Where do you think we came from? - Page 10

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

50.6k

Users

28

Likes

1.2k

Frequent Posters

Freethinker112 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#91
@Vintu and others

The discussion can get nowhere if we use terms in a context only to see that the other person took it as something else. So, let's clear out some things first.

What exactly do we mean by consciousness here? It is a very broad term. While sleeping, we are not "actively" processing information, but the body is still "aware" and carrying out it's job. So, our body can still sense but is it conscious?

Maybe sentience would be better term for what we are trying to discuss, "having experience".
Vintage.Wine thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#92

Originally posted by: Freethinker112

The hand stopped sending me signals, but my brain is fine right? The sensory experience "machinery" is still there, receiving no input. Our senses have somewhat diminished by losing a sensory part, but is our consciousness diminished?

Alright ...Alright ...😆...But then some people lose their abillity to smell or a few become deaf or blind . ..( Blind physically ..And Not in LOVE ...😆 ..The worst I have heard of is someone becoming Dwarf in LOVE ..What a Liar ...Sheesh ! ..😆 ) The sensory organs / machinery are still there, generating nuff signals ..but the brain is on the blink ..= Leading to the loss of sensations pertaining to that perticular organ / sense ... ..Which still doesn't mean the Eyes, the Ears or the Nose ..ie : The living cells in there have died ...In some cases ..all sensory mechanism works well ..Like in the case of the color blind people ..They can see all colors but can't comprehend the signal well ... ..life defo is independent of abillity to sense ..or awareness or cognition..

To sum up the aforementioned points ..Organs lose something EXTRA, a level of consciousness thats subtle and beyond the control of the brain ...as they are slit off the body ..And the death occurs LOCALLY ...the part thats been cut off dies ..Which in turn means the consciousness there is lost ...😊



No one can revive from brain death, the cognitive functions are lost forever. As to the beating of heart, a site answers the question.

No one can regain the LEVEL of consciousess that enables them to reciprocate / communicate with the outside world you mean ..Right ? ..but in the case of brain dead people ..a million other cells n their body can still be alive ....I'm being literal here ..I ain't going by the popular definition of DEATH as stated by me earlier on ...


http://www.carolinadonorservices.org/brain_death.php

^^^ Exactly my point ...Heart won't be dead in such a case ..And this is connotative ...The death of the brain and it's conscious mechanism doesn't override the heart's abillity to live and Lab Dab ..😛


Kidney working is a conscious decision? 😕 Do you take that decision every time your kidney functions?

When we sleep too, we are alive but not conscious. That should make you appreciate the difference between being alive and conscious. You keep using them synonymously.

And yes, to be self aware, you gotta be alive right?

..The decision to filter out something ie : Creatinine , leaving behind something else ie : Protein thats needed for the body sounds like a conscious one, like a encoded, conscious instruction that gets executed automatically and correctly ..And let me tell ya ..there is some definite program that all of us come preloaded with that changes some decisions irrespective of our will or desire ...I ll give ya a couple of examples ...The simplest being ...The Uncontrolled growth of the cells ...Commonly alluded to as Cancer ..If the brain can take the conscious decisions or instruct our organs to correct their blunder ..such a disaster won't happen ...But it does...when the program malfunctions for the worse ..and the decisions ( In accordance with whats embedded the DNA ..) are changed ..

Another such example is ' Autoimmune diseases' ...LIke ITP = Immune Thrombocytophenic Perpura ... <<< See ..what happens here is ..Our own immune system starts to reckon our own Platelets as enemy cells ...Foreign maerial .and starts to annihilate them inside the Spleen ..<< Now who took this decision ? If the organ's actions were governed by our conscious brains? The state is fatal and leads to profuse bleeding everywhere inside the body ...including the brain ..

