return_to_hades thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
Recently I got into a debate with some people on what art is. I considered singing as an art form, while others did not. There is a school of thought that defines art only from a creation aspect. A person is an artist when they are creating something like sketching, painting, sculpture or composing. Singers, musicians, actors are not artists but presenting someone else work of art. There is another school of thought which goes towards a more popular definition of art, anything that requires talent, training and skill is considered an art form.

Can art be really defined in mere words?
Can we gauge art objectively or will it be a matter of subjective taste?
What is art to you and what do you consider art?
Singers, actors, musicians, dancers - are they artists?
Nowadays we use art in a broader perspective like tattoo artist, design artist. How broad can we stretch the definition of art?
What about terms like con artist, escape artist - can art be used to define crime?
Is there an art and science to everything, or are some things limited to art and others to more mechanical ways?

Created

Last reply

Replies

78

Views

5.1k

Users

12

Frequent Posters

raj5000 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2

Brain teaser, even though, have thought and read about it. 😊 Over here would answer the question in brief, can write loads in case of disagreement😆

Originally posted by: return_to_hades



Can art be really defined in mere words?

Yes simple art is any thing that reflects ceativity of individuals. Or for humor its anything that is not a science or classified as different stream by humans.


Can we gauge art objectively or will it be a matter of subjective taste?

Matter of subjective taste. Objectivity attached to arts is nothing but humanly enforced.


What is art to you and what do you consider art?

Any thing ceative that comes from subconscience for the fist time, when already there is no humanly defined word for it. For eg. Painting/Painters... thats arts... infrastucture is arts.


Singers, actors, musicians, dancers - are they artists?

Absolutely, they all practise arts.


Nowadays we use art in a broader perspective like tattoo artist, design artist. How broad can we stretch the definition of art?

No Limit.
What about terms like con artist, escape artist - can art be used to define crime?

Its a creation not known otherwise, yes!


Is there an art and science to everything, or are some things limited to art and others to more mechanical ways?

First at then science. Similar to first talent then skill.

qwertyesque thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: return_to_hades

Recently I got into a debate with some people on what art is. I considered singing as an art form, while others did not. There is a school of thought that defines art only from a creation aspect. A person is an artist when they are creating something like sketching, painting, sculpture or composing. Singers, musicians, actors are not artists but presenting someone else work of art. There is another school of thought which goes towards a more popular definition of art, anything that requires talent, training and skill is considered an art form.

Can art be really defined in mere words? yes.. art is creating something, be it a poetry, painting. singing and acting is performing art...
Can we gauge art objectively or will it be a matter of subjective taste? However vague if many people tend to appreciate something the art has to have something objective...
What is art to you and what do you consider art? Its expression of imagination and innovation
Singers, actors, musicians, dancers - are they artists? yes but only performing art or depicting arts not creative art forms...
Nowadays we use art in a broader perspective like tattoo artist, design artist. How broad can we stretch the definition of art?...If you can control the frequency of farts thats performing art so is making arm-pit rhythms...😆
What about terms like con artist, escape artist - can art be used to define crime?Negative art forms dont constitute art just as negative values however skillful or creative are never emphasized...😊
Is there an art and science to everything, or are some things limited to art and others to more mechanical ways?Art and science are diametrically opposite perspectives where science depicts a more objective truth, art merely gives a subjective expressions...😊

-Believe- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Can art be really defined in mere words? Yes, I think art means a creative way of expressing our ideas...Now a days we people Practicing Art of Living too....😳


Can we gauge art objectively or will it be a matter of subjective taste?

Some time people not able to enjoy the things or they not try to understand the creativity....I believe nature itself a art form ...

What is art to you and what do you consider art? Nature....

Singers, actors, musicians, dancers - are they artists? Cooking,house keeping like that things also a art form....everyone perform diff way..

Nowadays we use art in a broader perspective like tattoo artist, design artist. How broad can we stretch the definition of art?...

