Armaan=Edward, Ridz=Bella, Sid=Jacob, p. 5 - Page 5

Firstly a very nice topic.Secondly comparing Bella and Ridz is not right
as Bella was young and Jacob did not
click pics with her. I agree that AR love was
like Edward-Bella love but Ridz's condition
was more critical than that of Bella.

No offense intended and this is what i personally feel.

the only similarities that i see is when armaan leaves her like edward to protect her and jake like sid a friend to comfort her but thats about it their personalities are totally diffirent but riddhima and bella are nothing alike because for bella it wasnt really a choice it was always edward for her even though she loved both her love for edward was far more stronger she cant live without him here riddhima ji doesnt know who she wants

yeah i think cvs r trying to do atleast some thing creatively than copying twilight lol
i love edward bella and bella jocob too but more edward bella,love them as trio
here the same like ARS as trio,but its India,its obvious tend to show woman giving importance to married life

Well I get your point...but over here people(including me) are taking Sid as Edward just because of his nature and all...I know to compare A or S with Edward would be a mistake(I'm a die-heart fan of Edward..so for me it is)....but I guess over here we are talking about the nature he have which is exactly like Edward...and Armaan acts more like Jacob...don't take me wrong dude...but I think.... Yeah Sid was meant to be as Jake in Ridz life....and Armaan as Edward....but here both posses reversed qualities !!!! I hope you get what I'm saying as I don't know what I'm writing...lolxxx

luv Alina

Agree
Armaan can be called Edward but Ridz can never be Bella since her love was way stronger than ridz for Edward.
Armaan did the same as Edward that he left her for her happiness.
Ridz is married to Sid = Jacob but still she stated in yesterday's episode that Sid was just his friend just like Jacob

Originally posted by: -Alina-

Well I get your point...but over here people(including me) are taking Sid as Edward just because of his nature and all...I know to compare A or S with Edward would be a mistake(I'm a die-heart fan of Edward..so for me it is)....but I guess over here we are talking about the nature he have which is exactly like Edward...and Armaan acts more like Jacob...don't take me wrong dude...but I think.... Yeah Sid was meant to be as Jake in Ridz life....and Armaan as Edward....but here both posses reversed qualities !!!! I hope you get what I'm saying as I don't know what I'm writing...lolxxx

luv Alina

ur right the nature of jake and armaan suits more and sid and edward more
i truely love bella decision of choosing edward and now i am more confused that is she choosed edward bcoz he is her first love or bcoz of his nature,refused jake bcoz he is never more than a friend or bcoz of his possessive nature
god more than ARS i am now worried of edward-bella-jacob😆

Originally posted by: bary

ur right the nature of jake and armaan suits more and sid and edward more
i truely love bella decision of choosing edward and now i am more confused that is she choosed edward bcoz he is her first love or bcoz of his nature,refused jake bcoz he is never more than a friend or bcoz of his possessive nature
god more than ARS i am now worried of edward-bella-jacob😆

lolxxx that is kind of funny !!!!😆
😆actually Bella choose Edward as she knew that she can't live without him and refused Jake because she was herself confused how can she love two ppl at a time so I think she choose Edward !!! lolxxxxx

luv Alina

Originally posted by: yasu09

First of alI..... did not think i'd get this many comments...so thank you all for particpating in this discussion......

Secondly, I'd like to to give all DMGians a round of 👏👏👏 as we havn't got any warnings yet...🥳

Thirdly some people are claiming that the compariosn isn't valid here and actually explained their points which I was more than happy to read...

but few felt the need to explictitly point this out with no justification but to disrupt the peaceful nature of this discussion.... why do you even bother....

and yes I know that Bella and Jacob were not married......some aspects of the characters are similar...that is what we are discussing here...most people are aware of the obvious differences........

Now all ur viewpoints have been very interesting....and Sidma fans have made some valid points which i agree with..... eg when comparing Sid and Edward.....*peace*...lol...


But...


* Bella knew that she couldn't live without Edward even though she had some feelings for Jacob and Riddhima said she cannot live without Armaan when she was about to drink poison. The only reason she is still in this marriage is because of anger towards Armaan.

* Sid is understanding of Ridz situation.... so is Armaan he isn't forcing her to leave Sid..... if anything he is actually planning on leaving again so she could be happy with sid...

* some argued that even when Ridz overcame the mariage barrier..she was still confused as to who to choose.... that's because she does want Armaan... but she also feels GUILTY coz she doesn't want to hurt Sid...

* in yesterdays epi Ridz said that when she first saw Armaan...she was worried about how sid was gna feel and didn't want him to be saddened....that's coz S and R do share a bond...*not of the romantic love type though*...

* some are arguing that Armaan felt that if he left ridz she would gladly accept his decision which shows he never really understood her. Obviously he didn't think that... at that time he didn't want to burden her with his mental insatbility so he left her knowing that this abandonment will still hurt hurt her.....


*phew*......

Hey yasu09😊....I agree with your explanation above....

Would it be right to compare the work of Stephanie Meyer the awesome author to Cinevistaas?

Stephanie has put years of effort into her characters and storylines while Cinevistaas do the same in months, weeks or even days