Why is Feminist a negative word? - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

75

Views

7.6k

Users

19

Likes

70

Frequent Posters

3365 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: angie.4u

I fully agree with this ! 😊 creating level field is the logical solution instead of reservation whether for females or SC/ST. I wish our politicians as well as the public realise this so that they can take appropriate steps to adress the problem in a logical way . Level playing field is what we shud be concentrating on. That also means providing equal opportunities by means of adequate training .The tricky part is how to convince some parents to allow their daughters equal opportunities at par with their sons.😉 😆



exactly. this is what i have been saying and he is conveniently ignoring. i am not saying that something should not be done to bring equality, but how? for me till the time the mind set of people could be changed whats so wrong in making as many women as possible self relaint. 🤢
3365 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#42
Edited by angelic_devil - 16 years ago
souro thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#43
[quote=angelic_devil]
exactly. this is what i have been saying and he is conveniently ignoring. i am not saying that something should not be done to bring equality, but how? for me till the time the mind set of people could be changed whats so wrong in making as many women as possible self relaint.
[/quote]
I'm not ignoring what you said, I was giving alternative solution. I said make education till higher secndary level mandatory for everyone and if any parent fails to send their children to school then punish the parents. Even if you send one of the parent to prison for 1 month, it will deter most people from obstructing a girl child from going to school.

Originally posted by: angelic_devil


education is already free for poor, but still only boys r sent to study not girls, specially in villages and the law an order is also with them so making it compulsory also doesn't help. there r so many laws against dowry, domestic violence but does it work? no.
but making women self reliant will slowly and steadily built confidence in women and people like this will be forced to change their mentality.
besides i dont think there is any need to give free education to boys bcoz as u said anyone will come with fake documents and demand free education and the really needy once dont get it.

thank you.😊

But without tackling corruption you can't do much with reservation alone. And best way to stop corruption is to teach everyone the proper things, having strict laws and implementing those laws.
If you simply provide reservation the women in cities who are already treated as equal will be able to go ahead and grab those seats. But what about those girls who live in some obscure village. What I mean to say is the idea of reservation will just help the already self reliant city women to avoid competition. I can't understand how it is going to help the women of villages in becoming self reliant, because they fail to make it to school to begin with. And without any education, how can they be made self reliant.
I was only concentrating on one thing, quality education should be provided to all and laws should be placed to see that noone is deprived of their rights. Because in my opinion, that can end corruption, disrespect, inequality and several other problems and all will be able to walk on their own without needing the support of reservation.
return_to_hades thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 16 years ago
#44
I had posted a good reply last night, but IF was having errors and it got lost in cyberspace. I feel too lazy now.
3365 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#46


i will just sum it all now abt reservation, as we have zeroed to only on aspect which u think is a priviledge for women. oh BTW u said that women get priviledge, but did not give a single example and this reservation is something women have not even got till now.
there r two main reason for so less ratio of educated women.
1. financial- where parents dont have enough money to educate both girls and boys.
2. intentionally not sending girls to schools and colleges.
in both the case women need to be provided free education in govt schools and colleges and reservation quota should also be provided.
this will make more and more women independent and they wont have to rely on orthdox parents and husband and will slowly and gradually also change the mentality of people.

return_to_hades thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 16 years ago
#47
Masculinism is what we need. The equality of sexes can only be achieved through masculinism.
Roadrunnerz thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: return_to_hades

Masculinism is what we need. The equality of sexes can only be achieved through masculinism.

whats wrong with feminism of both sexes ? The world may just turn out to be more peaceful & beautiful 😉
souro thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: angelic_devil



i will just sum it all now abt reservation, as we have zeroed to only on aspect which u think is a priviledge for women. oh BTW u said that women get priviledge, but did not give a single example and this reservation is something women have not even got till now.
I didn't say that women get privileges, I said they shouldn't ask for privileges.

there r two main reason for so less ratio of educated women.
1. financial- where parents dont have enough money to educate both girls and boys.
2. intentionally not sending girls to schools and colleges.
in both the case women need to be provided free education in govt schools and colleges and reservation quota should also be provided.
this will make more and more women independent and they wont have to rely on orthdox parents and husband and will slowly and gradually also change the mentality of people.

