Why do desi community equate a education to smartness? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

3.1k

Users

20

Likes

35

Frequent Posters

SoyMilk thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#11
While it's not a guarantee you'll be successful with a degree, you're far more likely to have a higher status of living compared to someone who's less "educated." I think being exposed to different subjects also makes you confident in your own abilities and in turn sound less like a bimbo / fool when you open your mouth.

I just mentioned this in another thread but most BW actors can't string a sentence together w/o inserting "um." Especially actresses since they usually start their careers early foregoing college or even high school. Compare some of the current younger stars with SRK or Amitabh and it's easy to spot the difference.
IPSO_FACTO thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#12
Well my parents are a bit different because even though they couldn't get an education themselves they did not force us to opt for subjects or a degree we didn't like and just told us to do what we feel is the right thing about our career. My sisters have a MScs but neither of them is in the science field as one is engaged in business and the other is in Banking 😆
I on the other hand have an inclination towards research which doesn't pay that well in the beginning but, my parents did not have a problem and told me to do what i feel is the right thing.
My youngest brother is not interested in studies at all 😆 He has involved himself in politics when he was in 11th standard and has become an integral part of a Youth Party in just three years, so my parents have given him the freedom to do whatever he likes. So, i dont think every parent thinks in a certain way. It is the padosis and the relatives that make then believe that.
Edited by Angry_Birdie - 7 years ago
Novarieaa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Avocado.Girl

While it's not a guarantee you'll be successful with a degree, you're far more likely to have a higher status of living compared to someone who's less "educated." I think being exposed to different subjects also makes you confident in your own abilities and in turn sound less like a bimbo / fool when you open your mouth.

I just mentioned this in another thread but most BW actors can't string a sentence together w/o inserting "um." Especially actresses since they usually start their careers early foregoing college or even high school. Compare some of the current younger stars with SRK or Amitabh and it's easy to spot the difference.


I fully concur. I am not gonna say that there are not any educated fools, but chances are higher that educated people are likely to have more knowledge, better judgement and reasoning, and hence they are more intelligent. White collar jobs require higher education for a reason and there's no way to challenge the perception.

The emphasis on education is intense for a reason. Educated individuals are more likely to contribute to the society substantially. However, that of course doesn't imply that only doctors & engineers or lawyers are intelligent. Education in general makes one brighter.
Petal_Pose thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#14
If anyone can talk to my dear mum ,will give u medal.

Thanks for the response guys,will reply later.
Edited by Mrs.Peanuts - 7 years ago
1117409 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#15
Because Desi Parents and desi society in general is dumb.
Firstly, Engineers make no money. They end up in different fields anyways because there's such a saturation now.

20 pe naukri, 25 pe chokri, phir bacche and live unhappily ever after.
Petal_Pose thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: aaditi123

Because Desi Parents and desi society in general is dumb.
Firstly, Engineers make no money. They end up in different fields anyways because there's such a saturation now.

20 pe naukri, 25 pe chokri, phir bacche and live unhappily ever after.




I know parents want best for their children and want to do well like other friends kids have.i am grateful the privileges they have given me. My mother has her reasons but she is constantly money money all day long.it's all day long you are getting old and no man will marry u. Get married,have babies ,find a job etc..


I am 25 and she keeps reminding I am getting too old to get married.

Even if u work 40+ hours .it's not enough. I am paying for next semester on my own. I am thankful for letting me take care of my other necessities but she needs to understand I will have career too.
Not the same as anyone else.i am trying to get funding for my own non-profit.I have too much in my life pursue but marriage is not near anywhere. I want to adopt as a single mum but that will be deal with judgement
Don't quote
Edited by Mrs.Peanuts - 7 years ago
BeingChevi thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#17
I suppose it's just because they want you to get ahead in life. Especially if they haven't lived a life of comfort when they were young but were able to afford you some luxuries - they want you to be able to do the same with your future kids and their kids etc.
I don't equate education to smartness. My mom has no higher education and that was no fault of hers - her brothers had to be educated first and she had to go straight to work. But she has taught me everything I need to know in life - discipline, to be honest, to be industrious and to be loyal - if I wasn't taught that, there's no way I'd be able to make a true success of my life or get ahead no matter how educated I get.

