Armaan=Edward, Ridz=Bella, Sid=Jacob, p. 5

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

moosewithgoose

@moosewithgoose

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

#21

actually she loved both of them bt her love for edward was far greater..he was the one she can never live without.

Quote

uzma

@uzmakhan

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: good4nothing
Hey, there is a primary difference between Edward and Armaan.

Armaan left Ridz just like the way Edward left Bella for her own good. Agreed.

But when Bella went after Edward, he protected her and did not go away again leaving her alone. Instead, they resolved all their misunderstandings and came together. (New Moon)

On the other Hand, When Ridz went after Armaan in Panchgani, he went away again and left her alone with a note telling her to move on without solving their problems and trying to understand each other. He even left her to die with hypothermia.

I am sure Edward would never have done such a thing with Bella. Please don't insult the character of Edward by comparing him with Armaan.

I hope that you will understand my point.

well armaan left ridhima agen fer her own gud agen...and how the hell wil armaan noe shez sufferin from hypthermia??😆😆😆

and armaan is being insulted wen compared wid edward!! not the other way round!!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

rahul_muskaan

@rahul_muskaan

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

#23

Edward and bella are meant to be

Quote

shabonjon16

@shabonjon16

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: good4nothing
Hey, there is a primary difference between Edward and Armaan.

Armaan left Ridz just like the way Edward left Bella for her own good. Agreed.

But when Bella went after Edward, he protected her and did not go away again leaving her alone. Instead, they resolved all their misunderstandings and came together. (New Moon)

On the other Hand, When Ridz went after Armaan in Panchgani, he went away again and left her alone with a note telling her to move on without solving their problems and trying to understand each other. He even left her to die with hypothermia.

I am sure Edward would never have done such a thing with Bella. Please don't insult the character of Edward by comparing him with Armaan.

I hope that you will understand my point.

OMG!!!! I couldn't have put it better myself!! Great job!! Kudos to u!! :)

Quote

bengalirani101

@bengalirani101

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#25

Armaan and Ridz are actually more beautiful than Ed and Bella. They have a more radiant chemistry and romantic story. But yes i also agree b/c AR will have to be together in the ened, no matter who else is in the way

Quote

Jenni

@prettyasjen

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 15 years ago

#26

Originally posted by: doukno
U choose to ignore dat Bella WAS in love wid Jacob and she very much enjoyed the kiss dat dey shared.

But she loved Edward more n went back to him!😛

Quote

Neha_S

@Neha_S

Voyager

+ 5

Posted: 15 years ago

#27

In this analysis-certain points are hitting the bulls eye.Sid is like Jacob because he was with Ridhima at the worst point of her life.He healed her,gave her a new course of life.But Jacob never gave her a free choice.He never said:No matter who you choose I will be here.Edward did.

But Sid did:He used the same words to Ridhima and he stood true to his word.Even though he had every right,much more right Jacob ever had over Bella,to stop her he never did.Not once did he use the excuse of his pain to bind her to him.Never once did he manipulate her.While Sid didnt do this,Jacob did.

What Sid did was the same as what Edward did in Eclipse-he gave her a free reign!Choose who you want and no matter who you choose I will stand there and hold your hand.Edward says:I can be noble.He lets Jacob-bella meet time and again all the time knowing that Jacob loved Bella.That was where his similarity with Sid lies.It was only after Arman returned that I started seeing the similarity.

Finally in relation to Bella-we have never seen Bella cry Edward or Jacob?For her from moment one the choice was Edward!There was no doubt-no confusion.Not even when she realised she loved Jacob.
But Ridhima is torn-not only by the marriage bond-she is torn because she cries out whether she wants Sid or Arman.She is confused to an extreme extent as to who she wants to choose.And that shows that Ridhima is not Bella.

Many people say it was marriage which stopped Ridz-was it really?If marriage was what stopped her-then why would she think she has a choice-the moment she thinks she has a choice she stops thinking marriage as a barrier.She thinks she can break the marriage-and this is shown clearly in the scene after Sid's Mom entry-she says I have sid on one hand and Arman on another-what do i do?Whom should I choose?

The moment she thought that she overcame the concept of marriage as a barrier-yet she remained confused.Also when Ridz first saw Arman she thought first of Sid and what to tell him.That shows the extent of her feelings for Sid.The fact that she gets upset when her husband says she has a choice and sents her to meet her lover-shows that she doesnt want Sid to let her go.It shows that she wants Sid to want her in his life.

So its not all about gratitude/marriage..nor is it about love.Its a bond that Sidma share.

Quote

whointheworld

@whointheworld

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

#28

ohhh dangg yeah i thought it was going twilight way or HDDCS hhehh ur rightttttt <3

Quote

whointheworld

@whointheworld

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

#29

Originally posted by: prettyasjen

But she loved Edward more n went back to him!😛

hhe she will go to amyy

Quote

Marisa

@KaSu4Life

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

#30

wow ur comparing dmg w. twilight. ahhh no please dont.
dont ruin twilight for me.
espacially bella's character...shes alot mature...sensible than ridz. ridz dumb n immature.

Quote

1 2 3 4 5

Armaan=Edward, Ridz=Bella, Sid=Jacob, p. 5 - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics