Why do desi community equate a education to smartness?

Petal_Pose thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#1


I know it's not Bollywood releated.

Just could not sleep because on asking why do desi parents think unless you are a doctor or an engineer,you are dumb and not smart. Why is the salary more important than finding job you love? a great salary provides a great lifestyle but ending with a job you hate is worth the hassle . You should have a stable salary but does money constitute your entire happiness?

Why do desi parents equate education with intelligence? Both are two different subjects.You can have a degree but be dumb.

Why does esp. desi parents want their child to in the profession as everyone else?


I find myself asking this question every day because my mother thinks unless I do go into IT ,I am a failure ..


You can ignore if u guys want.. will delete it later .

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

3.1k

Users

20

Likes

35

Frequent Posters

Life_Is_Dutiful thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
I will say only one thing. Every parent wishes good for their child. Unfortunately in this materialistic world, people assume that Money is the most important thing that brings happiness so they want their child to do big jobs, earn money and be happy.
Btw, why are only desi parents blamed for it? I have seen many videsi parents also doing the same with their children.😆
Angel-likeDevil thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
Well not ALL.. but generally all parents wish good for their kids, it's only because they're concerned but are exposed to many if not all dimensions of the insecure ugly real life more than us kids.
In this materialistic world, money, degree, a "name" etc matter... whether you are smart or not. I won't speak about name or reputation.


It's true though, we should follow our passion, do what we like, focus on growing as a person, etc, but... parents know what it is that will fetch you a good medical treatment should you fall ill tomorrow - it's money.

There should be a balance though, parents shouldn't FORCE it, but should know where to let go and go easy on their kids.. They should communicate like friends and put forth their concerns constructively no matter how difficult their worries may be. It's when parents try to micro-manage and emotionally blackmail their kids that all problems arise.

Some parents act like it's a do or die scenario and that causes pressure, other unwanted avoidable problems(being driven to suicide).

If the world outside was good, I doubt ANY parent would ever ask their child for degree or career or intelligence if the world outside was 'good' or a safe place to live in. Parents love you for whatever you are, smart or not, rich or not, academically good or not, this job or that job - doesn't matter to them.. But their concerns (sometimes delusional) weigh tooo heavily on their heads and hearts that they sometimes end up taking it out on their children in a toxic way, they are also innocent and cannot exactly foresee the effect of such pressure on the child. That is the root of such problems, healthy friendly communication is a must, and knowing when to go easy.. for this, you have to stop for a minute and look into the child's eyes..

TBH, according to me, there's no right way or a better path.. any path you take, there will seem a hundred other paths that look better, but again, this could be my idealistic young blood talking so I'll stop :p




PhunsukWangdu thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
Times have changed. Many parents have given freedom to kids to pursue their dreams and their life partners. This is just the beginning and others will change too.
1127278 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
Never spent a day in college

An I drive a Porsche 😳
RamSiyaRam thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: ChadDimera

Never spent a day in college

An I drive a Porsche 😳



Your Papa the great 😆


Not necessarily, parents are proud when their child becomes IAS officer too. Majorly it's what gives you income and reputation. Engineering has applications in all walks of life so its utility remains. Medical is about life hence important.
cory thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
Because they cant come out of their silly desi thoughts and enforce on their children
Education is important no doubt, but you dont in todays time need degrees like the old fashioned way then get a job straight after, now ppl just do short diploma courses centered on their subject pass it get a merit or distinction and they are on their way to earning money big time. i know many educated folk stuck in a mundance lifestyle and not even earning half as much as their education they've had.

Regarding your Mom i will just say do what YOU want to do, your'e no fallure this failure winner thing is all in the mind its an illusion, do whatever gives you inner peace and satisfaction creatively,
S_H_Y thumbnail
Screen Detective Participant Thumbnail 13th Anniversary Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
Coz largely engineering and doctors provides an stable job and have many more vacancies than other jobs.
India being poor country, parents always want that they get a more "safe" degree and are able to get a job easily.
Let' say your kid want to be sportsperson , except cricket most sports don't pay very well and you have to be exceptional by indian standards to be noticed in your sport and get decent wages.
As for salary, everyone judges people by how much wealth and salary person had , you can be a shitty son but if you earn well will be preferred over being decent son with below par income.
Not to add that guys wont get married easily if income don't support the girls satisfaction.

Now, the attitude is changing a little with liberalisation more varied jobs have come and one can see youngsters attending different than norm courses.
One have to consider the fact people born in authoritian regime of 70s are the parents now , next generation would have ppl born in 80s n 90s as the parent of teenagers and younger 20s and they would be more progessive than earlier gen.
This also lead to why current parents thought educated ppl are smarter, coz that's the way things were supposed to be as education was a luxury than.
s4santu thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
Education system and the fear for a stable life...
In our parents time, if u have a govt. job ur life is settled and how u get that, by marks and ranks...so good rank=smart, their mind set is still like that


1098676 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10
Forget parents, do people in general care about education or intelligence?? All they care about is getting a degree and a job, which pays you a high salary. Not saying it's something bad.

As for parents wanting their kids to pursue Engineering or Medical, as others have already said, these fields provide more stable jobs and of course high salary(which is the only parameter of getting respect in life.)Parents want their kids to have a degree, which provides more options for jobs.

Even if you don't get a job in Engineering or Medical field after getting a degree, still you can get a job in other fields if you wish. That's why parents force their kids to go in one of these two fields, even if they are not interested or not good at it. Like if you are not successful, you still have something else to do. But if you are successful, it'll make your life. It's more like "trying your luck".

Following your dreams and passion is of course the best thing to do. But sadly, world is not so perfect. People don't even realize, what is their passion for more than half of their life. From childhood, we are told that our goal is to first get a degree, then a high paying job, then get married, then have kids, and then pass it this to your kids. We never get time to polish our skills, and having big dreams is a crime in this society. India is a country where people hardly get chances to pursue their dreams. There is so much scarcity of jobs and opportunities, that you don't stand a chance if you are anything less than outstanding.

Parents are not completely wrong. I'll say, people should go for their passion only if they are exceptionally talented in that field. Because there is a difference between what you love and what you are good at. Also we have to take stability and salary into consideration, because it does matters whether we like it or not.


Related Topics

Debate Mansion Thumbnail

Posted by: Viswasruti

2 months ago

"Is Our Education, Our Choice" or "Parents' Choice?"

Education is not solely about earning a great living. The great aim of education is not knowledge but seeking an opportunity for meaningful...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".