Incest | A Sin Or Not | - Page 9

Originally posted by: Ankithate

comparison between fornication and incest .
u cant really !

fornication is just u are not married , having sex means what ? u have sex with the person for whom u love and have spme kind of feelings.
jusging somthing on basis of sex is certainly not correct !
if u love some one and both the adults are okay with it , the marriage question shouldnt rise ? its all long back culture story now .!
and about culture , there many looop hole in our culture i hope u know that .!
comparing incest or fornication with culture is a hypocrite thing as fad as i am concerned !

My dear, I wasn't comparing fornication to incest in its entirety. I was routing the two to being sins w.r.t. to marriage.

So the deduction is:

1. Fornication = Sin
2. Incest = Sin
3. Incest = Consensual sex with immediate or close relatives (Marriage not possible)
4. Fornication = Consensual sex between two individuals not related to each other. Here, marriage between the two is possible. However, the two may choose to not be married.

Therefore,

5. Incest = Unmarried sex
6. Fornication = Unmarried (premarital) sex
7. Sex before marriage of any kind is forbidden / declared to be sinful.

Which winds down to:

Incest being synonymous to Fornication, which is a sin.

Hope this helps you understand my viewpoint.

Originally posted by: -Xaffron-

My dear, I wasn't comparing fornication to incest in its entirety. I was routing the two to being sins w.r.t. to marriage.

So the deduction is:

1. Fornication = Sin
2. Incest = Sin
3. Incest = Consensual sex with immediate or close relatives (Marriage not possible)
4. Fornication = Consensual sex between two individuals not related to each other. Here, marriage between the two is possible. However, the two may choose to not be married.

Therefore,

5. Incest = Unmarried sex
6. Fornication = Unmarried (premarital) sex
7. Sex before marriage of any kind is forbidden / declared to be sinful.

Which winds down to:

Incest being synonymous to Fornication, which is a sin.

Hope this helps you understand my viewpoint.

Thats what i said , ur ^ statement is just on the basis of so called culture !

Culture?! 😳

Nowhere have I used culture and it's reference. It's religion that I used to support my viewpoint.

The very concept of "Sin" pertains to religion, not to culture. Cultures are secondary. They usually stem from their adherence to a certain religious philosophy or ideology.

Originally posted by: -Xaffron-

Culture?! 😳

Nowhere have I used culture and it's reference. It's religion that I used to support my viewpoint.

Religion is a part of culture, usually a very important part!

Originally posted by: Ankithate

Religion is a part of culture, usually a very important part!

And vice versa.

The TM asked the viewers if incest was a sin or not.

And my response to that is.

Yes, it's a sin. I find the act objectionable.

Originally posted by: -Xaffron-

The TM asked the viewers if incest was a sin or not.

And my response to that is.

Yes, it's a sin. I find the act objectionable.

Yaa , It May Be Sin According To You Pov .
But You POV is Based On Religion And Culture ,
and culture and religion is contradict in itself and hypocrite in nature !

Originally posted by: Ankithate

Yaa , It May Be Sin According To You Pov .
But You POV is Based On Religion And Culture ,
and culture and religion is contradict in itself and hypocrite in nature !

Why do you ask for peoples' opinions on a 'public platform' when you can't handle them? I'd respectfully posed in my opinion to your query. If you find someone's views as hypocritical, so be it. People are entitled to their opinions, aren't they? You can't be expecting people to think like you do. I was asked to pose an opinion. What and how does it matter what it's based on. Sorry that you couldn't hear what you wanted to.

Regards!

Originally posted by: -Xaffron-

Why do you ask for peoples' opinions on a 'public platform' when you can't handle them? I'd respectfully posed in my opinion to your query. If you find someone's views as hypocritical, so be it. People are entitled to their opinions, aren't they? You can't be expecting people to think like you. I was asked to pose an opinion. What and how does it matter what it's based on. Sorry that you couldn't hear what you wanted to.

Regards!

its a debate mension , if you are saying a point that too incest is a sin coz of religion and culture !

i didnt ask qustion on that why u are saying , i just told you that your points are just on basis of religon ,
if tomorow our social society accepts it and religion accept it , you will be ok with that and at that time you will be not calling it SIN !