Created

Last reply

Replies

28

Views

1.9k

Users

11

Likes

48

Frequent Posters

Ooolalala thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: .Vrish.

Hey, Saraella


I couldn't agree more - that's what I've been saying for the longest time. If you recall your thread where you asked whether this is Sriti's best show, I declined to agree. In fact, for her, I think it's one of her worst - only reason I don't go so far to say that is that I never watched her first 3 shows to say that w/ confidence. But I can't imagine her character being any worse there than it was here.

I mean, who is your favorite female character in this show? For the longest time, for me, it was nobody, but after Wednesday's show, it became Gayatri. I'm w/ those who've wanted to see Jhanvi, not Raghav, punish Viraj for his deeds. If that can't happen, then I don't see the point of having had Sriti in this show. Any other actress could have played the role of a weeping shrinking violent, Raghav could have come in and done everything that he did in this story, and there would not be an iota of difference, since it would still be about Viraj & Raghav.

In fact, one of the things we've tried to emphasize in this show is difference b/w actor & character. I won't claim to be the greatest Sriti fan, but she is my favorite actress. But in this serial, I just can't stand Sia anymore. Whenever I see her, I go 🥱 As Jhanvi, she was a sympathetic figure, and I'll allow that w/ the Awasthis, she was still recovering from her trauma, so I don't hold it against her that she didn't have the heart to learn bookkeeping from Mrs Awasthi. Even once she moved into Raghav's home, she was okay.

The point where I started hating her was the day Viraj moved into their house. Knowing what she did, it was criminally irresponsible of her not to have told one of them - either Gayatri or Raghav, but preferably Gayatri, everything. In Friday's episode, when she blamed herself for Tashu being victimized, I fully agreed w/ her. Heck, Raghav agreed w/ her that she was wrong not to have told him earlier on the day she told him. I mean, as a result of her actions, that house was unsafe for Krish and Tashu, which would never have happened had it not been for Sia. In one episode, when Raghav told Tashu & Komal everything, they instantly switched sides. Had they showed this when Viraj first entered, this show would have retained its credibility.

Making Viraj look larger than life is definitely a problem. In fact, in the exercise of making Viraj look larger than life, they've made India look like one of the most corrupt countries on earth, when in fact, it's somewhere in the median (currently, it's #95 out of 182 countries - granted, nothing to write home about, but at the same time, certainly not as bad as what they are showing here, where a person, who doesn't even seemingly have political connections, can just bribe the police into doing whatever he feels like. In terms of the DV message, all I can imagine is that it would have discouraged women from coming forward (contrary to the message that Sriti, not Sia, gave to TB in her interview Raise your voice if something wrong happens with you: Sriti Jha recently.) So yeah, in terms of the storyline, making Viraj almost god-like (as if the show is competing w/ DkDM to have a divine figure, which is probably what that 'Rama-Sita' analogy is about) was a major distraction.

Summing it up, it hurts to say this as one of her fans, but this serial was a major FAIL as far as Sriti goes. The promos, like the chess promo months ago, made it look like Sia would stage a coup over Viraj. Nothing even close - it's Viraj who had been running rings around her, and that too somewhere totally away from home. Now they'll show a leap, and what I wonder is whether they're going to do what MLTAK did, which is completely change the theme. That's probably the best option they have thinking about it some more, since they've bombed badly w/ one theme, so they could try another, and if it doesn't garner TRPs, they can wind it up, and then release all 3 actors for better things going forward.

vrish in many of parts I agree with you. This show has always glorify V and always forget raghav sia just for the sake of V. They always show V walking, crawling, and talking and raghav sia scenes are not even play out properly again just for the sake of V.

The Memory loss track was major downfall of this show. Since then trps start falling because people can never ever sympthize with V character but they showed that. It was ridiculous and now when show start picking so now they are gaving leap.

they dont realize people want freshness. they want the lead pair chemistry to be shown but they are so busy in concentrating on V character that now they are forgetting everything for it.

This 5 year leap will take most of part of J journey so what are they trying to show then???

Best thing they could do is that Not gaving leap!

well MLTAK has improved and cvs made a very sensible decision there. they are again showing the lead pair love track but here we didnt have even one.

whether people admit or not, love tracks gave trps.

Sriti Harshad needs justice!

prerna4rishav thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#12
And about the Love-stories part.. I dont agree fully.. Yeh Rishta is a family show.. BV yeah the show got more trps with love-track 😳..

But the problem with CV is, they have prolly the most powerful cast as a whole, but they have no stories.. 😊.. HC-SJ make nice pair, but the story makes no sense.. Now they are taking a leap .. CV is lost buddy.. So we cant expect them to do justice to anyone..

Even as MB fan, I feel they have ruined Viraj's character beautifully.. And I think they are gonna show him as a better person after the leap, which I condemn as much as you do, cuz V's acts are not to be forgiven so easily..

Never mind, when did CV listen to the fanz anyways ! 👎🏼
Ooolalala thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: prerna4rishav



First of all, where did I exactly defend Viraj ? 😕 Anyways.. Coming to the 'Dont reply' part, it's an open forum sweety, I can reply wherever I want.. And I didn't bash anyone out here.. 😊 If you want replies only from those people who agree with your post, then plz make a note abt that or mark the title as 'RaghavI' topic' 😳

Bold part shows who you are defending. yeah you can reply if you have a sensible point to share or else dont bother replying! soryy for being rude but you left no other choice for me.


prerna4rishav thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#14
Okie as you wish !~! Peace out <3 <3
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: prerna4rishav

Another complaining thread of 'Why MB is given so much screenspace' under the name of SJ !