Its nice art 😊 Actuly plan2 put small tatto on my hands,.........

What about terms like con artist, escape artist - can art be used to define crime? Yes


Is there an art and science to everything, or are some things limited to art and others to more mechanical ways?

Both are different but I think its related each other, Yoga is an Art but its help humans differnet ways....Teaching science is an Art..😊


Edited by Believe - 18 years ago
6508 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
lolsss i alsov had this discussion a few weks back in class 😆 small world, lolss.

We got a bt sidetracked...lolss and we got talking about Philosophy, and what it is...then the Q was set What is art?

Simple terms, Art can be anything! Some person might think so n so is art, howevr another might not think that is art.

Its matter to one's opinion.

ART lacks a satisfactory definition. It is easier to describe it as the way something is done "the use of skill and imagination in the creation of aesthetic objects, environments, or experiences that can be shared with others"

Art does not just have to cover the basic paintings, drawing, music, poetry etc....Buildings can be seen as art too, anything can be seen as art. Does not mean that people will always agree its art.

Like there was a picture of Myra Hindley made up of little Children's pictures or handprints- cant remember. Now to someone they thought that was Art.

Many were shocked at this.

If yo do not know who she was then, I'll explain briefly what she did.

Basically she used to lure young children, Her BF used to sexually abuse them, They recorded the children beggin for their life etc...and then they used to kill them and bury their bodies on the Moors..a place in yorkshire. I don't think half the bodies have ever been found.

for more info on it>>>
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moors_Murderers

Anyway so seeing this shocking thing they did in the 60's was it wise to make a picture of her using innocent children's pictures/handprints.

So to some thats art, for me that is NOT art.


😳




Morning_Dew thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: return_to_hades


Can art be really defined in mere words?

No, Art being the expression of imagination ,inspiration etc, is connected to one way or another one's sense of aesthetics, which itself a very large, on some aspects, vague term encompasses the sense of pleasure which could be achieved by imagination or inspiration

Can we gauge art objectively or will it be a matter of subjective taste?

In true sense we can't but our collective moral standards as society bring objectivity in it .


What is art to you and what do you consider art?

Expression of imagination /inspirations which can satisfy my sense of aesthetics .


Singers, actors, musicians, dancers - are they artists?

Yes they are. they convey a form of creativity with their own style ..even they have a role in the whole creative process.


Nowadays we use art in a broader perspective like tattoo artist, design artist. How broad can we stretch the definition of art?

You can stretch it as far as you can 😆


What about terms like con artist, escape artist - can art be used to define crime?

here is the limit where we have to put our moral values on top of this *creative *process😆.


Is there an art and science to everything, or are some things limited to art and others to more mechanical ways?

Science is itself a kind of art 😊


Edited by Morning_Dew - 18 years ago
sohn thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7


Beautiful answers Dewey 😊 👏 👏
I totally agree with you on all of them.
Morning_Dew thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
Thanks my dear 😊
Edited by Morning_Dew - 18 years ago
IdeaQueen thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
ART is something which involves imagination ,creativity and which may not have a fixed or standard rules.For me everything is ART.Every aspect of learning or every aspect of life is an oppurtunity to display our artistic nature. Every one is an artist.The difference is how we perceive and present those arts😊.
For that matter....A problem in life is an art which ....can be solved or dealt on the basis of creativity or imagination(about future) of that individual at that point of time.
Maths is an art.....it depends on an individual how he/she understands the problem..howor what method he /she tries to derive the solution for that problem....
Geography is an art...its upto the creativity and imagination of that individual..how he understands the beauty of the geography of a place or a country😊...
Similarly..biology..chemistry..physics..all are arts..art is a science and understanding the beauty of a thing /subject/issue is an ART.
mermaid_QT thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10
everything to me is an art. scientists and mathematicians are artists too.. so are singers, actors and painters.
Edited by mermaid_QT - 18 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".