why is communism wrong? - Page 9

Originally posted by: karandel_2008

I at least provided a link and wikipedia quotes PricewaterhouseCoopers.
If you know a better link then provide it to us. Till then we have to assume it to be correct.

Anyway there are 2 points:

- Statistics say that Kolkata has higher GDP than some other metro cities

Here, I am asking you what could be better metric according to you?

- on why Kolkata has higher GDP? I can attempt it but is GDP an ok metric according to you?

Originally posted by: Xinit

You cannot assume anything by giving an unreliable source from wikipedia. 🥱

Higher gdp of kolkata compared to what?

The other metros of India🤔

Originally posted by: Xinit

You cannot assume anything by giving an unreliable source from wikipedia. 🥱

Besides, according to wikipedia.. 😊 kerela has the highest crime rate in India. So much for social equiality and prosperity there... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_in_India

And kerela has higher gdp compared to what?

Wikipedia is not always unreliable. You can look at other links as well.

2005

http://www.citymayors.com/statistics/richest-cities-2005.html


more recent
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/Economy/Surat_tops_GDP_race_at_115/articleshow/2736233.cms

anyway to answer my own question. Another factor is GDP growth.

If Kolkata's GDP after british left is GDPi and its GDPf now. Then we may look at the effect of communism by looking at (GDPf -GDPi)/GDPi and comparing the same with other cities.

Originally posted by: debayon

The other metros of India🤔

Originally posted by: Xinit

You cannot assume anything by giving an unreliable source from wikipedia. 🥱

Higher gdp of kolkata compared to what? You started this statement, so burden of proof lies with you.

I gave you other links above.

Originally posted by: karandel_2008

I gave you other links above.

Originally posted by: Xinit

Which are?

New Delhi, Mumbai, Bangalore, Chennai, Hyderabad and Kolkata.

Originally posted by: debayon

New Delhi, Mumbai, Bangalore, Chennai, Hyderabad and Kolkata.

@Debu: He is just asking questions. When you answer he asks more questions. Everyone knows this is a trapping technique. because question after question there is a limit to the answers.

@Xinit: To be fair you have to answer some questions as well. or show some other reliable statistics.

Originally posted by: Xinit

And you are claiming that Kolkata is doing better than all of them?

Stop beating around the bush and say what you have to say.