You just stated it all yourself ...In sleep we are not conscious ? << Um ...There is another something called the Subconscious mind too ..And in either case ..are you suggesting that the Consciousness is LOST during the sleep ? << That makes the sleep and the death sound the same ...😆 ..or wait ...install a camera in your bedroom ( Just make sure you are the only human in the BED that time to make everything look decent...😆 ) and let the Bed Bugs bite ya ...And you ll see yourself scratching at that point as the camera records your movements ...Now do you think a Dead Persons would react the same way ? Scratch around if the Bugs bite them ? ...😆

Of course for being Self aware ..one has to be alive ..but for being Alive one doesn't necessarily need to be Self Aware ..<< That's the sweet point ..😆



If it is an energy, there should be a way to detect it, right? And now you talk about degrees. How do we measure degrees? And I think a particular arrangement of matter gives rise to consciousness, not vice versa.

^^^ WTH ...😆 ..This ain't as abstruse as knowing what CAME first ..The Chicken or the Egg ..😆 ...Are ya trying to say that the MATTER came first and the Energy ( Which I'm sure is conscious ) followed that ? ..Well ...Let me assert FREE ...There is no point being tetchy about the whole thing .. Columbus travelled WESTWARDS to reach the EAST ..and accidentally found a newer continent ...I don't think we would get lucky like him in this situation ..the conundrum ain't that easy , and the mystery is way too shrouded ...We might believe we are headed forward ..but we are sure to reach the point from where we had started back in time...the point where we left the last thread ...and the question unanswered ..Everything comes back to ONE thing ..where did the first piece of matter come from ..and to even try to know that we must admit first that it was the energy that created everything ...

The
Law of Conservation of Energy states : Energy can't be created or Destoyed .. <<< When we know this and make it the base of a vast portion of our contempoary science ..is there even a point to go identifying the Origin ? <<< See ..We are on about the Energy ..that has existed forever ...and shall exist forever ...It existed when no matter did ..and shall exist after all the matter is gone ..May be to create more ...So the Energy it is that CAME first ...Now if you agree to this ..my question to you is ... Did that energy take a Conscious decision to create matter ? and everything thats so astoundingly systematic in nature ? Who promulgated the laws that bind everything so impeccably well ? And if you think there was no degree of consciousness involved in the procedure, ...I would like you to give me a reason how and why do you think such randomness could lead to the creation of the Universe ..or may be Multiverse ..so vast ...so big ... And then we can carry on from there ...



Are we conscious when asleep?

^^ Yesh ..Yesh ...Free ..We are conscious when asleep.. .for the reason stated above ...The Bed Bugs case I mean ..😆




Vintu ...😛

PS : The comments in bewitchng Blue font are mine ..and the ones in the default font are yours ...I hope I learn how to quote someone here on IF before I quit being the part of IF or the World ..<< Whichever happens first ...😆


Edited by Vintage.Wine - 12 years ago
McNinja thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#93

Originally posted by: Freethinker112

@Vintu and others


The discussion can get nowhere if we use terms in a context only to see that the other person took it as something else. So, let's clear out some things first.

What exactly do we mean by consciousness here? It is a very broad term. While sleeping, we are not "actively" processing information, but the body is still "aware" and carrying out it's job. So, our body can still sense but is it conscious?

Maybe sentience would bebetterterm for what we are trying to discuss, "having experience".



FT, to be honest the term consciousness is being thrown around so much that I lost track of what was being said. 😆

What exactly is the current debate if you can summarize quickly. Conscious mind vs. unconscious?
Vintage.Wine thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#94

Originally posted by: McNinja



FT, to be honest the term consciousness is being thrown around so much that I lost track of what was being said. 😆

What exactly is the current debate if you can summarize quickly. Conscious mind vs. unconscious?



True that Ninja Girl .. ...The caravan here seems to have lost its way chasing the cosciousness mirage ..But I believe that FT is a astute operator and was easily the smartest person on THIS PAGE until you had posted.. 😆.. . I extol FT for his abillity to scrunge the meaning of the simplest known words , to pretend to be confused and create confusion amongst the opponents ..as much as I extol you for your Bold, to the point posts ...😛 .

Okay ..I won't quibble more and get straight to the point ..a set of questions that haunt my mind which I would wanna put forward for your consideration ...

A. If we believe in the laws of Physics ...We believe that the ENERGY existed forever ...The matter though didn't .. We understand that the earliest particles ( Imaginary ones ) were Gravitons ...So its obvious that the ENERGY created everything ( May be in a closed, rounded time dimension ? ) ..all matter , all the amusing permutation combinations of particles outta NOWHERE .. Now swear on DM and tell me do you really think such a massive event can be random ? Still creating everything so stupefyingly systematic ? Bound by laws ? Does the science know all forms of energy ? Do we have another example of such randomness ? Even on a less massive scale?