Sure you can still make a success of your life but at the end of the day, a degree will get you a higher salary and better opportunities and your parents certainly want that for you. I'm sure you do too :)
SummerRain7 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#18
Well , parents generally do want the best for you. But it also means that they want you to conform to their ideas of 'good' and 'best'. And that's where the conflict comes in. The best thing would be to have an open and honest conversation with them about your dreams and aspirations and why you won't be able to fit into their idea of a good career or life. If they have any reservations about your plans for your future, it will help you understand them and you can address them accordingly.
Having said that, let's also not forget that parents are also regular people who are capable of making mistakes. Because I have also witnessed parents for whom everything is a status symbol including the subjects that their kids should be studying and the careers they should be pursuing. That's why it is important for the kids to understand why their parents are adamant on them pursuing a particular career.

Another thing I have observed is that girls/women are always encouraged to choose safe careers that will give them a good and steady income. A business venture is riddled with risks and hence better left for men to handle.

I would just say that if you are convinced about what you want to do, then you should go for it. Because I have always felt that any decision taken wholeheartedly, irrespective of whether it works out or not is still much better than being forced into one. Good luck!
qwertyesque thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Mrs.Peanuts



I know it's not Bollywood releated.

Just could not sleep because on asking why do desi parents think unless you are a doctor or an engineer,you are dumb and not smart. Why is the salary more important than finding job you love? a great salary provides a great lifestyle but ending with a job you hate is worth the hassle . You should have a stable salary but does money constitute your entire happiness?

Why do desi parents equate education with intelligence? Both are two different subjects.You can have a degree but be dumb.

Why does esp. desi parents want their child to in the profession as everyone else?


I find myself asking this question every day because my mother thinks unless I do go into IT ,I am a failure ..


You can ignore if u guys want.. will delete it later .




Its simply logical. Medicine and Engg.. MAth.. IT requires extremely efficient use of left brain... and kind of establishes the base level of how much brain one has.. Later people who have no prowess in these arts.. can become successful through hardwork, netowrking...etc.. but that they dont have the base quality remains with them...

The left brain is not that great but one can always use your right brain to be happy and whatever else...
RamKiSeeta thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#20
I think there are values to be learned from both sides. We cannot lay all blame on parents. Even society shares a large part of blame. In many Asian countries, doctors, engineers, and businessmen make the most money. It's a fact of life. Now, does that mean other fields are worthless? Certainly not, every field is valuable and important to society, but when the market does not financially support other fields, going into those fields will be very challenging to people. That does not mean they shouldn't follow their dreams. If it's their dream and passion to pursue one of the lesser known fields, then they should go for it and work hard, but they should also expect challenges and be ready to face them.

For example, I am in the Mental Health field and work as a counselor. Even in the US, counselors/therapists make very little money compared to other fields in healthcare, even though they work just as hard. Psychology is my passion and thus I went for it, but even while working, I am not financially independent because the salary I make is not enough for a person to live on their own. I am married and my husband is an engineer, and thus I am not too worried about my salary because my husband is the main breadwinner of my family, giving me time to build experience and grow in my career without worrying about money.

If a person wants to be financially independent from their parents, then they should choose a field that pays well, because otherwise they'll be dependent on parents, or spouse for a long time, and in the case of parents, if they want their children to make money earlier and not be a burden on them when they're nearing retirement, can we blame them? Parents work their whole life to provide for us, and when they're nearing retirement it's our turn to provide for them, so we too should make smart choices when it comes to career. If we choose a career that won't put food on our tables, simply because it's our passion, can we blame parents for being disappointed?

I don't think parents should force their children into a career, but I also feel like children too should compromise their interests sometimes in the face of practicality. If they're married, it gives them a little more freedom to pursue their interests, especially if their spouse's salary is enough to run the family for a while. Both spouses should decide how they want to do things so there's no financial burden on the family, but when it comes to a child living in their parents' home, I think it's fair for parents to have a say in what their child does in life, though nothing should be forced against will.

Related Topics

Debate Mansion Thumbnail

Posted by: Viswasruti

2 months ago

"Is Our Education, Our Choice" or "Parents' Choice?"

Education is not solely about earning a great living. The great aim of education is not knowledge but seeking an opportunity for meaningful...

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".