The Hippocratic Oath and Sanjeevani Docs - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

122

Views

11.9k

Users

36

Likes

308

Frequent Posters

403365 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: eveline

and u honestly believe that by just looking at a patient...a doctor can diagonise hypothermia....😆..so armaan just by staring at ridhima should have known that..

No, no, we are not saying that. But I mean if you see someone unconscious on the floor lying, the least you would do as a doctor is check the pulse or heart rate, and attempt to diagnose the issue. If nothing works (maybe Armaan had forgotten his M.B.B.S due to such a hiatus), he could've attempted to take her to a nearby hospital, or if not that then at least he could've yelled for help. He was too calm....we didn't hear his voice even. He wrote a letter while someone was unconscious on the floor, and bid adieu. It was a PROFOUND way to sign off, I tell you...definitely an ETERNAL way to do so.

But I have no complaints with that one specific scene, because we had an aspiring young doctor living up to the oath. 👍🏼

Edited by zainab25 - 15 years ago
-alimabi- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#12
she was lying on the floor for gods sake and he was just looking at her lol

arp04srocks thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: jasmine_87



maybe u shud ask the creatives that question.. and if u dnt know sum people can be partly mentally unstable! anyways he wasnt practising at that time! he was a patient



i'm pretty sure he was practicing as the village ppl said that the "doctor in the town" is helping us but he is gone for a few days....when sid was trying to find out armaans location
eveline thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: zainab25

That's common knowledge, but the topic maker did define the gist of it.
On a credible website (not Wikipedia), the definition of it is as followed:
Hippocratic Oath: One of the oldest binding documents in history, the Oath written by Hippocrates is still held sacred by physicians: to treat the ill to the best of one's ability, to preserve a patient's privacy, to teach the secrets of medicine to the next generation, and so on.
The bold part is relevant to Ammy doc.😊
So what's your point again? 😆😆😆 To point out the spelling error? 😛

first wonder what is that laughing symbol for...and the funny part for me was that a person who does not have much knowledge of it is actually asking an answer why a doctor behaved in a certain way...and also what is the point of this post...actually to point out what ??? u love SR cool....why put Armaan down....?? dont get what has this got to do with ur SR love ??
naadanmasakalli thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#15
he was doing writing letters removing jewellery staring while she was unconscious on floor. way to go Mr Mallik and than you claim she's Your life 👏 he was more concerned about his maa ki payal & kangan than a girl dying .

& as someone said that he wasn't practising sure he wasn't but does that take away ur reposnibilities. i m sure when u r in a profession and even if u aren't on duty u see someone in trouble u try to help them on duty or off duty because even in your off duty hours u are still a doctor or teacher or engineer. a firefighter won't sit in his blanket if he's seeing flames coming out of neighbors house just because he isn't on duty.
eveline thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: zainab25

No, no, we are not saying that. But I mean if you see someone unconscious on the floor lying, the least you would do as a doctor is check the pulse or heart rate, and attempt to diagnose the issue. If nothing works (maybe Armaan had forgotten his M.B.B.S due to such a hiatus), he could've attempted to take her to a nearby hospital, or if not that then at least he could've yelled for help. He was too calm....we didn't hear his voice even. He wrote a letter while someone was unconscious on the floor, and bid adieu. It was a PROFOUND way to sign off, I tell you...definitely an ETERNAL way to do so.

But I have no complaints with that one specific scene, because we had an aspiring young doctor living up to the oath. 👍🏼

that aspiring young doctor ..abusing his oath to suit his own means...and oh yeah isn't he the same one who clicked pictures of a senior unaware doctor...just to blackmail her to keep her mouth shut....wow what an aspiring young mindful of oath doctor👏👏
ParneetS thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#17
just to let u know... riddhima's health got worse after Armaan left...there was Sid present at that moment when she was facing death no ARMAAN!!!!
she was lying on the floor unconscious but he didn't knew wht happend to her.....
btw at the time when this scene was taken CV themselves were UNSURE if they're gng to bring ARMAAN back in the show or not!!!! they just used his presence for that particular moment and then made Sid - Ridz married but however KSG fans left them with no option except bringing ARmaan back in the show!!!!!! soo this scene has messed up AR's feelings just cuz of CV's stupid mistake...!!!!!

sooo plzzz dont question Armaan's professionalism...... cuz we (his) fans might open up another topic abt Sid's professionalism after getting offended by it.... cuz we all know how professional he was at the beginning?????
but i seriously doesn't want that to happen as i liked Sid's character at the beginning...!!!!!
naadanmasakalli thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: eveline

first wonder what is that laughing symbol for...and the funny part for me was that a person who does not have much knowledge of it is actually asking an answer why a doctor behaved in a certain way...and also what is the point of this post...actually to point out what ??? u love SR cool....why put Armaan down....?? dont get what has this got to do with ur SR love ??



yes i m illiterate i accept it and that is why i thought of it thank u

and excuse me is it even mentioning SR or AR love? this topic is Just to pinpoint a doctors duty that sadly Mr mallik failed to fulfill
Edited by -Fizzylicious- - 15 years ago
403365 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: eveline

first wonder what is that laughing symbol for...and the funny part for me was that a person who does not have much knowledge of it is actually asking an answer why a doctor behaved in a certain way...and also what is the point of this post...actually to point out what ??? u love SR cool....why put Armaan down....?? dont get what has this got to do with ur SR love ??

1) When people had no knowledge of rape and hypothermia, posts were created, so why not here?

2) Not everyone who views this soap is a doctor, so there's no point in judging one's knowledge. DMG itself is not knowledgeable.

3) The point of the post is to question why Armaan as a doctor didn't find it necessary to help out a dying lady love. Forget doc, why not as a human being and for the sake of humanity?

4) This is a discussion forum, not a fan forum. Just because she happens to love S-R hasn't taken her right away from questioning Armaan, ok? It's not taboo last time I checked, and hey it doesn't violate any rules of the forum again.

5) Laughing emotions were clearly for your post, as it was just made to point out a spelling error, nothing more.

6) Lets assume you are literate and educated the most amongst all here, so prey please explain us fools why DOCTOR Armaan didn't find it necessary to assist a patient dying?

😆😆😆 <-- Only because I feel like smiling. It's not against any rule to smile. 😛

eveline thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#20
and one more point...normally ...actually in most of the cases..when a person faints ...it is due to low BP or too much physical stress...a fainting is rarely...rarely life threatening...my family is filled with doctors...and doctors do not panic when they see a patient faint..they generally wait for them to come back to consciousness on their own....sometimes they help by loosening the clothes and keeping the temperatures cool.....after they get back to consciousness on their own they advise ...glucose or nibu paani with lots of salt and sugar.....if that does not happen within a stipulated normal period of time...then they take the matter seriosly..so for a doctor fainting of a tired and exhausted person...as Ridhima was ...might not have been a big deal...
and looking at it from a non medical point of view...the man was under emotional stress coz he did not want face her...as he might not have the guts to walk away from his love...so he ran as fast as he could because otherwise he might never have been able to walk away from her...i think that much was pretty clear

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".