I've already said about free and mandatory education and laws to see that noone is deprived of their rights. They have already helped women in other countries achieve equality then why can't it work in India.
One more thing, I have everytime written that proper education should be given. At present although education is free in Govt. schools but most schools have a very poor education system and students are left to seek private tuitions, which unnecessarily burdens their parents. That shouldn't be the case. Everything should be taught at school including values.
If these are not there reservation won't be of any help to make the rest of the 47% women and about 30% men educated.

Edited by souro - 16 years ago
3365 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: souro


only bcoz education till HSSC is permitted are girls educated till that level. very few parents send their girls to college. so its not a rare case but a very comman scenario. and i dont expect a girls to revolt the whole family at the age of 17-18 to go to college. u only said it can fetch them a good job to earn and study on their own. so i dont think this is going to work.not even in urban areas let alone rural. thats the reason i am all for reservation.
Yes I said that only education till higher secondary is not helpful in getting a good job but I also said how it can help in increasing the rate of girls making it to college. when parents r not willing to send their girls to schools only then y will they pay for more expensive education in college?

You were only favouring reservation from the very beginning of the debate and didn't speak about anything else much. At present only about 53% women are educated, so if you introduce reservation, it will surely help these 53% women but will do little else to make the other 47% educated.
thats b coz u have been concentrating on reservation only. bcoz as per my knowledge its less. and u know whats the defination of literrate for these stats? person who can read write, basic education only. not enough to get jobs right.


In 1901 India only had 5% literate population and in 1911 it was 11%. Now we've a little above 70% men who are educated and 53% women. If men were only trying to avoid competition then educated men would've tried to stop both men and women from getting educated. But sane minded people are trying to educate all of them.
yes and sane minded people only proposed reservation for women.

I agree with the part that parents not allowing a child to study or work is a problem. Which is what I believe can be overcome by educating all, making education mandatory and making it punishable to obstruct anyone's education. and also provide reservation. for explanation refer to the above posts.
What I asked you earlier was, if someone is not interested in educating his/her children, then whether there is reservation or no reservation, how is that going to change their mind.
and i said more and more women being educated and self reliant will compel these people to change their mind set .dont u think mindset has been changed, bcoz of women being educated and earning?


That is because the number of educated people itself was low and in our society men were typically seen as bread winners making it their responsibility to venture out more (and you have to keep in mind that venturing out is a lot more safer now than what it used to be earlier). and so was cooking food and the rate of women dieing giving birth to soooooooooo many babies was very very high. so dont say that men did all the work and women used to sit their AC rooms and eat grapes. earlier the work was divided and now its 75 done by women and 25% by men. and dont say men help at house equally bcoz i will only agree to it if they make the meal half the time and so on.
As more and more people are getting educated more women are getting employed and they are moving up the ladder at work.
well they r and giving reservation will accelerate it.

Yes men are so cunning that they agreed that the society needs a change. Even before the feminist movement started there were cunning men trying to help women gain equal status in society. All those fathers who now want their daughters to be well educated are really cunning. All the male HRs who hired female employees were also very cunning.
a few , a handful of them did i dont deny it. had it not been for the initiative of those few women would still be the same as in 16th century. just tell me one thing y r there not girls at the top levels? and y there so less girls in IIT and IIM and other top colleges? and y r there so less business women and politicians in this world?and there r also HRs(male and female) who do not give jobs to women saying they will marry soon, they leave from work early,taek more leaves, they gossip more(like u said).


I didn't say that women get privileges, I said they shouldn't ask for privileges.
and what priviledges did they ask?

I've already said about free and mandatory education and laws to see that none is deprived of their rights. They have already helped women in other countries achieve equality then why can't it work in India.
and i already stated that there wont be any complaints only and even if there r there wont be actions. this is how it works in india.
One more thing, I have everytime written that proper education should be given. At present although education is free in Govt. schools but most schools have a very poor education system and students are left to seek private tuitions, which unnecessarily burdens their parents. That shouldn't be the case. Everything should be taught at school including values.
If these are not there reservation won't be of any help to make the rest of the 47% women and about 30% men educated.

53% is just women who can read and write, not those who have done graduation. these women cannot get jobs and compete. and BTW gap of 25% appx. is still very high.

Edited by angelic_devil - 16 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".