B. Do you believe we are in a Universe ..was big bang unique ? or are we in a Multiverse ? And many such bangs musta happened ? At different time intervals ?

C. Whats so wrong with naming that Energy as The God ? ( I woulda liked to call it Vintu ..but I fear a few might raise objection ...😆 ) unless anyone has the Patent for that NAME ...😆

Phew !!

Vintu ...😛


CuckooCutter7 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#95
ok, i can answer that for poultry. Take a hen. Hen came from an egg unless it got scrambled as breakfast first. Now where did the egg come from? The hen, stupid. 😆
246851 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#96
Deriving this knowledge from big bang theory, a tv soap,( I know I am pathetic)
but our lives might be actually acing out of a painting in a higher dimensional universe.😆
Vintage.Wine thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#97

Originally posted by: tannipartner

Deriving this knowledge from big bang theory, a tv soap,( I know I am pathetic)

but our lives might be actually acing out of a painting in a higher dimensional universe.😆



Aww ...Welcome to the battlefield Private Tanni ...Would you like to Partner up with us believers or be the greatest ever addition to the huge Atheist army here ? ..Please ? ....😆
Even the thought is nuff to send shivers down many spines ...But trust me if you choose to play an atheist, although few in number, expect us to put up a fiercest E fight with yall...And No ..Even that Super Cute DP can't thwart our efforts to Prove that the God exists ..😆 ...

Um ..I guess you are yet to take a clear stance ..right ? How about we working out a quick Under The Table Deal before that? 😉... Do you accept bribes? I promise I ll pay ya handsomely ☺️ to stand shoulder to shoulder with us believers ..

Vintu ...😛
246851 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#98

Originally posted by: Vintage.Wine



Aww ...Welcome to the battlefield Private Tanni ...Would you like to Partner up with us believers or be the greatest ever addition to the huge Atheist army here ? ..Please ? ....😆
Even the thought is nuff to send shivers down many spines ...But trust me if you choose to play an atheist, although few in number, expect us to put up a fiercest E fight with yall...And No ..Even that Super Cute DP can't thwart our efforts to Prove that the God exists ..😆 ...

Um ..I guess you are yet to take a clear stance ..right ? How about we working out a quick Under The Table Deal before that? 😉... Do you accept bribes? I promise I ll pay ya handsomely ☺️ to stand shoulder to shoulder with us believers ..

Vintu ...😛


chillux, I am a staunch believer in God and Nope logic cannot dispel it. I am bad in arguing about it, since I go more by faith on that topic than by anything else and yes I think the universe is older than 6000 yrs but I am fully believer in God made us and also we are acting out of painting ie big bang and all.😆 So I would sit this one out.
Edited by tannipartner - 12 years ago
Vintage.Wine thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#99

Originally posted by: BirdieNumNum

ok, i can answer that for poultry. Take a hen. Hen came from an egg unless it got scrambled as breakfast first. Now where did the egg come from? The hen, stupid. 😆



Ahahaha ...😆 ..Right ..But let's not be jealous of the Hens ..Cause their origin is now known ..and we humans are still groping around to find our ...Oh! Please ..😆
Vintage.Wine thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: tannipartner


chillux, I am a staunch believer in God and Nope logic cannot dispel it. I am bad in arguing about it, since I go more by faith on that topic than by anything else and yes I think the universe is older than 6000 yrs but I am fully believer in God made us and also we are acting out of painting ie big bang and all.😆 So I would sit this one out.




Aww ..Okay ..That assurance was pretty relieving ...😆 ..I must thank ya though for saving me Money ( Money that I never actually had ...😆 ) too ...Now I can safely pretend to feel bad for FREETHINKA ..I bet he musta rejoiced your entry ...And now that you are on My = The God's side ..he must be naffed off nuff to wanna deuce me again ... ..Sheesh !! ..😆

Vintu ..😛


Edited by Vintage.Wine - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".