Please don't make accusatory assumptions about what the TM has in mind. If you prefer, we can drop discussions on Viraj, and just discuss Jhanvi/Sia's role here. As I wrote, there is enough to write about in her case alone, w/o saying a word about Viraj.

Originally posted by: prerna4rishav

Anyways, as we all know, this is a one-man show.. Viraj the Dobriyal show.. Agree or not, this is.. If you take the name of this show in fronta ANYONE, the first thing people respond is, 'Oh you mean that show where the husband is brutal and psycho and beats his wife ?'...

Reason people don't think about the love angle is that every show has it, so obviously, that won't stand out. This one about spousal abuse does - it actually has nothing to do w/ Viraj or Raghav, since had the story been switched to make Raghav the abusive hubby & Viraj the rescuer, the story would still be tanking.

Originally posted by: prerna4rishav

No one in reality even CARES about the stupid love-angle they tried to focus lately.. TRP dropped.. Hence the leap nw..


The thing about love shows is that they are largely, if not solely, driven by one's fan following. I don't know about HC or KVB, but it doesn't seem to be Sriti's strong point. In Jyoti, hers was the only romantic setting that was endearing, and the CVs there underplayed that. In RS, TRPs were fine when she was fighting, but just as the show was about to take a good turn, the channel shifter the serial's time slot from 10pm to 7pm, and TRPs tanked. I'm not sure whether Sriti in a romantic serial would be as appealing as she's been to date. But yeah, I'd like to see her take a break from playing double roles, such as Sudha/Devika, Sandhya/Vrinda and now Jhanvi/Sia. Maybe police serials or a mytho could be good for her?

Originally posted by: prerna4rishav

SJ was important unless her character was not butchered to death.. Now she is just an XYZ.. Thanks to CVs ! 👎🏼


Fully agree!
Ooolalala thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: prerna4rishav

And about the Love-stories part.. I dont agree fully.. Yeh Rishta is a family show.. BV yeah the show got more trps with love-track 😳..

But the problem with CV is, they have prolly the most powerful cast as a whole, but they have no stories.. 😊.. HC-SJ make nice pair, but the story makes no sense.. Now they are taking a leap .. CV is lost buddy.. So we cant expect them to do justice to anyone..

Even as MB fan, I feel they have ruined Viraj's character beautifully.. And I think they are gonna show him as a better person after the leap, which I condemn as much as you do, cuz V's acts are not to be forgiven so easily..

Never mind, when did CV listen to the fanz anyways ! 👎🏼

Yeh rishta has a balance between family and leads. They show both equally. Thats an awesome thing about that show and the show got around 9 trps when lead love track was showing. it always head towards positive thing and reality plus lead romance which gave them high trps.

I agree they ruined all characters. Lets see where leap take this show to.

Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#17
VB Note: to keep this thread on topic, let's just discuss Sriti and Jhanvi/Sia here - not Viraj, not Raghav. But anybody can participate - no banning anybody from participation.
prerna4rishav thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: .Vrish.


Please don't make accusatory assumptions about what the TM has in mind. If you prefer, we can drop discussions on Viraj, and just discuss Jhanvi/Sia's role here. As I wrote, there is enough to write about in her case alone, w/o saying a word about Viraj.

Reason people don't think about the love angle is that every show has it, so obviously, that won't stand out. This one about spousal abuse does - it actually has nothing to do w/ Viraj or Raghav, since had the story been switched to make Raghav the abusive hubby & Viraj the rescuer, the story would still be tanking.


The thing about love shows is that they are largely, if not solely, driven by one's fan following. I don't know about HC or KVB, but it doesn't seem to be Sriti's strong point. In Jyoti, hers was the only romantic setting that was endearing, and the CVs there underplayed that. In RS, TRPs were fine when she was fighting, but just as the show was about to take a good turn, the channel shifter the serial's time slot from 10pm to 7pm, and TRPs tanked. I'm not sure whether Sriti in a romantic serial would be as appealing as she's been to date. But yeah, I'd like to see her take a break from playing double roles, such as Sudha/Devika, Sandhya/Vrinda and now Jhanvi/Sia. Maybe police serials or a mytho could be good for her?


Fully agree!



Agree.. But my expectations were to see SJ starting the actions in DS from where she left in RS.. But they have made her such weak character.. As a woman, I would want to see her fighting this devil alone.. Something like Dushman will also do, where the male lead is giving her strength to fight the evil.. But CVs have made this as male-dominated show.. Ram vs. Ravan.. Nothing to do..
Soaps1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#19
This is viraj ka show everything revolved around him ... not just sia ... raghav is mostly muted too ... i don't know why did they hire them if they had nothing for them to do in the show 🤣 The only time Sia is actually not mute is when she is scolding Raghav or with him ... issi liye may be their scenes are the best part of the show ... similarly mostly Raghav only usually talks when he is with sia

Thnk about it in gyatri episode where she slapped viraj ... it would make much more sense if actually raghav punched him or sia slapped him, best would be sia slapping him obviously ... but na they just stood there muted 😆 There are many other such instances
Edited by Soaps1 - 13 years ago
Ooolalala thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Soaps1

This is viraj ka show everything revolved around him ... not just sia ... raghav is mostly muted too ... i don't know why did they hire them if they had nothing for them to do in the show 🤣 The only time Sia is actually not mute is when she is scolding Raghav or with him ... issi liye may be their scenes are the best part of the show ... similarly mostly Raghav only usually talks when he is with sia

Thnk about it in gyatri episode where she slapped viraj ... it would make much more sense if actually raghav punched him or sia slapped him ... but na they just stood there muted 😆 There are many other such instances

Nadz RaghaVI relation is only good thing about this show right now.

No comments about V!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".