'Raghav-Sia Scene Lacked Intensity' DID IT?

Page

Next Last

@rickks

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 13 years ago

I know many of you found the scene between Sia and Raghav to been treated very lightly...And are displeased about it...But this is what i though, and hence i am sharing ti with you...Juts my POV and what i felt the scene was trying to show😊

I thought the way the scene was shot was Brilliant...Sia need not show any emotion to it, because she has lived it so many times in the past few days that there the emotion seems to be non-existent when she thinks abt it...
Like when she told the truth to Mrs. Singh that was the last time she ever lived that nightmare all over again, after that whenever Viraj came in front of her she has managed to keep it still, and not let hear fears or any emotion, expression get in the way...Which is why whenever Viraj wants to see the fear in Sia eyes its blank and expressionless...These days Sia almost speaks to Viraj without any fear, the only part where is falters is when Viraj Brings the Singh Family into the picture, its only then that Sia is shown to be a little helpless infront of Viraj and even tries to make him understand,as she does not want to provoke him which is why she keeps it low...

They way i see it Sia has said this story many a times, she has expressed her fears and helplessness but doing it over and over will not help in terms of story and screenplay...It would be been there done that

But now we can see her story being expressed from Raghav's POV...And it has already started...When Sia gave Raghav details regarding her past, her horror-filled days with Viraj as his wife he was stunned to learn them, but he did not react, there was just one instance when Raghav anger was almost ready to explode (I think that time she was talking about how Viraj raped her) but then after that though anger he isn't shown to be reactive which i think was an excellent move because if he expressed it then, usmein naya kya hoga?

Now he will express, emote and react to each and every word Sia said but its Viraj who will have to face him...I think this move did complete justice to the Character called Raghav as we get to see what Raghav felt after hearing Sia's confession...His reactions when he sees Viraaj in front of his eyes every second of the day...

Now the story will be played from Raghav's POV...Its gonna be all the more interesting...

Cheers Viji

Quote

Frequent Posters

Anjali

@stylish_VJ

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

Okay that's a new way of seeing it...Din't think of it before...Now that you have mentioned it maybe that could be very much possible...😊

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Soaps1

@Soaps1

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

More than Raghav's reaction i felt Sia needed to speak some of the things herself and not be muted ... i agree may be because she has faced it so many times in past few days so there was no emotion but there could still be anger on her voice no? Some how the entire thing in mute somehow did not seem impactful to me

Quote

@rickks

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: style_diva
Okay that's a new way of seeing it...Din't think of it before...Now that you have mentioned it maybe that could be very much possible...😊

Lets see😊

Quote

@rickks

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Soaps1
More than Raghav's reaction i felt Sia needed to speak some of the things herself and not be muted ... i agree may be because she has faced it so many times in past few days so there was no emotion but there could still be anger on her voice no? Some how the entire thing in mute somehow did not seem impactful to me

Well everybody has their own views about seeing things...I just thought of sharing why i felt there wasn't any need for emotions, and expressions...as you can see the Impact has already started from Today...Raghav has taken over, not alone but he is making Sia also do things...He is planning the whole thing now...I found it was really innovative,...😊

Quote

SavageMinion

@Minionite

Channel Moderator

+ 47

Posted: 13 years ago

It's quite interesting to read. It's a new POV. And thanks for sharing it.

Quote

@rickks

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: khota_sikka_sri
It's quite interesting to read. It's a new POV. And thanks for sharing it.

Its my privilege

Quote

xSaiyaara

@xSaiyaara

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

It's an interesting point of view. Thanks for sharing -- love to read different perspectives.

But in my opinion, the impact of what she has lived through will never fade...she will never grow to be accustomed to it. The scars are so deep that there should be something - tears or anger, it doesn't matter- whenever she recalls and relives those days. For example, whenever someone talks to me about something that I am trying to block out, I lash out every single time, no matter how many times it has been brought up. And compared to the magnitude of what Janvi has been through, when she speaks of it, it can't be like a casual conversation.

But for the scene itself, my biggest complaint was not having any dialogues. I needed her to SAY, to ACKNOWLEDGE, what she has been through. And I wanted to see Raghav's expression change with each word because I know HC would have done that so well and I feel like CVs just deceived us given the acting talent they could have utilized. More than anything, I wanted to be in tears, or at least moved, in the confrontation scene but all I felt was glad that the story is moving on. That's all. Not a good sign.

Compared to when she opened her mouth in front of the NGO people that V had bought. When she said - yeh maarte hain mujhe, arrest him. I was heatbroken for her. I wanted to feel that again.

I'll stop the rant here hehe

Quote

Soaps1

@Soaps1

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: rickks

Well everybody has their own views about seeing things...I just thought of sharing why i felt there wasn't any need for emotions, and expressions...as you can see the Impact has already started from Today...Raghav has taken over, not alone but he is making Sia also do things...He is planning the whole thing now...I found it was really innovative,...😊

Arey i respect your POV but since I felt it did lack intensity so i just shared my POV 😊