J Winner but CVs the Biggest Loser

Guys I hardly post in this forum, but I just couldn't help myself today. What was Cvs trying to show today that J was clever because she had her servant count all those grains and she administered the final result😊…Seriously, how is that helpful trait in a Yuvarani😃..she actually had her servant count 'EACH' grain😕…so when she gets the throne and in moment where 'Instance' decisions are needed she will have servant spend countless hours doing 'Futile' job…Man…Cv😡…Please use your brain…I could have appreciated if the Cvs showed 'the Power of Approximation'…meaning counting 1 pot of grain and multiplying the number of grains with the number of pots😃, the process will be faster yielding a pretty accurate result too Cv😃….isn't that kind of brain needed in a Yuvarani😆…I rest my case…😃

Originally posted by: Zaynmohin

This was only the first Maybe it gets better

Originally posted by: -Mais-

Hmmm...I disagree.

Cheating or not, how J handled the situation made her deserving to win. There are times when leaders have to do a job but that job is either too much for one person to handle or so time consuming that other important tasks are left at hold.

J didn't simply just order them to count, she sat sitting them do their job and keeping count of their work done. It means, as a leader she was not only taking responsibility for whatever they were doing but keeping a strict eye on it as well. Being a Yuvrani, there will many projects or jobs being done simultaneously in the kingdom and a good Yuvrani woul be able to keep tabs on everything that is happening.

M was wrong. It is a seemingly impossible task for one person. She didn't see through it. J knew that alone she can't do anything. ANY leader knows that without the support of his people, he can't do anything. J just called her "people" to help her while she saw them do the work. Not only do it, but by sitting with them she was giving them a kind of moral support that they weren't doing it in vain. Their leader was with them while they worked and the leader supported them. What else do they want? These people are born to work and if they are appreciated for it, they feel like they are in Heaven.

J knew the task before-hand, it was wrong. Her attitude after she won the task was also wrong. But how she handled the situation was correct. You honestly can't expect leaders to wake up and do all these trivial things by themselves and waste the day instead of going to the people who are doing these things, watch them, boost them, thank them and appreciate their hard work?

Originally posted by: Kalapi

Well if you are hell bent on proving that CVs didn't do their homework or came out with a boring/useless task then I can't do anything to change your mind.

The whole point of the task was to prove their leadership skills. If it was done through counting grains or counting numbers, it was no big deal. Numbers could be tricky? Maybe, J or M could have the higher IQ. Maybe the servants had a higher IQ. Playing with numbers is not easy. And if you are comparing it with some old age technique of counting stars then a) it was not night at that time and b) that was the whole point to test their knowledge. You are arguing about a calculator and Excel. Well, half of the audience might not even know what an Excel is.

The thing is, you didn't like the task personally. But to a general audience, it worked. Why? Because not everyone has the time and energy to sit through someone count numbers or blood cells. Grains did their work. Because counting grains is a impossible task. When a general audience saw this, the only thought in their mind was "How are they going to crack it?" making them curious and hooked on the tv. That's the CVs job, to keep the audience hooked. So what if the task they portrayed was useless and futile, it did its job to keep the majority hooked and in the dilemma of finding the winner. Thus, CVs did use their brain to do their job. Now instead if they had chosen a technically hard task with so much logic and mystery that only some Sherlock Holmes could see through it and that task would have made the audience change the channel to see something light and gripping, then that was the CVs failure.

So, I don't find any fault in either the task or the CVs thinking.

Originally posted by: -Mais-

Mais, I am not trying to prove anything here...I am beyond that point with Hindi serial Cvs 😃, and Maybe you are right that generally Indian audiences are pretty medicre not know much about things like brain test, my point about a calculator or a Excel wasn't to show if the Indian audience knew or not about these things...my point if the serial is showing a computer on desk of a queen or blackberry on the show then the Cvs can't be progressive for some and not for other, they need to go through fully...if you are read my post I talked about the power of extrapolation (and not really even using a calculator)...Well we are all adults and as adult we can hardly change anyone's POV...I just put fwd something I thought was pretty mediocre of the Cvs, specially coming from the land where great stories of 'Chanakya', "Birbal' and "Gopal Bhar' are the stories told with pride to toddlers...I already rested my case😆

Edited by Kalapi - 13 years ago