the STUPIDITY and NOT so funny jokes??? 😕

As if "Dhanno" was not enough where the 3 devdas's (including one who has just lost his wife and other the love of his life) of the channel find a random girl so hot that they forget all their dukh n dard, we were also tortured with "Raat ke dhai baje" where Shilpa's "thumkas" not only makes a patient randomly come out of a coma singing "dil ne kaisi durgat ki hai" (like a zombie) but also dancing to the song (as if the only thing he was waiting for was a seductive dance number).

What exactly are they trying to show??? What are they making her character do?? Why is "Dr Shilpa" behaving like a cartoon instead of a doctor??? Why is she randomly playing pranks on anyone and everyone for no rhyme or reason ???? Whats with the LAME STORYLINE and the repetitive "jokes" (if u can call them that)??? Why are they copy pasting all the previous AR scenes (with SA as Riddhima) now with Arsh in reverse order???

NOW WHATS NEXT??? Watching Armaan and "Shilpa" lonavala scenes in reverse mode (from the previous AR lonavala scenes). Even the kids in lonavala will go like "pehle baar to ye aurat Riddhima thi. Abhi ye shilpa hai?? Yeh kya confusion hai??" Confused

And I'm sorry to say but I'm really dissapointed with SA's acting. She is playing an already OTT character in an even more OTT manner. Its thoroughly ANNOYING to say the least. Before people defend her n say that "she is supposed to be OTT and annoying" i would just like to say that she is supposed to annoy Armaan and NOT the AUDIENCE. (For eg. Armaan in the beginning annoyed Riddhima but not us) .

A lot of people appreciate Shilpa Anand and the character will come up with things like "Your just insecure or bitter or jealous etc". AHAH atleast come up with something more fresh and original. SA is an actor and Dr Shilpa a fictional character. None of them make a difference to me personally and hence no question of me feeling any of the above for them. 😛

Honestly This post is not to take a jibe at anybody but just to state my opinion and going by the episodes of the previous month I'm sure majority feel the same way.


PS: This post is in fond memory of Star One which has been chucked out of my Tata Sky Package.......Give it some time???? CHALLLLLLLL HATTTTTTTT. :):):):)


---- Dhwani (Hey guys...sorry net not working )


With Love
Shruti

Created

Last reply

Replies

157

Views

14.3k

Users

57

Likes

422

Frequent Posters

Harpreet.M thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
HATERRRRRR

SHILPA ANAND IS THE BEST! she and the character shilpa

and basically the only reason alot of us watch DMG and waited for her to come back
Alu- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
🤣 I knew this was Dhwani
I love this post
I am so glad u took it out from your tata sky
LOL
Anyways i watched one episode i was so annoyed
Be ready for bashing 😆
MysticalRealm thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
Go F***** off u were trying to post your views but you've created a rep of a HATER for yourself!
Really kelp your extremely negative and offensive comments to your self and DO NOT try and change others thoughts towards her coz she's PERFECT!
UNDERSTAND!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Really just ZIP IT!
simplytoxic thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
i personally feel it's the fault of the creatives and the storyline. She is just trying to do the best with the cheesy role, dialogues and scenes provided. she is agreat actress, i think we all saw that when she played the first Riddhima...so i feel that it's the creatives who r messing up
*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
The problem is that a forum should be able to discuss an actor's talent critically but in the DMG forum, whenever says something against SA, they are automatically accused of being a hater. Everyday, I see a TM being bashed because apparently they're either a newbie (hence making MIDs in their opinion) or they are an AR fan who is jealous or insecure. So can I ask, who the hell is allowed to post their valid opinion?

Call us whatever you want but I remember there was a topic criticising JW's acting but NONE of her fans attacked the topic maker.

Dr Shilpa's character is very random. There is no explanation to her pranks whatsoever. Shilpa the actress, I just don't approve of her acting at all. I won't say more but both the character and actor leave a lot to be desired for.

Now call me insecure or jealous but I had this opinion even before I came across KaJen.

Shruti/Dhwani....I do agree with you guys but be prepared for backlash :)
armaanasya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7
"makes a patient randomly come out of a coma singing "dil ne kaisi durgat ki hai" (like a zombie) but also dancing to the song (as if the only thing he was waiting for was a seductive dance number)"
"she is supposed to annoy Armaan and NOT the AUDIENCE."

🤣🤣🤣
BlackWitch thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
Yeah, I to a large extent agree with you. The storyline is toooo lame! I love Shilpa Anand, been waiting for her to come back for a long time! But the storyline is not doing justice to her role. And her expressions are just plain annoying. You're right when you say - She is supposed to annoy Armaan, not the audience! She is very OTT in her acting skills and the character is just NOT making sense.

I hope the creatives will pay more attention to the character and make it more realistic. Masti is fine, annoying storylines and lame jokes are NOT!
riddhan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#9

firstly m not able to understand from whom u have more complaints shilpa the actor or the character😉 n secondly boss dmg had no story before shilpa entered n i felt tortured seeing everyday ridzs crying n crying n more crying n shilpa has come as a new intern so i believe the character needs to be different as every other character or else people wil be bored n its different shilpa the character is a brat but yah has a soft corner too which she does not want to show to anyone as she is hiding something she is not showing her pain to anyone n from now u can't expect shilpa 's character to be serious she is an intern n she is annoying armaan n m loving that bcoz by doing that only old armaan can be back n i want to see the happy go lucky armaan back n yah regarding shilpa the heroine she is justifying shilpa's role perfectly n her expression n her eyes speaks a lot n yah seeing ArSh together is the cherry on the cake n yah m loving it n yah 1 last thing u don't like shilpa the actor its ok but don't insult her so much 😃

MysticalRealm thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: *Reemz*

The problem is that a forum should be able to discuss an actor's talent critically but in the DMG forum, whenever says something against SA, they are automatically accused of being a hater. Everyday, I see a TM being bashed because apparently they're either a newbie (hence making MIDs in their opinion) or they are an AR fan who is jealous or insecure. So can I ask, who the hell is allowed to post their valid opinion?

Call us whatever you want but I remember there was a topic criticising JW's acting but NONE of her fans attacked the topic maker.

Dr Shilpa's character is very random. There is no explanation to her pranks whatsoever. Shilpa the actress, I just don't approve of her acting at all. I won't say more but both the character and actor leave a lot to be desired for.

Now call me insecure or jealous but I had this opinion even before I came across KaJen.

Shruti/Dhwani....I do agree with you guys but be prepared for backlash :)



U know y?
Coz SA fans stick togther like glue they'll not hear any shittt about her what so ever becoz we LOVE her!!!!
Unlike some Jen fans who will not fight for her rep!!!!!!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".